Shorty's delivers a top-tier pie that impresses on almost every level. The cheese is rich, creamy, and perfectly melted — a high-quality blend that stretches just right and adds a satisfying mouthfeel. The sauce is a standout: balanced, vibrant, and layered with flavor. You get a nice tang from the tomatoes, a subtle sweetness, and a touch of herbaceous depth that suggests it’s made in-house.
The crust is where Shorty’s really shines. It's got that perfect balance of crisp on the outside with a chewy, airy interior — likely cold-fermented dough with a solid hydration ratio. There’s a pleasant char from the oven, adding just a hint of smokiness and crunch without being overdone. A true artisan-style base that holds up well under the toppings.
Overall, this is a well-executed, gourmet-level pizza. The ingredients are clearly high quality, and the attention to detail in the bake and flavor profile is impressive. While it’s definitely on the higher end price-wise, the craftsmanship and flavor justify the cost. A great spot for serious pizza lovers looking for a memorable pie.
c vihos
Moved to the neighbourhood four months ago have been all over for pizza 🍕 I’m big on Ottawa area pizza because of the brick cheese mozzarella mix but Shorty’s really beats everything I’ve tried after 11 visits Wow , oh forgot to add I had the banana pudding today I got one bite my wife and daughters left the room with it ….. all to say .. no one needs to go try anything else …. this is the way pizzaaaaaaa is meant to be experienced ….. 👍🏻
Ben Skarratt
Pretty decent pizza but 70 something dollars for 2 pizzas picked up? For that price I expect a little more quality
Marilo Nunez
Best pizza in Hamilton!
Nidhi Kalra
Loved the place...what's not to love? The staff is super friendly, the pizzas taste great and the ambience is just right. Our first time here but we already know it won't be the last.
Mischa C
This is by far one of the bestest pizza joints in Ontario. Easily. Edgy, wholesome, and super gourmet tasting pizza. If you chooee to chill in the seating area its really comfy and good tunes playing.
Tiana Meridith
The pizza is good BUT the sanitary protocols are just a bit questionable. I went in for the first time to try it out starting with a slice. The woman at the front desk handled my cash and used the same hands to throw cheese on my pizza with her bare hands 🤢 not sure if I’ll be back
dave wilson
Wow great pizza cold beer we will be back
BurnA-Bee
The fall off should be studied honestly. Once my go to pizza place , fresh , quick , crisp and overall amazing taste .. but all that came to an abrupt end lastnight unfortunately. When I opened my already half opened box to see this cold grease trap , I was stunned to say the least . Watching the driver toss (yes legitimately toss) my food onto my step . (I have a camera but who doesn't these days) non the less should be handled with more care but that's not Shorty's fault , their fault these days lies with the quality. Unfortunately this isn't even close to what it was like 2 years ago also $45 for this isn't nice . Shame honestly .
Really cozy, old school diner vibes with excellent pizza! Excellent crust that you'll want to eat with their dipping sauces.
Arjun Raj
Best pizza in Hamilton
Tessa DiLoreto
Wonderful pizza, staff are easy to engage with either in person or over the phone. Pizza is always warm, never soggy on pick up. Their seasonal pizzas are always so exciting and delicious! The salads have been so filling and packed with flavour. Have been our go to for at home party catering. There is some local street parking but it can be hard to get a spot.
Stephen Kirkpatrick
A true Hamilton Icon
J C
Just moved into the area. Ordered a pepperoni slice to go. Delicious and friendly staff. Large slices and tasty. Will definitely order a whole pizza to try there next time.
Shorty's delivers a top-tier pie that impresses on almost every level. The cheese is rich, creamy, and perfectly melted — a high-quality blend that stretches just right and adds a satisfying mouthfeel. The sauce is a standout: balanced, vibrant, and layered with flavor. You get a nice tang from the tomatoes, a subtle sweetness, and a touch of herbaceous depth that suggests it’s made in-house.
The crust is where Shorty’s really shines. It's got that perfect balance of crisp on the outside with a chewy, airy interior — likely cold-fermented dough with a solid hydration ratio. There’s a pleasant char from the oven, adding just a hint of smokiness and crunch without being overdone. A true artisan-style base that holds up well under the toppings.
Overall, this is a well-executed, gourmet-level pizza. The ingredients are clearly high quality, and the attention to detail in the bake and flavor profile is impressive. While it’s definitely on the higher end price-wise, the craftsmanship and flavor justify the cost. A great spot for serious pizza lovers looking for a memorable pie.
Moved to the neighbourhood four months ago have been all over for pizza 🍕 I’m big on Ottawa area pizza because of the brick cheese mozzarella mix but Shorty’s really beats everything I’ve tried after 11 visits Wow , oh forgot to add I had the banana pudding today I got one bite my wife and daughters left the room with it ….. all to say .. no one needs to go try anything else …. this is the way pizzaaaaaaa is meant to be experienced ….. 👍🏻
Pretty decent pizza but 70 something dollars for 2 pizzas picked up? For that price I expect a little more quality
Best pizza in Hamilton!
Loved the place...what's not to love? The staff is super friendly, the pizzas taste great and the ambience is just right. Our first time here but we already know it won't be the last.
This is by far one of the bestest pizza joints in Ontario. Easily. Edgy, wholesome, and super gourmet tasting pizza. If you chooee to chill in the seating area its really comfy and good tunes playing.
The pizza is good BUT the sanitary protocols are just a bit questionable. I went in for the first time to try it out starting with a slice. The woman at the front desk handled my cash and used the same hands to throw cheese on my pizza with her bare hands 🤢 not sure if I’ll be back
Wow great pizza cold beer we will be back
The fall off should be studied honestly. Once my go to pizza place , fresh , quick , crisp and overall amazing taste .. but all that came to an abrupt end lastnight unfortunately. When I opened my already half opened box to see this cold grease trap , I was stunned to say the least . Watching the driver toss (yes legitimately toss) my food onto my step . (I have a camera but who doesn't these days) non the less should be handled with more care but that's not Shorty's fault , their fault these days lies with the quality. Unfortunately this isn't even close to what it was like 2 years ago also $45 for this isn't nice . Shame honestly .
Might be the best pizza I've had
Restaurantji Recommends
Really cozy, old school diner vibes with excellent pizza! Excellent crust that you'll want to eat with their dipping sauces.
Best pizza in Hamilton
Wonderful pizza, staff are easy to engage with either in person or over the phone. Pizza is always warm, never soggy on pick up. Their seasonal pizzas are always so exciting and delicious! The salads have been so filling and packed with flavour. Have been our go to for at home party catering.
There is some local street parking but it can be hard to get a spot.
A true Hamilton Icon
Just moved into the area. Ordered a pepperoni slice to go. Delicious and friendly staff.
Large slices and tasty.
Will definitely order a whole pizza to try there next time.
Loading...