Onifades Cookie Company

1114 S Yale Ave, Tulsa
(918) 409-0442

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Whitney Jones

I ordered a Vegan German Chocolate Cake with ganache for my mom’s birthday. Ordering online was a breeze even though I messed up and scheduled it for the wrong date. Onifade’s was great to work with me on the pickup date and time. They were super friendly and the price was great.

The cake was absolutely decadent! There were only three of us eating so it took close to 3 weeks to finish it and it was good to the last bite!! I’m not a vegan so I’m always skeptical when I share dessert with my vegan mom. But this cake… NO regrets. It was moist, exceptionally chocolatey, and the coconut and pecan filling was to die for!

If you’re looking for a treat for a special occasion or just to eat alone in your room, I would highly recommend Onifade’s!
I’m looking forward to my next order!

Food: 5

Service: 5

S J

I cannot recommend Onifade’s Bakery highly enough. My sister and I purchased a German chocolate cake for our mom’s birthday, and it was—without exaggeration—the best German chocolate cake I have ever had.

The cake was incredibly rich and well-balanced, with a chocolate ganache that, frankly, stood out as the star. Despite how indulgent it was, I genuinely could not tell that it was vegan. The texture, flavor, and overall quality were exceptional.

Beyond the cake itself, the experience was just as wonderful. The owner/baker and mom/son duo were extremely warm, welcoming, and accommodating, which made the entire visit feel personal and special rather than transactional.

If you are looking for a bakery that delivers both outstanding flavor and genuine hospitality, Onifade’s Bakery is absolutely worth your time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tara Payne

Chef Seyi took us to Italy 🇮🇹! She made a 4-course meal for our 18th wedding anniversary. We had a prosciutto wrapped pears and cantaloupe, covered in balsamic glaze and pecans, scrumptious focaccia and rye bread, beautiful Italian salad, oso bucco with mushroom risotto and honey glazed carrots and Italian cake with a yummy icing for dessert. Because we aren’t big drinkers she made us a hibiscus tea. 😋 Best meal EVER, and she came to our home to do it.
Thank you for making this anniversary celebration so memorable.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lindsay Gay

DELICIOUS SWEET TREAT!
We had the vegan chocolate chip cookie and a strawberry white chocolate cookie along with some vegan, vanilla ice cream!
10/10, will definitely be going back!
I crumbled my cookie on top of my ice cream which I highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark

I knew mr onifade for 9 months so far and he's the most kind and generous dude I know he has changed my perspective on things I hope he thrives in whatever he does when hes older

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip

Tiffany Lau

I had the chance to try some cookies at Freedomfest and I wish I had bought more. I got a smores, chocolate chip, and a butter cookie. My kids ate the cookies so fast I didn’t get a chance to try the chocolate chip or butter cookies but the smores cookie was perfection. They were also gracious and gave me a chocolate cupcake to celebrate my birthday. It was just the right amount of sweetness and fluffiness on the icing and cake. I can’t wait to make a trip to the store to see what else I can try. No photos as all the goodies were gone so fast 🤗

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Megan “Meg”

They are doing the Tulsa 30 day Vegan Challenge so I ordered 1 of each option which is a Strawberry cookie, a lemon cookie, and a blackberry cobbler. They have pop up locations that they sell their brand at or you can place a order for pickup/delivery. It's probably easier to have them deliver because otherwise it gets a little complicated due to GPS directions. The packaging is cute, friendly service, and now let's get down to the taste... Oh my my my goodness YUMMY! The cobbler is seasoned with hints of cinnamon and a good amount of blackberries. The cobbler crust crumbles and melts in your mouth. The cookies are thick and crunchy on the outside and chewy soft in the middle.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rahul Yadav

Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amber Garnett

This location is permanently closed.

Penquin402

I knew Onifade when I worked at the Y and remember him selling his cookies around the school and through word of mouth. I went to the cookie store a few months ago and his cookies are still great! I got his Brownie cookie and it was so good. If you get the chance to go there I highly recommend that you do. Onifade's mom is super nice.

Vegetarian options: They offer vegan cookies.

Dietary restrictions: Organic cookies that taste delicious.

Kid-friendliness: My brother-in-law takes my nieces there all the time and they love it. The staff is friendly towards kids.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anson C

Closed at 2 pm on Wednesday , hours say they should be open

Jumal Harrigan

The cookies and Ice cream were excellent perfect Treats in the summer heat.

Clinton

Fantastic, everything was wonderful!! Very friendly, I love local owned businesses!

Jeneva Lynn

I tried the S’mores cookie he was testing and it was AMAZING! So creative and delicious and such a cool place! The ice cream and brownie cookie was amazing too!!

Emmalee Stailey

We got a 1/2 dozen cookies. They are all SO GOOD!!! We will definitely be back!!

Loading...