6 Best Chicken Wings near New Hamburg

“Placed an order for pickup through the app for the triple treat box and it did not disappoint! The order was correct and ready upon the requested pickup time. 2 medium pizzas, chicken bites, bread sticks, a giant chippits cookie and two dipping sauces for less than $45.00? Send me!“

“We placed a large pick up order for a family gathering at the end of August 2025. The pizzas were done right, at the right time. The staff was friendly, and acknowledged the milestone birthday we were celebrating. Customer service A+, Food Quality A+, Value for Cost A+. We highly recommend their restaurant, and we will be back again! Thank you!“

“I can’t say enough good things about Tito’s! I’ve been a regular for a while, and they never disappoint. Recently, there was a mix-up with my order—there was a miscommunication with the front of house and another customer accidentally took it home—but the owner (great guy) went above and beyond to make it right. Not only did they remake my entire order, but they also refunded me! Their customer service is absolutely top-notch, and the quality of the food is always amazing. This is why Tito’s remains my favourite pizza joint in New Hamburg!“

“In searching for a non-chain and local place to get wings, I was a bit hesitant to order from here - typically, we've had bad and inconsistent experiences with small "local" shops. We took a chance here after reading some VERY good reviews. We're also a sucker for a feel good story, and this couple seemed like their customer service (and wings) were too good to pass up.

Well, let me tell you, the reviews are all 100% accurate! The wings are great - big, well-breaded (not too much/little) and sauced properly (I worked at Wild Wing in high school, I'm a sauce snob). We also took a flyer on the butter chicken, and it was also great. That said, their real crowning achievement was how genuinely friendly and welcoming they were. These are people that love the community they work (and I assume live) in, and truly appreciate the business they get.

If you're thinking about ordering wings from here, do it.

Order - 1 pound of xtra hot, 1 pound of hot/honey, 3 blue cheese dips (they have the good off-colour blue cheese) and the butter chicken.“

“I ordered online a thin pepperoni pizza and i didn’t know that comes with oregano, my son can’t eat it with different flavours. I talked with them and they make a new one right away, even though it was a busy night and they had lots of orders to do . the stuff here it’s friendly and great. they didn’t want to charge me for the second one. We get our pizza from here all the time . Please make sure to leave a great tip for the hard working guys.“

“This is one of my favourite places to get vegan pizza, but if I'm honest, we often just pop in for the cheesy bread. I'm not a fan of the default dip that comes with it, but they will happily give you tomato sauce instead. The pizza is also pretty good. In fact, I think the pizza is even better the next day, cold.“