Jay's Ice Cream & Sunshine's Gelato

$$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
146 Main St E, Milton
(905) 875-1313

Customers' Favorites

Recent Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
3.6 (49)
Restaurantji Rating

I went with a few of my friends and I had a great time, I had advised them this is a mom-and-pop shop and makes the ice cream fresh. So it's a very popular spot in Milton. Great helpings, the girl even gave me an extra scoop for me to try the other flavour I was interested in ☺️

Restaurantji Rating

Sp had been looking for a particular Coconut Ice Cream since early 2000s. Found it here. The staff is great and pleasant to speak to. They never fuss despite being busy during summer. Prices are reasonable and portions are large.Love the old world Ice Cream Parlor feel.

Restaurantji Rating

Best place for Ice Cream Cakes! It is less expensive than Marble Slab, Dairy Queen and Baskin Robbins. However the Ice Cream is the same as used in both Marble Slab and Baskin. When you order a Birthday Cake they let you pick two flavors as well as a cookie crumble if you wish which contains gluten or wheat if that is an issue. So these cakes are custom. Love the flavors and this is where we now buy our Birthday Cakes 10.00 less and also bigger than Marble Slab ?

More Reviews(126)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 3 - 8PM
Tuesday 3 - 8PM
Wednesday 3 - 8PM
Thursday 3 - 8PM
Friday 3 - 9PM
Saturday 12 - 9PM
Sunday 12 - 8:30PM
Updated on: