Came on a Sunday late afternoon with the fam and we were seated right away. The menu says their stuffed pizza takes at least 30mins so we made sure to put that in first. We had the veggie stuffed pizza, bruschetta bread and antipasto salad. Everything was absolutely delicious! Bread was so soft, the salad was well dressed and a favourite of the tables. Pizza was insanely good! It was heavy, the sauce had this really nice kick to it and the veggies were nice and crunchy. And our server was very sweet and friendly. The hour drive to eat here was worth it. Highly recommend and would definitely be returning!
Sean Palmerston
There are a lot of newer pizza shops in Hamilton getting praise these days, but for me nothing in the city beats the stuffed pizza from Chicago Style. We always get the large Chicago Special and it never disappoints. The meatballs are so tasty inside of it. This pizza is huge - it must weigh over five pounds - and it feeds our family of four for two days. A Hamilton mountain institution!
Gene Garreau
Imy family has been coming here for over 30 years pat and grace are so amazing the food an service fantastic gene garreau
Keelan Giesinger
What a silly place. No reservations. Call them to see if there is a table available. There is, so you drive up. Get there and are told it will be a 45 minute wait. Just take a reservation.
Anna Nicole Ureta
(Visited for the first time on Sunday, May 18 around 6PM for dine in - had to wait maybe 15-20 mins for a table)
This place is busy even for a Sunday but it is dinner time. We came all the way from York Region for the Chicago Style pizza. While I personally found the sauce a bit sweet and the crust an interesting flat bread consistency I would still 100% come back anyway~
We only got the caesar salad and the chicago style stuffed pizza with pepperoni and we were incredibly happy with both of them. Definitely a place where I'd love to try the rest of the menu. Too bad this is the only location in the far and wide GTA.
We had to wait for the pizza which is fine - the cheese was cheesing. The sauce and saucing. I need to go to Chicago to compare but since we can't go to the US right now this is your next best bet for the best Chicago Style Pizza north of the border.
**one thing I will say is finding parking can be difficult so I'm not sure where we should be parking to dine here.
Yael Ortiz
One of the best restaurants in all of Hamilton, the food is very delicious and generously portioned, the atmosphere is very pleasant and tranquil. If you're looking for a beautiful restaurant with excellent food in Hamilton, visit this place - it's a restaurant you can't miss. The customer service is magnificent.
Bren GS
Delicious Chicago-style pizza with a special touch! The crust is crispy and the toppings are generous. But what really stands out is their lasagna, it's incredible! The service is friendly and attentive. Highly recommended! I'll be back soon 😍
Rohan mehta
Their stuffed pizza is all you can ask for. I specially drive all the way to hamilton for their spaghetti. It’s by far the best i have had. Will go again n again and highly recommended.
D N
Tomato sauce sucks
Chuck D
Excellent 👌 best pizza I've had in a long long time.
The most delicious Italian cooking you can get in Hamilton, there's a reason this place has been open for so long and with food like that there not going anywhere!
Michelle Wobst
This is one of my favourite places to dine. Chicago style deep dish pizza is incredible and the red and white is my favorite entree option. Soooooo good! Whenever I'm in Hamilton I try to get there!
Call me Devon
**This review comes with a disclaimer: I don’t care for Italian food.**
That said, the people in my life who do, my wife and my mother in this case absolutely love this place.
On our most recent visit, my wife had the eggplant parm, and my mother ordered the baked rigatoni. Both were extremely happy with their meals and praised the flavor and portion sizes. I made sure to question them thoroughly, and by their accounts, the food easily earns five stars.
As for me, I had a pizza. Unfortunately, I found it a bit lacking, especially for the price. Even a touch of cornmeal on the crust (a must-have in my opinion) might’ve added some welcome texture and complexity. I’ve tried one of their deep-dish pizzas in the past as well and found it similarly underwhelming—but again, Italian food isn’t my thing, so I don’t weigh my own experience too heavily here.
To be fair, I ordered takeout. Maybe the pizza hits better when dining in. I genuinely don’t know.
What I can say is that I’ve never had an issue with service, and the few times I’ve eaten in, the space has always been quiet, warm, and perfect for a family meal.
Bonus points: The garlic bread, Italian wedding soup, and bruschetta bread? Genuinely delicious.
It takes a lot for a restaurant to get a positive review from someone who doesn’t even like the style of food they serve, but in this case, I’m happy to give credit where credit is due.
