We arrived shortly after 8pm. According to their online hours, they close at 10pm. We ordered two slices of pizza, as two different individuals, and a beer. We asked to sit in the back and were told that was not an option because the back was closed. We received our pizza slices together in a to go box. No silverware. No plates. Nothing. In a to go box. I received a beer in a glass and two conjoined pizza slices in a to go box. We got the message but actually went out to eat instead of ordering pizza because idk, we wanted to go out to eat. We asked for plates and silverware. We were given flimsy paper plates and plastic ware. We asked again for actual plates and real silverware which we eventually received. We have enjoyed this place for years and unfortunately the service model of trying to get rid of your customers from the moment they walk in left a lot to be desired. Pizza was great but could have been warmer. Service was not. We also tipped generously for a counter service restaurant so not sure why we were treated like pests. Edit: My partner also told me their pizza was cold. We also watched as 2 people who walked in after us were turned away when looking for friends because “the back is closed and they’re probably at Cherry street” and two additional people were turned away who clearly expected a sit down meal and were also told the back was closed and were ubruptly asked if they wanted their pizza “for here or to go”. All four customers walked out looking confused. I worked as a server for 10 years, a sit down restaurant is a sit down restaurant unless otherwise stated. Unless a customer orders a piece of pizza to go, especially ordered along with an alcoholic beverage, that pizza is not to go. This is a place that serves dessert and the vibe has always been to order a slice and a beer or two, maybe get gelato after. The vibe has always been welcoming, not sure what happens after 8pm that changes those standards.
Chase Trujillo
Really good gelato!
Ryan Mann
Quality Italian pizza and gelato.
Braxton Tempest
Late night spot for great gelato and friendly staff. This is essentially the same location as Andolini's but they are listed separately. Was delighted when I found this place still open when our group was in the mood for some ice cream after spending time at a local resturant nearby. Very friendly staff, even at 11:30 pm. Staying open late on a Saturday is a great move! Love this place and will be back. Also, you should bring back affogato like you all used to have at the Broken Arrow - Rose District location!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brianna Maynard
Extremely HOT! We know its summer, but DAMN we can get a cool facility to enjoy our meal/drink(s)?!?!?! It felt miserable as soon as you hit the entrance, almost made me second think entering! Poor workers!! They need better conditions!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jennifer Miles
Delicious, we were greeted by the friendliest staff member who gave us his most favorites to sample. We got a two scoop of chocolate cake and chocolate peanut butter. Then we took a pint of Madagascar vanilla, home with our pizza. So glad to have gelato in Tulsa. It’s a wonderful treat :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carlos Moreno
Loved the Roman pizza! The pizza and salad lunch special was affordable and very yummy. Great patio to have a nice lunch and hang out with friends.
We arrived shortly after 8pm. According to their online hours, they close at 10pm. We ordered two slices of pizza, as two different individuals, and a beer. We asked to sit in the back and were told that was not an option because the back was closed. We received our pizza slices together in a to go box. No silverware. No plates. Nothing. In a to go box. I received a beer in a glass and two conjoined pizza slices in a to go box. We got the message but actually went out to eat instead of ordering pizza because idk, we wanted to go out to eat. We asked for plates and silverware. We were given flimsy paper plates and plastic ware. We asked again for actual plates and real silverware which we eventually received. We have enjoyed this place for years and unfortunately the service model of trying to get rid of your customers from the moment they walk in left a lot to be desired. Pizza was great but could have been warmer. Service was not. We also tipped generously for a counter service restaurant so not sure why we were treated like pests. Edit: My partner also told me their pizza was cold. We also watched as 2 people who walked in after us were turned away when looking for friends because “the back is closed and they’re probably at Cherry street” and two additional people were turned away who clearly expected a sit down meal and were also told the back was closed and were ubruptly asked if they wanted their pizza “for here or to go”. All four customers walked out looking confused. I worked as a server for 10 years, a sit down restaurant is a sit down restaurant unless otherwise stated. Unless a customer orders a piece of pizza to go, especially ordered along with an alcoholic beverage, that pizza is not to go. This is a place that serves dessert and the vibe has always been to order a slice and a beer or two, maybe get gelato after. The vibe has always been welcoming, not sure what happens after 8pm that changes those standards.
Really good gelato!
Quality Italian pizza and gelato.
Late night spot for great gelato and friendly staff. This is essentially the same location as Andolini's but they are listed separately. Was delighted when I found this place still open when our group was in the mood for some ice cream after spending time at a local resturant nearby. Very friendly staff, even at 11:30 pm. Staying open late on a Saturday is a great move! Love this place and will be back. Also, you should bring back affogato like you all used to have at the Broken Arrow - Rose District location!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Extremely HOT! We know its summer, but DAMN we can get a cool facility to enjoy our meal/drink(s)?!?!?! It felt miserable as soon as you hit the entrance, almost made me second think entering! Poor workers!! They need better conditions!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 5
Delicious, we were greeted by the friendliest staff member who gave us his most favorites to sample. We got a two scoop of chocolate cake and chocolate peanut butter. Then we took a pint of Madagascar vanilla, home with our pizza. So glad to have gelato in Tulsa. It’s a wonderful treat :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved the Roman pizza! The pizza and salad lunch special was affordable and very yummy. Great patio to have a nice lunch and hang out with friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caprese Salad, Affirmisimo Pizza
Convivial
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Porter peach gelato is magical. Sublimely light and flavorful. I dare say, better than eating a real Porter peach.
Always great gelato!
Restaurantji Recommends
This was the best place for gelato with great customer service and the best pizza I've had in a long time
Can’t expect more under 110F!
Great experience.
LOVE!!!!
Excellent food and service
Loading...