Prairie Fire Pie

1303 E 15th St, Tulsa
(918) 895-8725

Recent Reviews

Emily MacKenzie

The restaurant atmosphere was nice and the service was good. We found that the pizza itself was extremely salty, likely the dough, so it’s not something we’ll be returning for.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Kenny Campos

Amazing pizza and drinks. Would highly recommend this place for groups looking for a fun night

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daya White

I love this place! This is definitely a hidden gem! Spencer takes care of me everytime! He is very talkative and always encouraging me to try new things. Ever since I’ve went I have told everyone about this place!?

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Carbonara

Hope WILKERSON

Wonderful hostess and wait staff! Loved Spencer behind the bar. He makes the yummiest drinks! Try the cauliflower and Kale salad if your wanting to eat lighter. ?Delish!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Horn

We went to an early dinner on a Sunday afternoon. Food and drink options were all pretty fantastic. We had three flavors of chicken wings, of which our favorites were the Five Spice wings. The baked fontina was wonderful. Service was good and attentive.Parking: There is a multi-business parking lot across 15th, and another behind the business just north on Peoria. There is no parking in front of the business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crispy Chicken Wings

Ray Osborn (TheRaysistance)

As if the service and food weren't completely over the top, the cost made my jaw drop. We arrived during happy hour and had two appetizers and two pizzas with soda to drink and spent less than 40 bucks which equated to more money to leave as a tip.We started with some fontina and an order of mearballs. I swear I could've sat and ordered just that over and over and over and over. And over yet again.The sourdough crust was quite pleasing and the toppings were delectable. Don't sleep on those meatballs (on the pie or as an appy) or the mushrooms. YUM!The house made sauces added more than just a little extra kick. They enhanced the flavor of anything you splashed a few drops on. The habanero had just the right amount of heat and their own Prairie Fire signature sauce was just... WOW!I can't wait for the kiddo to come back to town so we can hit up our new favorite spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

918 Interiors

The best place in Tulsa. My favorite. Kale Salad is to die for, Oregon Mushroom pizza is unbeatable.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Linda Fleming

Service was fantastic, it was very nice. I had a greek gluten-free pizza with vegan cheese. It wasn't amazing, but pretty good. Just needed more flavor, it may have been the sauce I picked. I was glad to have food I could eat that was pretty decent. I was also glad it wasn't thin crust. The kombucha is delicious! So is the cauliflower appetizer.Vegetarian options: They have vegan cheese and vegetarian pizzas.Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free and non-dairy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Roasted Cauliflower

Ange Johnson

Gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan cheese options.I chose a roasted cauliflower appetizer. It was delicious. I also chose the kombucha, which was tart and refreshing.The server said the pizza was California style, I'd say it was sold short. I lived in Italy for a time and had this type of pizza in Floridia Sicily.We enjoyed our selections, and I would recommend for a date or special occasion.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jana Robinson

Best artisan pizza place in all of Tulsa hands down, I like to get the potato pizza with extra arugula, there's some kind of fig drink that Spencer makes for me there and I love it ????

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ethan

Not gonna lie, a group of us stopped in to gets some drinks while waiting for a dinner reservation down the street. So I’m not expecting anything but killing time. We ordered our drinks, which were amazing. They have this whiskey that puts fireball to shame. Someone in the group got a order of the garlic bread, which was the best I’ve had in years. But what made our time spent here so much better was the bartender, Spencer. I’m 53 years old and this kid is the best bartender I’ve ever been around, not a joke. He makes me want to come back and visit this place. We will be back for the food. But Spencer, you absolutely fantastic at your job. We’ll be back because of you!

Dustin Whiteley

Ordered delivery, we are less than 5 mins away. Bread was burned and meatballs were cold. Pizza is good.

Bryce Barker

Spencer was awesome, he made some fantastic drinks. Food was also very good. Super comfortable atmosphere. 100% will be back soon!!

Ashley M

Service doesn’t get much better than this. Really cozy spot with tasty pizza in perfect portions. Will 100% return and recommend to friends.

T. mack

I ordered wings online. When I showed up 30 min later from across town I was told they were out of wings. No sorry for the inconvenience of driving to pick up nothing or sorry we didn’t call. Was told I would be reimbursed. The reimbursement never came. When I went back to give them a second chance and to get what I paid for I was again told no wings. The manager has a bad attitude and I damn near wanted to put hands on him. Won’t ever be back or give them another chance at disappointment again.

Load More