Anjelica Martinez
Arrived at around 5:00pm on a Saturday, waited about 30 min for a table and it was so worth it. The stuffed pizza was close enough to the pies in Chicago - we enjoyed it so much! Service was also so friendly and attentive. Would make the drive from Toronto again for this gem.
trisha billa
Enjoyed the authentic Chicago style pizza and flavors. Had a great time
Came on a Sunday late afternoon with the fam and we were seated right away. The menu says their stuffed pizza takes at least 30mins so we made sure to put that in first. We had the veggie stuffed pizza, bruschetta bread and antipasto salad. Everything was absolutely delicious! Bread was so soft, the salad was well dressed and a favourite of the tables. Pizza was insanely good! It was heavy, the sauce had this really nice kick to it and the veggies were nice and crunchy. And our server was very sweet and friendly. The hour drive to eat here was worth it. Highly recommend and would definitely be returning!
There are a lot of newer pizza shops in Hamilton getting praise these days, but for me nothing in the city beats the stuffed pizza from Chicago Style. We always get the large Chicago Special and it never disappoints. The meatballs are so tasty inside of it. This pizza is huge - it must weigh over five pounds - and it feeds our family of four for two days. A Hamilton mountain institution!
Imy family has been coming here for over 30 years pat and grace are so amazing the food an service fantastic gene garreau
What a silly place. No reservations. Call them to see if there is a table available. There is, so you drive up. Get there and are told it will be a 45 minute wait. Just take a reservation.
(Visited for the first time on Sunday, May 18 around 6PM for dine in - had to wait maybe 15-20 mins for a table)
This place is busy even for a Sunday but it is dinner time.
We came all the way from York Region for the Chicago Style pizza. While I personally found the sauce a bit sweet and the crust an interesting flat bread consistency I would still 100% come back anyway~
We only got the caesar salad and the chicago style stuffed pizza with pepperoni and we were incredibly happy with both of them.
Definitely a place where I'd love to try the rest of the menu. Too bad this is the only location in the far and wide GTA.
We had to wait for the pizza which is fine - the cheese was cheesing. The sauce and saucing.
I need to go to Chicago to compare but since we can't go to the US right now this is your next best bet for the best Chicago Style Pizza north of the border.
**one thing I will say is finding parking can be difficult so I'm not sure where we should be parking to dine here.
One of the best restaurants in all of Hamilton, the food is very delicious and generously portioned, the atmosphere is very pleasant and tranquil. If you're looking for a beautiful restaurant with excellent food in Hamilton, visit this place - it's a restaurant you can't miss. The customer service is magnificent.
Delicious Chicago-style pizza with a special touch! The crust is crispy and the toppings are generous. But what really stands out is their lasagna, it's incredible! The service is friendly and attentive. Highly recommended! I'll be back soon 😍
Their stuffed pizza is all you can ask for. I specially drive all the way to hamilton for their spaghetti. It’s by far the best i have had.
Will go again n again and highly recommended.
Tomato sauce sucks
Excellent 👌 best pizza I've had in a long long time.
Restaurantji Recommends
The most delicious Italian cooking you can get in Hamilton, there's a reason this place has been open for so long and with food like that there not going anywhere!
This is one of my favourite places to dine. Chicago style deep dish pizza is incredible and the red and white is my favorite entree option. Soooooo good! Whenever I'm in Hamilton I try to get there!
**This review comes with a disclaimer: I don’t care for Italian food.**
That said, the people in my life who do, my wife and my mother in this case absolutely love this place.
On our most recent visit, my wife had the eggplant parm, and my mother ordered the baked rigatoni. Both were extremely happy with their meals and praised the flavor and portion sizes. I made sure to question them thoroughly, and by their accounts, the food easily earns five stars.
As for me, I had a pizza. Unfortunately, I found it a bit lacking, especially for the price. Even a touch of cornmeal on the crust (a must-have in my opinion) might’ve added some welcome texture and complexity. I’ve tried one of their deep-dish pizzas in the past as well and found it similarly underwhelming—but again, Italian food isn’t my thing, so I don’t weigh my own experience too heavily here.
To be fair, I ordered takeout. Maybe the pizza hits better when dining in. I genuinely don’t know.
What I can say is that I’ve never had an issue with service, and the few times I’ve eaten in, the space has always been quiet, warm, and perfect for a family meal.
Bonus points: The garlic bread, Italian wedding soup, and bruschetta bread? Genuinely delicious.
It takes a lot for a restaurant to get a positive review from someone who doesn’t even like the style of food they serve, but in this case, I’m happy to give credit where credit is due.
Arrived at around 5:00pm on a Saturday, waited about 30 min for a table and it was so worth it. The stuffed pizza was close enough to the pies in Chicago - we enjoyed it so much! Service was also so friendly and attentive. Would make the drive from Toronto again for this gem.
Enjoyed the authentic Chicago style pizza and flavors. Had a great time
Loading...