Tony G’s Pizza is a hidden gem! The pizza is flavorful, cheesy, and always hits the spot. Great crust, generous toppings, and friendly service. Whether it’s a quick bite or a weekend treat, Tony G’s never disappoints. One of my local favorites!
Adrian Pulsone
Best New York style pizza in Hamilton!! Everyone working here’s great and they got an awesome sense of humour. Great atmosphere and best pizza around.
Jessy
Excellent pizza slices!
NatashaS Duckett
EDIT*** SO TODAY WE DECIDED TO TRY COWABUNGAS PIZZA BC WE HEARD THEY WERE GOOD TOO! NAWWWW TONYS #1. TONEYS STILL BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA AND WINGS IN HAMILTON. SUPER FRIENDLY CUSTOMER SERVICE, THEY EVEN MAKE THEIR OWN IN HOUSE CHEESE. ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS... ME AND THE HUBBY WILL ONLY BE GETTING OUR PIZZA FROM TONY G's PIZZERIA, YOU WOULD TOO IF YOU WANT AUTHENTIC DELICIOUS FOOD. THANKS GUYS FOR THE #1 BEST PIZZA IN THE CITY. I WISH I WOULD OF TAKEN A PHOTO OF THE AMAZING SIZE WINGS WITH THAT DELICIOUS SAUCE!
Nikola
Was recommended this place by a friend, and it exceeded every expectation. Amazing pizza, and quality service across the board with everyone working being extremely friendly and sociable. Will definitely be coming back many times!
Veronica
Ordered for pickup on a Saturday night and it was ready in only 20 minutes. The staff were super friendly! Pizza was light and crispy, not too doughy or saucy. Definitely will be back!
Stephan Nalezny
Pizza look beautiful but is bland
Aubrey Milne
Popped in for a pizza for the first time and was instantly treated like family, and presented with a GORGEOUS pizza. Great service and delicious pizza! 10/10 would recommend.
Got slices, so not fair to review totally. Get a fresh pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: New York Pepperoni Pizza, Calabrese Pizza
Alex Dale
Walked by and tried their pepperoni slice on a whim. Now a few weeks later I have to avoid walking by because I must stop for a slice every time. Really great pizza that strikes the balance between high quality cheese and fresh and crisp crust. In my opinion the best pizza in Hamilton.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Pepperoni Pizza
Marco Carpanini
Best pizza in the Hamilton area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brent Cescon
The pizza is amazing. The owner is a beauty. Will definitely be back and would strongly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dasha Diez
This place is an absolute gem. The pizza is just perfect, crispy and chewy.
Fantastic!
Tony G’s Pizza is a hidden gem! The pizza is flavorful, cheesy, and always hits the spot. Great crust, generous toppings, and friendly service. Whether it’s a quick bite or a weekend treat, Tony G’s never disappoints. One of my local favorites!
Best New York style pizza in Hamilton!! Everyone working here’s great and they got an awesome sense of humour. Great atmosphere and best pizza around.
Excellent pizza slices!
EDIT*** SO TODAY WE DECIDED TO TRY COWABUNGAS PIZZA BC WE HEARD THEY WERE GOOD TOO! NAWWWW TONYS #1.
TONEYS STILL BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA AND WINGS IN HAMILTON. SUPER FRIENDLY CUSTOMER SERVICE, THEY EVEN MAKE THEIR OWN IN HOUSE CHEESE. ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS... ME AND THE HUBBY WILL ONLY BE GETTING OUR PIZZA FROM TONY G's PIZZERIA, YOU WOULD TOO IF YOU WANT AUTHENTIC DELICIOUS FOOD.
THANKS GUYS FOR THE #1 BEST PIZZA IN THE CITY.
I WISH I WOULD OF TAKEN A PHOTO OF THE AMAZING SIZE WINGS WITH THAT DELICIOUS SAUCE!
Was recommended this place by a friend, and it exceeded every expectation. Amazing pizza, and quality service across the board with everyone working being extremely friendly and sociable. Will definitely be coming back many times!
Ordered for pickup on a Saturday night and it was ready in only 20 minutes. The staff were super friendly! Pizza was light and crispy, not too doughy or saucy. Definitely will be back!
Pizza look beautiful but is bland
Popped in for a pizza for the first time and was instantly treated like family, and presented with a GORGEOUS pizza. Great service and delicious pizza! 10/10 would recommend.
Pizza was excellent. Service was great as well!
Restaurantji Recommends
Got slices, so not fair to review totally. Get a fresh pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: New York Pepperoni Pizza, Calabrese Pizza
Walked by and tried their pepperoni slice on a whim. Now a few weeks later I have to avoid walking by because I must stop for a slice every time. Really great pizza that strikes the balance between high quality cheese and fresh and crisp crust. In my opinion the best pizza in Hamilton.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Pepperoni Pizza
Best pizza in the Hamilton area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is amazing. The owner is a beauty. Will definitely be back and would strongly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is an absolute gem. The pizza is just perfect, crispy and chewy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...