Anam and Hassan have made our evening a few days back amazing. Everything was fantastic, the service, the food... Unforgetable. Please, keep up the good work. Thanks for everything. We'll be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doug Clark
Best pizza in town! Not even comparable to others. Its a whole different level although new pricing & taxes is disappointing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Rodz
Excellent pizza, it is pricey for what you get. I would have expected a bit more toppings and basil on the pizzas
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
V
I recently visited Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza Milton and it was such a pleasant surprise!
From the outside, it looks quite ordinary—but the moment you step in, it feels like you’ve been transported straight to Italy. The cobbled-style interiors, rustic charm, elegant chandeliers, and even a beautiful wall wine cellar—every detail has been thoughtfully designed to create an authentic Italian vibe.
We ordered the lunch special, which included a Margherita pizza, pomodoro pasta, bruschetta, and soda. Every single dish was bursting with flavor. The pizza was perfectly balanced, the pasta was rich and comforting, and the bruschetta was fresh and delicious.
Honestly, the meal was so satisfying, we walked out in a full-on food coma 😄
If you’re looking for authentic Italian food with a cozy, immersive ambiance, this place is definitely worth a visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dhruv Varde
While we were around Milton, one of my buddies suggested this place. He had been here multiple times. Considering we are vegetarian, sometimes its hard to find amazing taste and flavor at authentic places but this place is an exception.
Amazing food, nice ambience, good service and especially awesome taste and presentation.
I would definitely recommend to visit here if you want to try Italian.
Try their Pizza and Pasta. Especially the ravioli, it was amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ria
We’ve been regulars here for about two years, mainly because of the wonderful waitresses. It was disappointing to find out that their hours were cut and they were eventually replaced, as we never saw them again. Also tips don’t go directly to the waitresses and prices have gone up while portions have gone down. A 5-piece appetizer that used to cost $12 is now $13 for only 3 pieces. Unfortunately, it just doesn’t feel worth it anymore and it’s not the same without those waitresses we were so excited to be greeted with.
Marlene
We went to dinner last night. It has been a while since we last visited, and over the years the atmosphere has certainly changed. To begin, the entrance walkway was not even plowed or salted. Second, the service needs to be polished; opening a beer can and pouring as well not understanding what fresh pepper should be basic service at a restaurant. The food remains very good, but playing music would help improve the atmosphere. Overall there is clear contrast from the Streetsville location in terms of atmosphere and service. Moving forward, we will only go to the streetsville location.
It was such an amazing place to go in. We didn't have a reservation but they gave us the cutest spot to sit in the corner it was so ascetic. All the staff was so friendly. We got two wood oven pizzas and they were delicious. We ordered the Napoletana sized pizza, one Marghertita and the other was Pollo Piccante. We went in hungry but it was more than enough for left overs. Definitely a great spot to go to.
Goodfellas is my go-to Italian spot. Wood-oven pizza perfection — hands down the best Margherita in town. Obsessed with the crema di tartufo pasta (that mushroom sauce 🤌) Whenever i need a little uplifting, i got here The atmosphere is so calm and has that comforting vibe. I also recently tried their risotto and really enjoyed it — cooked beautifully and full of flavor.
Bonus points for serving halal options, which makes it even better. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Ripley
Service was good (we were the only two people in there). My son and I both had the ravioli. It was very good, but the portion should have been a kids meal. We each counted 6 ravioli...6 😞 for 25.00 a plate. Decided to get a pizza to go. Told 25.00 for a 4 slice or 50.00 for a 12 slice. We got the 4 slice (about the size of a medium pizza). Food was good, but for the price, the portions were a huge disappointment 😞
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Krys Danilko
Didn't like the pizza there was little to no flavor and the gnocchi dish was NOT homemade and way too much cheese in the so called Alfredo sauce. Very disappointed
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Alun Ash
$30+ for a pizza that was horrible. I hate to say it but I have had better $6 frozen pizzas.the toppings were scarce and the crust was soggy.will never order from there again
Always excellent food! The pizza is worth the trip!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
WoOhOoo great place to have pasta 🤩🥂🥇
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always good! This place became our favourite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anam and Hassan have made our evening a few days back amazing. Everything was fantastic, the service, the food... Unforgetable. Please, keep up the good work. Thanks for everything. We'll be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in town! Not even comparable to others. Its a whole different level although new pricing & taxes is disappointing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Excellent pizza, it is pricey for what you get. I would have expected a bit more toppings and basil on the pizzas
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I recently visited Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza Milton and it was such a pleasant surprise!
