2:30 in the afternoon during business hours and no answer after calling twice...hey, I get people can be busy...but it's 2:30 on a Thursday in Broken Arrow...and nothing. Called Uncle Vinny's and they answered 1st call during their posted business hours. Guess I'll get a white at Vinny's instead. First time to try Jimmy's and already disappointed before I could even order.
Matthew Doss
This place brought back great memories of going out to eat with my grandparents, who loved authentic NY-style pizza. The pizza here is spot on—delicious, fresh, and full of flavor. We started with garlic knots, which were perfectly baked and packed with garlicky goodness. For dessert, my wife enjoyed the chocolate chip cannolis, which were absolutely fantastic. Portions were generous, and the prices were very reasonable for the quality and quantity of food.
Christina Jones
great place! great service!
Leah Michelle Garoutte
This place is delicious! The pizza is best fresh out, but also good to go!! The sauce on the pasta IS THE BEST I'VE HAD IN MY LIFE! If you want real Italian food, this is it. The owners are the sweetest people!
Rick Palmer
Amazing customer service, and even better pizza! Had a great first experience with the new BA location. Will definitely be our new go-to pizza spot.
Briana Dalton
Tried Jimmy’s today for the first time (ba location) and it did not disappoint! My friend and i split the “Margherita” on our lunch break and it’s all i can think about this evening. The store was clean and the staff were super friendly. Will definitely be back… probably tomorrow haha
Henry David Diaz
The worst attention I have received in a restaurant, I placed an order at 4:44 pm (two pizzas) it was 6:00 pm and even the pizzas were not done, I asked the boy at the checkout how much longer should I wait for the pizzas and his answer was: i don’t know, if you want your pizza you must wait and if not you can cancel your order. In the end I canceled the order because they have no idea how to treat a customer. In addition, it seems to me an exaggeration that for two simple pizzas I should wait more than 1 hour and 20 minutes, however, one as a person can understand that the restaurant is very busy but if so, they should at least give a polite treatment to the customer, It was very unfortunate not being able to eat my pizzas since they really are very good in that place.
M Kennicottii
This is easily the very BEST pizzeria in Tulsa. Family owned and operated. (Husband, wife and son.) They're extremely friendly, and it feels like you're eating with family.Everything is made fresh: the dough, the sauces, etc. The toppings are also fresh, flavorful and delicious! The crust is to die for. Classic New York style pizza.The restaurant is comfortable and well lit as well as cleverly decorated.While the pizza is the main event here, you'd been missing out if you didn't try the stromboli or the fried cheese cake! It's absolutely amazing.
Rachel Feeley
We've been coming to Jimmy's since it was in the Tulsa location because it is HANDS DOWN the BEST NY style pizza in town, state, southern US.Jimmy & his wife and family are the nicest people making amazing food. Get yourself some pizza from Jimmy's Pizzeria!
Hunter Stark
Always great from the food to the service! People who actually care not just about making money but building customer relationships. All around amazing food and people. 100% recommended you won't be sorry!
First timer-I ordered a slice of pepperoni. They hooked me up with a fresh slice really quickly. The slices are big and worth the money. Highly recommend.
Leah Doughty
We found Jimmy's by happy accident and I am so glad we did. Their pizza is AMAZING! We've eaten here a few times and have gone out of our way to eat here too. Definitely worth it every time. The Manhattan Meat is so good and I LOVE the Bronx Chicken Alfredo. If you have any room left after eating the pizza you should try the Cannoli. We'll be back Jimmy. Thanks for another great meal!
Emma Francois
Most delicious (and authentic!!) pizza in Tulsa! Slices as big as your head that ALWAYS are delicious and mouthwatering. The staff is always so kind and always willing to go the extra mile. Can’t recommend this amazing place enough!
Karl T
Felt like Bob s burger s but with Pizza. Great establishment. Very friendly and a family setting. Stromboli was amazing. Crispy on the outside and a cheese pull that makes a great selfie! Forget bout it!
hannah Rodriguez
My husband and i have been going to Jimmys since they opened! The quality doesn't disappoint! The customer service is also amazing! He makes us feel like family, i had jaw surgery 9/13/2021 and he went out of his way to make sure i was able to eat and enjoy the meal! I recommend jimmys if you want an amazing family atmosphere and great quality ?
