Jay's Ice Cream & Sunshine's Gelato

146 Main St E, Milton
(905) 875-1313

Recent Reviews

Extreme Auto Refinishing Steve Morgado

Absolutely loved this place! The staff was amazingly friendly and super polite!Great flavors to choose from!It's definitely worth the drive! Your family and kids will love it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Fudge Brownie One, Gelato Flavor, Banana Split, Twist Soft Serve Ice Cream Cone, Mango Sorbet, Mango Ice Cream, Black Raspberry Cheesecake, Banana Fudge, Espresso Flake and Pistachio Almond, Pistachio Almond, Butter Pecan, Butterscotch, Salted Caramel, Baby Cone, Double Scoop Waffle Cone One Scoop of Cherry Cheesecake One Scoop of Blueberry Cheesecake, Birthday Cake, Rainbow Sherbet

joyce zhu

ice cream was good but they had only one person working cashier and scooping. took half an hour to get two scoops.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Amira Hasan

No cash? And no samples? The girls were really rude with their answers too because sometimes it's not what you say but how you say it. There are many other options in town where you'll actually be treated like a guest instead of a worm, so why would anyone go here?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Chandrika D

I went with a few of my friends and I had a great time, I had advised them this is a mom-and-pop shop and makes the ice cream fresh. So it's a very popular spot in Milton. Great helpings, the girl even gave me an extra scoop for me to try the other flavour I was interested in ☺️

Amit Walia

Solid independent spot for ice cream. They make their own banana ice cream which is very good. Staff have always been good to deal with.

Manan Kapoor

Sp had been looking for a particular Coconut Ice Cream since early 2000s. Found it here. The staff is great and pleasant to speak to. They never fuss despite being busy during summer. Prices are reasonable and portions are large.Love the old world Ice Cream Parlor feel.

Don Leo

No cash are you kidding me ? I came all the way from Scarborough to try your ice cream and only had cash . (left cards at home). Kids crying because I couldn't get the ice cream and girl who worked didn't seem to care . Wow ! Heartless humans still exist. I'll never support this trash place . She just blame covid ! What's covid have to do with not accepting cash ? I lost my respect to this town . It's not the same it was 20 years ago.

Holly

Best place for Ice Cream Cakes! It is less expensive than Marble Slab, Dairy Queen and Baskin Robbins. However the Ice Cream is the same as used in both Marble Slab and Baskin. When you order a Birthday Cake they let you pick two flavors as well as a cookie crumble if you wish which contains gluten or wheat if that is an issue. So these cakes are custom. Love the flavors and this is where we now buy our Birthday Cakes 10.00 less and also bigger than Marble Slab ?

Arif Amjad

Top notch ice cream. Good customer service and good prices.

CardBoard VeryCrunchy

Nice ice cream reminds me of one of those old ice cream parlors in the 1990s really like old trendy style its a bit overpriced but I LOVE the waffle cone the flavor was really POWERFUL like addicting so I think the pricing was worth it

Nik Thakkar

One of my favorite places to visit in Milton with family. All the ice cream flavors are great. It is located right in downtown and it's a must visit if you are coming to Milton

Eman Asif

Poor customer service.. two girls serving were full of attitude. We came in quickly decided on a flavour, didn’t waste any time etc and the entire time they were behaving as if they were doing us a favour. Extremely uncomfortable visit with two young kids (who were also very behaved). No samples even though every other icecream place does that .. icecream it self was ok. Some ice pieces. Wouldn’t recommend due to unpleasant servers & ok quality.

Kris Vathsalan

They have so many different kinds of iced treats and so many flavours! They have hard ice cream, soft-serve, gelato, sorbet, sherbet, milkshakes and more! Each and every flavour we got was delicious. They have the conventional flavours but also many unique flavours as well. We tried the lime mojito sorbet, cannoli gelato, s’mores, cinnamon bun, monster cookie and banana fudge ice cream. The sorbet was so refreshing and all the other flavours were so decadent and had a decent amount of mix-ins. The service was also super sweet and fast.

SA Tangerine

Ice cream was good - got the cookie dough on waffle cone. Service was underwhelming, and they don’t take cash. Won’t be back for this reason cause I can’t support a cashless society!

J “JLRZX” R

A few varieties of ice cream, some usual and some not so usual. Good luck if you want to try before you buy, no samples!! Probably betlst to be a bit adventurous at another ice cream shop.

Load More

Jay's Ice Cream & Sunshine's Gelato

146 Main St E, Milton, ON L9T 1N6
(905) 875-1313