From the outside, it looks quite ordinary—but the moment you step in, it feels like you’ve been transported straight to Italy. The cobbled-style interiors, rustic charm, elegant chandeliers, and even a beautiful wall wine cellar—every detail has been thoughtfully designed to create an authentic Italian vibe.
We ordered the lunch special, which included a Margherita pizza, pomodoro pasta, bruschetta, and soda. Every single dish was bursting with flavor. The pizza was perfectly balanced, the pasta was rich and comforting, and the bruschetta was fresh and delicious.
Honestly, the meal was so satisfying, we walked out in a full-on food coma 😄
If you’re looking for authentic Italian food with a cozy, immersive ambiance, this place is definitely worth a visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
While we were around Milton, one of my buddies suggested this place. He had been here multiple times. Considering we are vegetarian, sometimes its hard to find amazing taste and flavor at authentic places but this place is an exception.
Amazing food, nice ambience, good service and especially awesome taste and presentation.
I would definitely recommend to visit here if you want to try Italian.
Try their Pizza and Pasta. Especially the ravioli, it was amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
We’ve been regulars here for about two years, mainly because of the wonderful waitresses. It was disappointing to find out that their hours were cut and they were eventually replaced, as we never saw them again. Also tips don’t go directly to the waitresses and prices have gone up while portions have gone down. A 5-piece appetizer that used to cost $12 is now $13 for only 3 pieces. Unfortunately, it just doesn’t feel worth it anymore and it’s not the same without those waitresses we were so excited to be greeted with.
We went to dinner last night. It has been a while since we last visited, and over the years the atmosphere has certainly changed. To begin, the entrance walkway was not even plowed or salted. Second, the service needs to be polished; opening a beer can and pouring as well not understanding what fresh pepper should be basic service at a restaurant. The food remains very good, but playing music would help improve the atmosphere. Overall there is clear contrast from the Streetsville location in terms of atmosphere and service. Moving forward, we will only go to the streetsville location.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
It was such an amazing place to go in. We didn't have a reservation but they gave us the cutest spot to sit in the corner it was so ascetic. All the staff was so friendly. We got two wood oven pizzas and they were delicious. We ordered the Napoletana sized pizza, one Marghertita and the other was Pollo Piccante. We went in hungry but it was more than enough for left overs. Definitely a great spot to go to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Wood Oven Pizza
Goodfellas is my go-to Italian spot.
Wood-oven pizza perfection — hands down the best Margherita in town.
Obsessed with the crema di tartufo pasta (that mushroom sauce 🤌)
Whenever i need a little uplifting, i got here
The atmosphere is so calm and has that
comforting vibe. I also recently tried their risotto and really enjoyed it — cooked beautifully and full of flavor.
Bonus points for serving halal options, which makes it even better. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was good (we were the only two people in there). My son and I both had the ravioli. It was very good, but the portion should have been a kids meal. We each counted 6 ravioli...6 😞 for 25.00 a plate. Decided to get a pizza to go. Told 25.00 for a 4 slice or 50.00 for a 12 slice. We got the 4 slice (about the size of a medium pizza). Food was good, but for the price, the portions were a huge disappointment 😞
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Didn't like the pizza there was little to no flavor and the gnocchi dish was NOT homemade and way too much cheese in the so called Alfredo sauce. Very disappointed
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
$30+ for a pizza that was horrible. I hate to say it but I have had better $6 frozen pizzas.the toppings were scarce and the crust was soggy.will never order from there again
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Loading...