Dough was too thick and close to raw in the center. Sauce tastes like it came out of a can, was far too acidic and slopped on haphazardly. For $30 (or $5/slice) and based on the previous reviews, i expected better. Residents of Hamilton must be desperately hard up for halfway decent dining options if folks are thinking that this is 5 star pizza. We should have known better ordering pizza from a cupcake shop.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
Anthony Sistilli
While it was a bit expensive for a somewhat small looking pizza - let me tell you it was amazing.Sourdough pizza is a labour of love and you could definitely feel that love coming through on every bite. I drove 40 minutes each way to try this pizza and it was worth every second. I hope you guys open one up in Mississauga (and get a bit cheaper or make the pizzas a bit bigger haha).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erin Mc
Very good pizza and dip! I got the Scotty Peppen and the Elle PePe and both are very tasty! If u had to pick one over the other it would be the Scotty Peppen. The dip is made in touch and very delicious! I ordered for pick up and the location is easy to find with lots of street parking available. If you like deep dish style pizza you'll love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Timothy N
This was a very hard one to rate. On one hand the pizza is very very very good. On the other, its very expensive for the amount of food you get. I get it, its better ingredients, but so is cowabungas and you get way more bang for the buck there. This place will be a very occasional one for us.
Jess D
I have been interested in trying out Sourdough Pizza for sometime! It exceeded all my expectations and it was incredibly delicious! I will 1000% be back for more.The establishment itself was in an easily accessible location, and the interior is beautiful and very trendy for social media. The staff were kind, efficient and double checked the order before giving it to me.My order consisted of El Pepe & Scotty Peppen. I also order the Ranch and Truffle Aioli Dips- they were delicious! Every bite was amazing; flavourful, fresh, and the crust was what pizza dreams are made of lolThe homemade dips complimented the pizza perfectly.If you are thinking about giving this place a try, stop thinking twice and do it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luca Siciliano
The pizza itself was pretty decent, fresh toppings, fresh sauce it was great. Where it gets a three star is the price and size. I payed 55$ for 6 slices the size of a kitkat bar (as seen in photo). I was really unimpressed, it wasn’t even a meal it was more of a snack. Maybe I’m cheap but for 55$ I expected a lot more.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beau Cranston
First bite down of the 1000s i plan to take in the future. I got hit by a train of flavour which completely destroyed me and rebuilt me into a whole new person. The pizza has a bit of a price tag but I’m happy to say it’s completely worth the money. The el pepe with truffle aioli has no rival. Truely delectable.
leah cassidy
Damn. So impressed! Honestly best pizza I've ever had. We tried the El Pepe, Scotty Peppen and Pesto Sausage and all were amazing. Truffle aioli dip is also chef's kiss
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric Vienneau
The truffle dip is a must-have next to any of the pizzas. I had the Mush Love pizza, the small was he perfect size for one person. Definitely check out if you want something new and not too heavy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Myles Arnott
The pizza and service were amazing! I had the El Pepe with truffle sauce, and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve had!
Can’t say enough good things about this pizza! Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had. We got the Scotty peppin, SO GOOD! The best mix of sweet and spicy. Great service, great food! We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zac Taylor
Amazing pizza, the bread-crust was thick and crispy. Guys in the store were super nice. Pepperoni and was fantastic and the sauce was perfect.
Emily Brisson
Unreal. The bread is next level. The pre made pizzas are great options (the ricotta …. I can’t say enough). Please enjoy so they can stay in the neighbourhood !!Vegetarian options: Good veg options ! Street parking around easily
Brendan Tait
Ordered two pizzas and both were amazing. Perfectly cooked, ample toppings, and light and airy. I’ve already placed a other order for this weekend.
Cole Avery
I've always been a fan of Detroit style pizza but first time having it with sour dough. Holy moly it was good. This will be my new Friday night spot.
Dough was too thick and close to raw in the center. Sauce tastes like it came out of a can, was far too acidic and slopped on haphazardly. For $30 (or $5/slice) and based on the previous reviews, i expected better. Residents of Hamilton must be desperately hard up for halfway decent dining options if folks are thinking that this is 5 star pizza. We should have known better ordering pizza from a cupcake shop.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
While it was a bit expensive for a somewhat small looking pizza - let me tell you it was amazing.Sourdough pizza is a labour of love and you could definitely feel that love coming through on every bite. I drove 40 minutes each way to try this pizza and it was worth every second. I hope you guys open one up in Mississauga (and get a bit cheaper or make the pizzas a bit bigger haha).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good pizza and dip! I got the Scotty Peppen and the Elle PePe and both are very tasty! If u had to pick one over the other it would be the Scotty Peppen. The dip is made in touch and very delicious! I ordered for pick up and the location is easy to find with lots of street parking available. If you like deep dish style pizza you'll love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was a very hard one to rate. On one hand the pizza is very very very good. On the other, its very expensive for the amount of food you get. I get it, its better ingredients, but so is cowabungas and you get way more bang for the buck there. This place will be a very occasional one for us.
I have been interested in trying out Sourdough Pizza for sometime! It exceeded all my expectations and it was incredibly delicious! I will 1000% be back for more.The establishment itself was in an easily accessible location, and the interior is beautiful and very trendy for social media. The staff were kind, efficient and double checked the order before giving it to me.My order consisted of El Pepe & Scotty Peppen. I also order the Ranch and Truffle Aioli Dips- they were delicious! Every bite was amazing; flavourful, fresh, and the crust was what pizza dreams are made of lolThe homemade dips complimented the pizza perfectly.If you are thinking about giving this place a try, stop thinking twice and do it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza itself was pretty decent, fresh toppings, fresh sauce it was great. Where it gets a three star is the price and size. I payed 55$ for 6 slices the size of a kitkat bar (as seen in photo). I was really unimpressed, it wasn’t even a meal it was more of a snack. Maybe I’m cheap but for 55$ I expected a lot more.
Food: 5
Service: 5
First bite down of the 1000s i plan to take in the future. I got hit by a train of flavour which completely destroyed me and rebuilt me into a whole new person. The pizza has a bit of a price tag but I’m happy to say it’s completely worth the money. The el pepe with truffle aioli has no rival. Truely delectable.
Damn. So impressed! Honestly best pizza I've ever had. We tried the El Pepe, Scotty Peppen and Pesto Sausage and all were amazing. Truffle aioli dip is also chef's kiss
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The truffle dip is a must-have next to any of the pizzas. I had the Mush Love pizza, the small was he perfect size for one person. Definitely check out if you want something new and not too heavy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza and service were amazing! I had the El Pepe with truffle sauce, and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Can’t say enough good things about this pizza! Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had. We got the Scotty peppin, SO GOOD! The best mix of sweet and spicy. Great service, great food! We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pizza, the bread-crust was thick and crispy. Guys in the store were super nice. Pepperoni and was fantastic and the sauce was perfect.
Unreal. The bread is next level. The pre made pizzas are great options (the ricotta …. I can’t say enough). Please enjoy so they can stay in the neighbourhood !!Vegetarian options: Good veg options ! Street parking around easily
Ordered two pizzas and both were amazing. Perfectly cooked, ample toppings, and light and airy. I’ve already placed a other order for this weekend.
I've always been a fan of Detroit style pizza but first time having it with sour dough. Holy moly it was good. This will be my new Friday night spot.