New York Bagel Cafe

3723 S Peoria Ave, Tulsa
(918) 743-7400

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Paige S

So good! We stayed in Tulsa for 5 days and ate here almost every morning. I wish we had this place local to us!

Jennifer Smith

Great atmosphere unique location delicious flavor combinations. Yum!! Friendly service

Joseph Clark

I came here with the family. we had a great time. the food was amazing and the staff were friendly. the atmosphere here was perfect to enjoy. I definitely recommend this place.

Andrew

Great Tulsa restaurant. The Brookside bagel shop has better service than the one on Yale. Super place to get breakfast or lunch.

Jessica Winnie

Love that there is a drive thru! However, there was no line inside. So, I went on in! The pecan roll is delicious! I don't know how they can afford to cram the top of the roll with so much goodness! Chopped pecan pieces were falling off into the yeah! The pecans have just enough sweetness to be a topping and not overloaded with sugar. Almost had a light/airy feel to them yet still candy like. Not overwhelming, though. The roll was soft and not doughy with hints of cinamon. Next timeI will get it warmed up. I also had the Lemon Poppy Seed muffin, and it was very, very moist.. Almost cake like. The muffin top was delicious. Staff was friendly. They also have an array of hotsauces/bbq on the shelf. There is plenty of indoor seating.

Star

I tried cookies from here awhile ago and they were great! My second time stopping in and I was disappointed. The cashier was unpleasant. The gluten free bagel sandwich was like cardboard and the cinnamon bun was dry. On the plus side,the coffee tasted good and kept me awake on my long drive.

Natalie W.G.

There's no better breakfast bagel. Period. I've tried many....many many many.
Everything Jalapeño with egg and cheese 👨‍🍳💋 🤌🤌🤌

HHH Transmission

Great Breakfast Bagel.

Denise Mondor-Gavern

Love the twinkle lights on the ceiling. Good bagels and coffee. My go to bagel place on Tulsa.

Michelle Green

Great food but the service just keeps getting worse.

Cayman Seagraves

Solid lox bagel. It’s the only one I’ve tried in Tulsa, but I give it a 7/10. Great atmosphere inside. It took a little while for my bagel to come out, though. The coffee was fantastic!

Elizabeth Brown

I sent an email to the restaurant about this incident and haven’t heard back.

I went in with my twin toddlers for lunch one day. The woman working the cash register took our order and commented on how cute my twins are. I am used to be people commenting on them - it happens anytime we go out but today was the most uncomfortable I’ve ever been with it. After taking our order she followed us to the table where she continued talking about how cute they were. She asked their names and how old they were. I thought it was a bit overbearing but didn’t think much of it. She brought us our food and then walked to another table and said “have you guys seen these twins? Cutest kids ever”. Again a lot but not really concerning. After this she went to the other side of the dining area (not by the counter) and just stared at us. It started to me feel weird so we tried to eat quick. After a few minutes of this she comes back up and asks to take my twins’ picture. This was where I got incredibly creeped out. I said no you may not, thank you. She said okay and walked away and kept watching us from behind the counter and then we left.

This incident was very unprofessional and made me very uncomfortable as a mom. We will not be returning to this location.

Edited to say: I saw the reply and they have confused with someone else. My brother has never worked there - I don’t have a brother old enough to have a job😂

stuart steele

I got a meatlovers, everything bagel with cream cheese...
A lil' slice of Heaven!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Liz Dillsaver

Not old school :( the beagle but especially the coffee. Taste like hotel coffee

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Crystal Hembree

Cappuccino was shorted. I had to make an 8 oz cup of coffee at work to fill it. Seriously, over $4 for less than half a cup of cappuccino. Go for the bagels not the coffees...

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Loading...