It's one of our favorite restaurants in Tulsa. Excellent bar staff that knows how to consistently make refreshing drinks. Professional wait staff makes every meal a delightful experience. The meals are both visually appetizing and delicious. A perfect atmosphere for fine dining.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Escargots, Cold Water Lobster Tail, Caesar Salad
Tom Nickell
Easter brunch has become a tradition for us. Great food, great selection, great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill R. Bland
Always wonderful! Excellent food. Great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Spencer Ashworth
I have enjoyed McGill’s to go service multiple times in my life but after tonight , they will never be bothered with my patronage. I called to make a to go order as I have multiple times on Friday nights for ages. After a lengthy moment of being placed on hold , I was told that because their main dining room was busy, they would not be taking to go orders. Let me be perfectly clear. You either offer to go service or you don’t. You don’t get to choose when you turn it on or off. You either appreciate the to go business or you don’t. We are unable to eat in the dining room at times and look forward to meals to go when that happens. I called back to speak to someone about this as this glaring inconsistency in service offerings needed to be addressed. They gave me David. He is the General Manager and really missed the mark .His handling of my 2nd call and the owners refusal to talk to me is what ultimately led to this review as their actions or lack there of to be held accountable is too much to go unsaid. At some point David talked to the owner. He came back on the phone saying that he and I quote “I don’t want to take your to order but will anyway…” How dare you David! You and the owner who hid behind you instead of taking heat for their decision need to know that they are literally surrounded by 5-6 steakhouses that are 100% accepting of to go orders at all times. You insulted me twice in one night. I am beyond disappointed in the actions that occurred tonight .Heads up to all patrons that this experience at McGills proves where they rate the priority of their to go service and customers who might need service at a time not conducive to McGills liking. I have never felt like a second rate class of customer in my life until trying to eat at McGills To Go tonight. PS. Ruth Chris made a great to go meal tonight and I could really tell they where appreciative even though they were actually busier than McGills. I’ll probably give Mahogany’s To Go a shot next. Good luck.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
kaldaus Bazarian
Great food but quite expensive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion
S N
The service was outstanding, but I found the food to be mediocre for the price. My Ribeye was cooked perfectly, but the flavor was substandard for a high caliber restaurant such as McGill's.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari
Shelley Murphy
Love the patio. We take our Pugs in their strollers. Wait staff is wonderful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cobb Salad, Caesar Salad, French Onion
Dick Hankins
Only reason not perfect is the insanely high prices. Everything was over the top. Leyla was the best server I've had in years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Cakes
Gerry M.
If I could rate this restaurant with a NEGATIVE ZERO STAR I would!!!!!! Friends and family please don't waste your hard earned money on this place! It was me and my husband's 37th anniversary tonight. We made reservations for the McGill's above hard rock but decided to go to the one closer to where we live. After all, we thought they were a franchise just to find out the original one (yale) is the crappy one. After telling our server THREE times about our anniversary he apologized each time and said he would let the manager know. My husband ordered the NY strip and couldn't even eat it because it had no seasoning, lobster tail? BLAND, soup? WATERY, the only thing that was appetizing was the BREAD!!!! Our server, (bless his heart!) Told us that the food there isn't great at all and way over priced. For someone working for this hell hole he sure did lay down some facts!!! The plates looked disgusting and our drinks arrived after getting our food packaged up. We complained to 2 other servers who looked like they had a couple of drinks themselves (probably ours) and they apologized as well. After we paid the bill, we were expecting a complimentary dessert which my friend who visits there quite often says that they do those kind of things. Nothing was offered, servers moved like they were high or drunk.....and food was terrible!!! The manager came right after we were getting up to apologize but we saved all of them the crap and got the heck out of there!!! I had to call my friend to tell her about the experience as well. When we got home my husband noticed that they misspelled the handwritten course on the to-go box. I kid you not! Instead of "NY Strip" our server wrote "NY Stripe" that should say enough. Long story short neither one of us will ever go there nor recommend this place to anyone!! Please just go to Mahogany's or better yet the BETTER McGills on the hard rock casino. McGill's y'all better count your days.
The ambiance and food was great. Service was friendly and attentive. The price for food was high, but average for the same food around. I would definitely come here again for special occasions. Not a place I would regularly dine. That doesn't mean it wasn't a great experience, though.
This was my second time visiting the restaurant the food was delicious, the atmosphere very nice and the service was very professional. I just hate that we didn't take
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Lobster
Fabio
Always good in past, but took a while to click into their system. You would think that the servers would all be clued in to not keep walking past customers just sitting there at a bare table.
Chris Harmon
Always a great experience. Great food and service in a wonderful atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blue Cheese Cream Sauce Strip Steak, Lobster Pasta
Fritzi P.
Great ambiance, knowledgeable and excellent wait staff and delicious food! Great for a romantic evening or joining friends.
Average high end food. Steak was smaller than normal 7oz fillet and bacon wrapped. One lobster tail was $79. Calamari had little seasoning. Overall good date night with my wife and knew I was spending $200 but food could have been better. I miss Dallas. Probably spoiled on their great steak and seafood scene.
