New York Bagel Cafe

3723 S Peoria Ave, Tulsa
(918) 743-7400

Recent Reviews

Krystal West

I love the bacon, egg and cheese bagels and the mocha.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mia Navarro

Our 1st time visit and it was a great experience, and my grandkids and daughter had a blast. Everything we tried (lox bagel, pizza bagel, breakfast bagel, cream cheese plai, you pick 2, Mango Mania & Strawberry Banana smoothies and sides) was excellent, great customer service on the counter and table side. We will definitely return and recommend to friends and family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lox, Pizza Bagel, Meat Lovers on Everything Bagel, Breakfast Bagel

Emily

Awesome bagels!! Definitely check this place out, guys!!

Camryn Rought

Vegetarian options: Smoothies

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Bagel

Carrie Nelson

Worst experience, the food was not good, service terrible and quality of espresso drinks was awful. Do better. We won't be back.

Scotlin Irene

I had called them before I left to see how much a bagel was, because I know how these cafes like to up charge on the cheapest things. I call and the guy tells me “they range from $1.00-$2” basically. I go through the drive through and order JUST 3 Asiago bagels and cream cheese (because who eats a bagel without cream cheese???). Tell me why my order was $16???? Not including the tip???? As soon as I heard the drive through worker say “$16 is your total” I left the drive through line because what do you mean 3 bagels are $16???? I can go to Panera and get 3 bagels WITH cream cheese for $9….Absolutely ridiculous. The fact that the worker didn’t tell me how much the cream cheese was also pissed me off, because why would you not tell me the cream cheese is more expensive than the actual bagel??? And how does that even make sense???? I don’t know all I can say is it felt super scammy of them to not tell me when I called, and I’d rather save my money and go to Panera instead, Sorry not sorry!!!

Service: 1

Heather R

Such a great place!!! The bagels are simply the best no matter what you get!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barbara H

Both bagels that we ordered this morning were terrible.We could not eat them.It was a waste of our time and money, very

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Ashleigh Alfieri

This is crazy that I paid $12 for the keto scramble and this is what was in the container. No , I didn’t eat a single bite before I took this picture. I would have brought it back but I didn’t notice this until I was already at work about to eat it.I get this breakfast all the time and it’s always filled to the top , sometimes so much that I get full and eat the rest later. Seriously so ridiculous that I paid this much for one egg .

Food: 1

Walter Lipman

I'm a New Yorker, bred, born, raised, and a lifelong resident. When I say that this bagel shop has New York quality bagels, I mean every w word of that.Go, eat, enjoy!Vegetarian options: Scallion cream cheese, on an everything bagel!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Bagel

Jackie O.

Delicious bagels with the "everything" goodness on both the top & bottom of their bagels, all the flavors are like that!! Coffee & espresso is yummy ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Assorted Muffins and Cookies, Lox, Breakfast Bagel

Rick Fortner

Delicious bagels and a host of other deductibles! Excellent!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Assorted Muffins and Cookies, Breakfast Bagel

Roberto Corral Vazquez

Best place to work and relax. Great atmosphere, excellent food, and friendly employees!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Bagel

Jennifer Kisamore

My family go here regularly. Everything is tasty! They even give slices of bagels to our dogs when we bring them with us in the drive thru lane. Our dogs now get excited when they hear the word "bagel." Service is friendly but gets backed up on the weekends in the drive thru. I wish they had someone taking orders in the line during peak times like other drive thru places so it was ready when you get to tge window. It would help move things more quickly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Bagel

Casey Peetz

Cute bagel cafe in Tulsa. I picked up a bagel to-go for my family member. It has a lot of menu options. There's lots of cafe seating and a nice outdoor patio for better weather. The patio has a water bowl for dogs so I'd guess dogs are welcome on the patio. A good amount of parking. And it's right next to a nice green space park.

Food: 5

Load More