2:30 in the afternoon during business hours and no answer after calling twice...hey, I get people can be busy...but it's 2:30 on a Thursday in Broken Arrow...and nothing. Called Uncle Vinny's and they answered 1st call during their posted business hours. Guess I'll get a white at Vinny's instead. First time to try Jimmy's and already disappointed before I could even order.
This place brought back great memories of going out to eat with my grandparents, who loved authentic NY-style pizza. The pizza here is spot on—delicious, fresh, and full of flavor. We started with garlic knots, which were perfectly baked and packed with garlicky goodness. For dessert, my wife enjoyed the chocolate chip cannolis, which were absolutely fantastic. Portions were generous, and the prices were very reasonable for the quality and quantity of food.
great place! great service!
This place is delicious! The pizza is best fresh out, but also good to go!! The sauce on the pasta IS THE BEST I'VE HAD IN MY LIFE! If you want real Italian food, this is it. The owners are the sweetest people!
Amazing customer service, and even better pizza! Had a great first experience with the new BA location. Will definitely be our new go-to pizza spot.
Tried Jimmy’s today for the first time (ba location) and it did not disappoint! My friend and i split the “Margherita” on our lunch break and it’s all i can think about this evening. The store was clean and the staff were super friendly. Will definitely be back… probably tomorrow haha
The worst attention I have received in a restaurant, I placed an order at 4:44 pm (two pizzas) it was 6:00 pm and even the pizzas were not done, I asked the boy at the checkout how much longer should I wait for the pizzas and his answer was: i don’t know, if you want your pizza you must wait and if not you can cancel your order. In the end I canceled the order because they have no idea how to treat a customer. In addition, it seems to me an exaggeration that for two simple pizzas I should wait more than 1 hour and 20 minutes, however, one as a person can understand that the restaurant is very busy but if so, they should at least give a polite treatment to the customer, It was very unfortunate not being able to eat my pizzas since they really are very good in that place.
This is easily the very BEST pizzeria in Tulsa. Family owned and operated. (Husband, wife and son.) They're extremely friendly, and it feels like you're eating with family.Everything is made fresh: the dough, the sauces, etc. The toppings are also fresh, flavorful and delicious! The crust is to die for. Classic New York style pizza.The restaurant is comfortable and well lit as well as cleverly decorated.While the pizza is the main event here, you'd been missing out if you didn't try the stromboli or the fried cheese cake! It's absolutely amazing.
We've been coming to Jimmy's since it was in the Tulsa location because it is HANDS DOWN the BEST NY style pizza in town, state, southern US.Jimmy & his wife and family are the nicest people making amazing food. Get yourself some pizza from Jimmy's Pizzeria!
Always great from the food to the service! People who actually care not just about making money but building customer relationships. All around amazing food and people. 100% recommended you won't be sorry!
Restaurantji Recommends
First timer-I ordered a slice of pepperoni. They hooked me up with a fresh slice really quickly. The slices are big and worth the money. Highly recommend.
We found Jimmy's by happy accident and I am so glad we did. Their pizza is AMAZING! We've eaten here a few times and have gone out of our way to eat here too. Definitely worth it every time. The Manhattan Meat is so good and I LOVE the Bronx Chicken Alfredo. If you have any room left after eating the pizza you should try the Cannoli. We'll be back Jimmy. Thanks for another great meal!
Most delicious (and authentic!!) pizza in Tulsa! Slices as big as your head that ALWAYS are delicious and mouthwatering. The staff is always so kind and always willing to go the extra mile. Can’t recommend this amazing place enough!
Felt like Bob s burger s but with Pizza. Great establishment. Very friendly and a family setting. Stromboli was amazing. Crispy on the outside and a cheese pull that makes a great selfie! Forget bout it!
My husband and i have been going to Jimmys since they opened! The quality doesn't disappoint! The customer service is also amazing! He makes us feel like family, i had jaw surgery 9/13/2021 and he went out of his way to make sure i was able to eat and enjoy the meal! I recommend jimmys if you want an amazing family atmosphere and great quality ?
Loading...