Bayfield Brewing Co.

Wait time was short. Drinks were brought out quickly. Mexi fries were disappointing. My 7 year old refused to eat overpriced Mac and cheese. He liked Shirley Temple. Garlic bread was just sliced bread which he did eat.
My friend order Greek Salad. She devoured it until a hair was found.
Apparently no manager was in and nothing was done about it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

This place is a must visit for beer lovers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Got there at 1:35 PM we were seated right away. However we were not told there would be an hour wait. We had our drinks delivered right away and then never saw the waiter until I went in after an hour at that point I payed for the drinks said they sucked and left. Went up the street to Captain Harry’s and we were served in 10 minutes and the wait staff were awesome.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

I ordered a Greek salad with no tomatoes and grilled chicken, but what I received was actually a Caesar salad. When I pointed this out, the manager refused to acknowledge the mistake or offer an apology. There was no effort to correct the order, and I left without eating because of this.

Good customer service means listening to customers and fixing errors, but that didn’t happen here. I hope the restaurant improves how they handle mistakes and treats their guests with respect.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Overall good experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Not what it use to be and would never go back. They’ve always been slow but now it’s a huge problem. Wasted half our afternoon waiting for an hour for bad food. Burger barely has meat and was burnt to a crisp. Fries clearly sat out for too long. Too much money given you’ll end up leaving most of it on your plate since it’s inedible. Shame what happened this place but we won’t be back - there’s other food on the strip.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

I found a long blonde hair in my taco salad… I told my server and the manager took it off the bill for me which was nice… we went back one time after this and had another bad experience… hit or miss I suppose.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Not terrible but outragously overpriced for what it is. $18 for 3 kids chicken strips that one could mistake for boxed ones? I know it is Bayfield but cmon. Businesses like this keep their same pub food from 3 years ago and now charge 5 times the price for the same stuff. No wonder no one goes out to eat anymore. Won't be back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

If you don’t mind waiting over an hour for your appetizer, then this is the place for you.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Don't go here for the local bar feel. Walk straight through to the back where there is a modest patio amongst shaded trees. Food is very good. Perch tacos are great, tai chicken nachos were also really good! Service was great. Have been here before and will be back! Go for the food! 😊

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

The fish and chips were very overcooked and pricey. The chips are okay. But Clare is truly one of the best servers I’ve ever had the pleasure of being served by. From the moment we were seated, she was warm, attentive, and incredibly professional. She has a natural ability to make guests feel welcomed and cared for, anticipating needs before we even had to ask.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

My husband had the fish and chips. The only thing he liked was the chips. The fish was too overcooked. I had the mexi fries which was supposed to have a beer cheese sauce on them and didn't. I wanted to tell my server but she didn't come around again until I was almost done my meal. I guess our server was pretty new there so I will be a bit forgiving with our service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 3

I’m a little torn on this review - while the food was good, it was not a 24$ burger. Fish was good, and fries are great. Our server was super sweet, but appears to be the only one actively serving… Other diners had run out of cutlery and there was no clean cutlery available. During the summer when it’s busiest? The hostess could probably not have cared less to be here and that was written all over her face. After easily 15-20 minutes, we were asked for our drink order. We placed our food order at the same time. Drinks took about 10 minutes. Basic beer and a pop, and food took approx 35 more minutes. If it had been busy, we would’ve understood. But there were few others in at this time. Food was decent, but the lack of everything else made the experience dull. When you can hear the staff telling other staff that there’s no place for anything, just look around and eventually you’ll find it somewhere? Also whoever Derek is - they love to scream your name on a regular basis. We can see the potential here, and the food IS GOOD just the experience needs to be better. Much better. And air conditioning!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Greek nachos were good. Pet friendly. We sat on the patio with our German Shorthair and he had ice water while we were looking at the menu. Staff was great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best stop we made in Bayfield! Went on a Monday night for dinner.

The restaurant itself is a bit stuffy, but the BACK patio is perfect. Shaded, quiet, comfy chairs, no loud music.

Drinks, we got the Beer Flight. The server was super helpful in selecting which options (I’m a non-beer drinker). Loved the Blonde Lime the best!

Food, the table ordered Calamari, Smash Burger and Tacos. Unfortunately they were out of perch, but no complaints on the Beef Tacos! Smash burger was fabulous (huge portion for me!), and the fries were delicious! The calamari was also perfect!

Service was great! Food came at a good pace, love the server (kind, and courteous).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5