Godfathers Pizza - Fenelon Falls

Pizza was delicious. Hot and quick

I rarely leave reviews, but after my experience at Godfather’s, I felt it was necessary to share. The level of unprofessionalism displayed by the manager, Carissa, was honestly shocking.

During my visit, I witnessed Carissa treating one of her employees with open disrespect, raising her voice and making snide remarks in front of customers. What made it even more uncomfortable was the way she looked at me mid-incident, as if expecting me to side with her or validate her behavior. It was clear she was trying to shift blame onto her employee, which I found both disgusting and incredibly unprofessional.

Her attitude made it very obvious that she does not take her role seriously. This wasn’t just a one-off moment of stress, it was a pattern. She was equally rude to other customers and came off cold and dismissive the entire time I was there. There was no effort to create a welcoming environment. Instead, the energy she brought into that space made everyone feel on edge.

A manager sets the tone for a workplace, and in this case, the tone is toxic. Godfather’s has potential, but with someone like Carissa at the helm, I can’t recommend it. No customer or employee deserves to be treated like that.

I come to Godfather’s regularly, and I’ve had a few experiences now with the manager Carissa that are seriously making me reconsider coming back. Not only is she rude to both staff and customers, but the times she’s made my food, it’s been noticeably worse compared to when other employees prepare it—sloppy, rushed, and just not the same quality.

What really bothers me is how unprofessional she acts. She’s openly disrespectful to her team, and it creates a really uncomfortable vibe for everyone. After multiple visits where this has happened, I’m honestly disturbed by her attitude and how she handles her position. If this continues, I don’t see myself returning.

Do better.

I dont care if the pizza is good or not. An hour wait for two pizza is wild. Just a single person working on a Friday night.

Delicious food and super nice staff. Possibly the best garlic fingers I’ve ever had highly recommend anyone eating here to try them.

Great za, other place was full up on orders and had a long wait time, one person. Godfathers had multiple ppl and were very nice. Was an offer I count refuse 😎

Pizza was delicious, loved the fresh pepperoni, and the sauce was nice and not too acidic, everyone that had a slice was happy with it too 💯🔥

I don’t know what the new management is doing but they are doing it right, I don’t normally leave reviews but this place deserves it. Me and my family have been coming here for awhile now and we have all noticed an amazing change in not only the food itself but the service and physical state of the restaurant. The dough is wonderful, not to hard but not soggy, the sauce is always perfectly balanced along the entire pizza, toppings are perfect, not too much where its hard to handle but just the right amount where you get all the flavours. They cook it to perfection with a light and crisp crust, and the customer service is unmatched. They have created such a welcoming and friendly environment. Big props to the new management.

My son and I go to godfathers in fenelon often, we Absolutely love the pizza, And we've noticed great changes in the last little while.

I went in to godfather's pizza to order a slice of pizza. The pizza was dried out and not warm. There was a little kid running in the back by the ovens and the place was dirty. Also the place smelt like cigarettes. I would never recommend this place or go back I ended up throwing out the pizza. Very disappointed in my experience there.

Great food for a great price!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza the Way I Like It

Great pizza and friendly staff. I 100% recommend this place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza and friendly staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza the Way I Like It

The pizza is incomparable. layer of cheese, You're toppings and another layer of cheese on top. 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Could NOT possibly have been better!!!!!?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza every time

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza the Way I Like It

Food was good, ready for pick up, but very dated building

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza the Way I Like It