Simple Simon's Pizza

4532 E 51st St Ste. C, Tulsa
(918) 292-8711

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Seth Michels

I'm from Wisconsin, for custom pizza places we have pizza hut, Domino's and Papa John's. I'm telling you everything simple Simon's did is better than those chains.

The pizza is better, the cheese bread is better and the cinnamon bread is out of this world.

Debbie Wirt

Good takeout pizza. Consistent. At least once-a-month go-to for our fam, and one of the very few places that makes a great crustless presentation (Big10 pizza bowl).

James G Hannah

Some simple Simon’s are better than others, this is one of the crappiest ones. We order pizza the same way every time. Twice recently the pizza was made wrong. The manager wasn’t there, it was rush hour, so we called, no results. Next day the manager say “his employees said they made it right so no replacement. So, as far as I’m concerned they can shove their pizza where the sun doesn’t shine.

Domonique

Very delicious,not too salty. Best calzone around!

Christina Kelton

Friendly service.

Robert Kibling

Food was fresh and excellent, the employees friendly, the store was clean always fast, friendly service.

Ashley Miller

The workers here are so friendly the atmosphere is very warm and welcoming. The food is always so fresh and hot. I recommend ordering from this location.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Alpine, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich

Stallionslaughter Music (Floor Tom)

The Pizzadilla is a beautiful hybrid of Mexican flavors, Italian staples, and American ingenuity. Imagine the italian calzone with the mexican flair of a quesadilla in a distinctly American wrapper, that's the Pizzadilla. Trying it for the first time was nearly as magical as watching my first child be born. My only regret is not being able to go back and experience it for the first time again.

It's incredibly delicious, surprisingly affordable (Pizzadilla + soda =~$8), and the staff of this particular Simple Simon's establishment is attentive and courteous. Highly recommend this place, and menu item, for your next lunch break.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amalia Smith

Fantastic service, good pizza 🍕
Try the supreme calzone, it's one of my favorites and far better than any other calzone in the area. Can't beat the price, speed or friendly service! Cooked exactly the way I like, I'll be back many many times!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Big 10, Supreme Pizza

Adriana Chance

Just picked up my original calzone and specifically asked for extra alpine sauce, instead I ended up getting zero alpine sauce with my order they gave me a cup of ranch, didn’t even put any alpine sauce on the calzone. Bout the only thing that makes me like the calzone is the extra alpine sauce… hate to make the drive to mannford location, but man atleast those kids out there get the order right…

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Alpine

Alexis

I placed my order online for a club sandwich, said it would take 20 minutes on confirmation email. I arrive and the young lady working with colored hair is still working on it, she’s the only one there. She could barely speak up, very hard to understand her. She gives me my order, I go back to my office to eat lunch and discover she burned my bread. I was also given expired chips. I mean so burnt that it’s all I can taste, when eating it. I call the location, let her know I just picked up order, she burned it, where do I reach out for a complaint. All she says is the website and hangs up. She didn’t say sorry. I got my order on 08/27 around 1:10.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nikki Ham

Why cant people read ? Just picked up my canzone and there is no sauce just thr one extra we ordered .. calzones come with marina or alpine . The alpine sticks were supposed to have marinara and the additional alpine sauce. Thanks for making me have to go to a store to grab marinara which for 38 it should have been provided

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Terri Francis

I didn't buy the pizza there because they are higher than the simple Simon's on my side of town so I left and went to the other one and save $3.

L K

Only eat here if you want food poisoning! Calzone made me so sick!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lisa Gniech

Haven't eaten here in a while, and I guess I am reminded why. Got a thin veggie. Topping was great! Lots of cheese and fresh veggies. I do like canned mushrooms, but no problem. I DIDN'T like the crust. It was thin, but it was not crispy, and it wasn't cut well, so when trying to get a slice, it tore the pieces up. And it was so chewy. But the service was great, super nice. Just be going somewhere else for crispy thin.

Food: 3

Service: 5

Loading...