Jimmy's New York Pizzeria

7123 S 92nd E Ave, Tulsa
(918) 252-0333

Recent Reviews

Deyra Campos

If you want good quality pizza from a family man, come too Jimmy's!- great taste my kids are addicted!

Nunya Beezness

Outstanding. My wife and I are from Connecticut and would visit NYC all the time just for pizza. Jimmy's has it going on, as awesome if not better than the taste we grew up enjoying. Thank you guys!!!

Carrie C.

Went a few times ALWAYS GREAT. Everything has amazing flavor and staff is always above and beyond. You have to try this you will be hooked too.

Anonny M.

Best pizza in town! If you can't get to NYC, this is the next best thing. Very friendly employees. If you prefer greasy, slimey Pizza But, this isn't for you.

Kristi O.

Really great pizza. The garlic knots are so incredible. Their pasta is probably my favorite thing but you really can't go wrong with this place.

Karen Kendall

Hot, fresh and always good. Staff are friendly, yet professional. Recommend this highly. You won't be disappointed.

Logan / Gursh

This is New York City pizza. I’ve been to New York several times and had all the famous places and this is right up there with them. Great for just a slice or full pizza. It’s worth every penny and any early onset diabetes.

Mallissa Cruse

Hands down, the best Pizza you'll find in Oklahoma. The food is made with love, this I have no doubt in!!! Jimmy and his family are genuine, kind people. And the pizza..... my oh, my. Finally tried other dishes they have and was more than happy. Everything they make there is so damn delicious. Also, I could drink the cannoli filling they make. ?

Andrew Perez

This place is amazing. This NOT “New York Style Pizza”, this is New York Pizza....PERIOD!!! Great food, and excellent customer service. Owner cares about his employees, his guests, and food quality. Thanks Jimmy, I’ll be back for sure.

Shirley Hood

Love this Pizza !! We have looked for several years to find a place that makes the "Perfect White Pizza" Well the "Staten Island White" I add spinach & mushrooms but that's me. Is an amazing Pizza, I hope they are here for many, many years treat yourself get a slice very soon !!

Mary Moe

Best. Pizza. Ever. I picked up 2 slices and some garlic rolls today. The slices are HUGE and the best I've had! We will be back a lot more!

Ashley R.

This place is fire the pepperoni roll was my favorite, but maybe a lil expensive for just one but I'll pay it! I mean I should probably not eat 3 at one time anyways lol Also with my order I got the cheese knots and those too were amazing. I will be coming back!

Zack P.

I check reviews on google and Jimmy's has a great rating. I placed an order for pickup for my office. We got the Manhattan Meat and some garlic knots. Both were very hot and fresh and tasted amazing. The garlic knots have TONS of garlic. So good. My office has unanimously agreed that we will start getting our pizza from Jimmy's.

Aleks Aleks

it's a nice place with excellent service but the pizza slice hasn't impressed me much. i had Manhattan and it was a greasy mess, crust is too thin for that amount of grease, everything got saturated with grease. flavor is ordinary and basic, not worth the price. i liked the place and staff.


Went in without knowing anything about this place, the Pizza is authentic, one of the best in town and definitely worth a visit. Once inside you find that a family owns and operates it. They are all friendly, responsive and enjoyable to speak with. My favorite (so far) is the Staten Island White, oh my this is awesome.

Load More