The Italian Eatery

90 Park Pl Blvd, Barrie
(705) 733-2697

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Adam Vengroff

Greeted with a smile and sweet aromas!
This lovely little piece of Italian everything was a great place to have lunch with the family.
We had pizzas, veal sandwich, pasta and garlic knots. All were delicious! The taste and quality you could tell came from love.
Lots of walk out specials, lunch specials and all kinds of extras to take home. A little market of things from Italy and home cooked meals refrigerated for later.
We will be back!

Reba C

We went to the market area this morning, and great environment, and amazing customer service. I can’t wait to go back and eat in for a meal, everything looks SO GOOD

Maria Lindsay

Ordered a sfoglia cake and got nothing but a MESS of whipped cream and puff pastry!!
I’ve had sfoglia cakes from several places over the years, and never had I ever been so disappointed!! I was told upon ordering that it was layered with strawberries and custard, and the whipped cream was only on the outer part of cake. Absolutely not at all!! This cake was made with 90% whipped cream and ONLY 10% custard AND strawberries combined!!! Due to the amount of whipped cream inside the cake, cutting it was an absolute disaster! With every cut, the entire cake just fell apart. $90 for a cake, I didn’t mind spending, as they’re usually worth every bite. Unfortunately, not in this case.
You definitely need to do better with this one!!

Darcey Graham

Food is really good place gets super busy.

Sahil Negi

Had a wonderful experience at this Italian eatery. Ordered the Tomato Basil Pasta Penne, a Personal 12” Pizza, Strawberry Shortcake, and a Cappuccino-everything was absolutely delicious. The soothing music in the background made the atmosphere even more enjoyable. It’s a perfect place for a date or family outing. Highly recommend!

Andrew B

We ordered a catered veal and vegetable meal and everything was great. The veal was very tender and well received.

Judy S

Great spot, delicious food. We had a fettuccini with rosé sauce and a sorento panini. Wonderful service and decadent bakery counter. A must try when in Barrie.

Saba Tayebifar

A local gem! A must try!

Monika Shepherdson

Very disappointed that upon trying this place for the first time on April 25/25, there is no accommodation for a senior who has mobility issues. I sat on a comfortable bench seat at a table, and when my daughter asked for a menu to bring over for me, they didn't have any, only pointed up to the board. I cannot stand for any length of time, and so got up from the seated area and told my daughter to leave. We left while all the other people who had placed orders were standing around waiting in front of the market items. So, unfortunately, I didn't get to try anything that I had been looking forward to. We went to another establishment.

Kathy

I wish I could stay there all day and eat🤣🤣 take out today was Tiramisu, Fettuccine Alfredo with spinach and garlic 🤤 😋 the portions are filling and the twisty rolls served with my meal are amazing. Picked up some packaged pasta as well.Its busy and the staff really try and keep the flow. Be patient !!! It’s a hang out/eatery with a family vibe. If you’re in a hurry don’t go. It’s not a McDonalds. Its Italian!!!!!

Taylor Courtney

Highly recommended. Super friendly. And extremely delicious.
Absolutely fabulous. The options are great and the food is absolutely worth the stop.

Jeremy Holdsworth

Great spot for a sandwich or pizza. My only complaint is they don’t offer Italian dressing as a sandwich topping.

Santo Bagnato

Amazing food & service.

Krystle Deschene

We live an hour north and make a point of stopping here any time we have to go to the city. The food is amazing. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. And the place looks CLEAN. Any time we have been in, I have been impressed with the atmosphere

Linda Hyatt

Wonderful place for lunch! Great food with all sorts of options. Amazing pasta, sandwiches, salads, pizza, take out entrees, wine, plus everything you can think of Italian. Wonderfully friendly staff that help you figure out what you’d like if you’re
Overwhelmed by the options. The aroma of all the fresh baked goods is to die for!

Loading...