It's one of our favorite restaurants in Tulsa. Excellent bar staff that knows how to consistently make refreshing drinks. Professional wait staff makes every meal a delightful experience. The meals are both visually appetizing and delicious. A perfect atmosphere for fine dining.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Escargots, Cold Water Lobster Tail, Caesar Salad
Easter brunch has become a tradition for us. Great food, great selection, great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always wonderful! Excellent food. Great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have enjoyed McGill’s to go service multiple times in my life but after tonight , they will never be bothered with my patronage. I called to make a to go order as I have multiple times on Friday nights for ages. After a lengthy moment of being placed on hold , I was told that because their main dining room was busy, they would not be taking to go orders. Let me be perfectly clear. You either offer to go service or you don’t. You don’t get to choose when you turn it on or off. You either appreciate the to go business or you don’t. We are unable to eat in the dining room at times and look forward to meals to go when that happens. I called back to speak to someone about this as this glaring inconsistency in service offerings needed to be addressed. They gave me David. He is the General Manager and really missed the mark .His handling of my 2nd call and the owners refusal to talk to me is what ultimately led to this review as their actions or lack there of to be held accountable is too much to go unsaid. At some point David talked to the owner. He came back on the phone saying that he and I quote “I don’t want to take your to order but will anyway…” How dare you David! You and the owner who hid behind you instead of taking heat for their decision need to know that they are literally surrounded by 5-6 steakhouses that are 100% accepting of to go orders at all times. You insulted me twice in one night. I am beyond disappointed in the actions that occurred tonight .Heads up to all patrons that this experience at McGills proves where they rate the priority of their to go service and customers who might need service at a time not conducive to McGills liking. I have never felt like a second rate class of customer in my life until trying to eat at McGills To Go tonight. PS. Ruth Chris made a great to go meal tonight and I could really tell they where appreciative even though they were actually busier than McGills. I’ll probably give Mahogany’s To Go a shot next. Good luck.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great food but quite expensive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion
The service was outstanding, but I found the food to be mediocre for the price. My Ribeye was cooked perfectly, but the flavor was substandard for a high caliber restaurant such as McGill's.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari
Love the patio. We take our Pugs in their strollers. Wait staff is wonderful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cobb Salad, Caesar Salad, French Onion
Only reason not perfect is the insanely high prices. Everything was over the top. Leyla was the best server I've had in years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Cakes
If I could rate this restaurant with a NEGATIVE ZERO STAR I would!!!!!! Friends and family please don't waste your hard earned money on this place! It was me and my husband's 37th anniversary tonight. We made reservations for the McGill's above hard rock but decided to go to the one closer to where we live. After all, we thought they were a franchise just to find out the original one (yale) is the crappy one. After telling our server THREE times about our anniversary he apologized each time and said he would let the manager know. My husband ordered the NY strip and couldn't even eat it because it had no seasoning, lobster tail? BLAND, soup? WATERY, the only thing that was appetizing was the BREAD!!!! Our server, (bless his heart!) Told us that the food there isn't great at all and way over priced. For someone working for this hell hole he sure did lay down some facts!!! The plates looked disgusting and our drinks arrived after getting our food packaged up. We complained to 2 other servers who looked like they had a couple of drinks themselves (probably ours) and they apologized as well. After we paid the bill, we were expecting a complimentary dessert which my friend who visits there quite often says that they do those kind of things. Nothing was offered, servers moved like they were high or drunk.....and food was terrible!!! The manager came right after we were getting up to apologize but we saved all of them the crap and got the heck out of there!!! I had to call my friend to tell her about the experience as well. When we got home my husband noticed that they misspelled the handwritten course on the to-go box. I kid you not! Instead of "NY Strip" our server wrote "NY Stripe" that should say enough. Long story short neither one of us will ever go there nor recommend this place to anyone!! Please just go to Mahogany's or better yet the BETTER McGills on the hard rock casino. McGill's y'all better count your days.
The ambiance and food was great. Service was friendly and attentive. The price for food was high, but average for the same food around. I would definitely come here again for special occasions. Not a place I would regularly dine. That doesn't mean it wasn't a great experience, though.
Restaurantji Recommends
This was my second time visiting the restaurant the food was delicious, the atmosphere very nice and the service was very professional. I just hate that we didn't take
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Lobster
Always good in past, but took a while to click into their system. You would think that the servers would all be clued in to not keep walking past customers just sitting there at a bare table.
Always a great experience. Great food and service in a wonderful atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blue Cheese Cream Sauce Strip Steak, Lobster Pasta
Great ambiance, knowledgeable and excellent wait staff and delicious food! Great for a romantic evening or joining friends.
Average high end food. Steak was smaller than normal 7oz fillet and bacon wrapped. One lobster tail was $79. Calamari had little seasoning. Overall good date night with my wife and knew I was spending $200 but food could have been better. I miss Dallas. Probably spoiled on their great steak and seafood scene.