Absolutely amazing. You can tell how much care goes into the food here. Everything made in-house, from the focaccia bread to the garlic dip. The prosciutto sandwich was a particular standout!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto
C V
Absolutely delicious. Fair price. Pleasant customer service. Ordered the Calabrese Newyorker and cheese/pepperoni. Great crust, fresh tasting, loved the sauce.
Matthew Hughes
This is a great lunch spot, has been for 20 years!
S “SuzeKm”
Great New York style pizza.
hazariah siti
We ordered the margherita and new yorker pizzas to go. Beautiful undercarriages, delicious zzas ALLL dayyyyy. 100% We’ll definitely order again! 😁
Food: 5
Martin Ryalen
Sad to write this as I try to support locally owned businesses. Ordered from Best Pizza tonight and it was not great. hardly any toppings, very little cheese (even though we ordered extra cheese), way too much sauce.
Over the years this was my go to pizza place and it was always delicious. I know it’s changed ownership and now it’s probably one of the worst pizzas in town.
As a side, the menu has also gotten really small, I used to order the hamburger with fries and gravy all the time but now the menu is just lacking, quality is not good and I’ll have to find another pizza joint to order from in the future.
Food: 2
Lisa Anne Harrison
We tried the pizza tonight and it was so delicious! Such good sauce and toppings. Reasonably priced and very lovely people running it! Support local! We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Siyuan Cheng
Probably one of the best spots for lunch in Newmarket. Hands down. 15 at most for a fantastic sandwich, better food and cheaper than McDonald’s for real food.
Expect quality level of a $20+ sandwich if you were downtown, great food, great people who run the place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Negin Sari
Amazing Italian sandwiches! I got the Italian Deli. The bread was freshly made when I ordered and the sandwich was scrumptious!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Deli
Yasmine Karsli
Hidden gem! Got the Brooklyn pizza. Absolutely delicious the crust was perfectly crispy and light, toppings were fresh and the flavours were all spot on. Definitely recommend trying it out
If Dave portnoy came here it would be 8.5 or higher. Been to many pizza joints and been trying to find something like this close to home. Knocked it out of the park.
Miriam Hinde
I ordered only because of the ratings. Unfortunately I will not be reordering from here as the pizza was underwhelming to say the least. The crust was so chewy and pizza greasy and not even appetizing to look at.
Food: 1
Mike Ragone
Just picked up a veal sandwich and no joke the guy makes the bread fresh to order for me like who does that man. It was crazy fresh and seasoned perfectly and tasted amazing. I also got a hot honey pizza which sounds weird but it was amazing as well.
I recommend this place to anybody you won't be disappointed.
Drew M
The name speaks for itself—truly the best pizza in the area. After moving north from Toronto, we were thrilled to find a spot that rivals the top downtown pizzerias. It’s become our go-to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Tharren
Hands down the best sandwich EVER! They make the bread fresh. I don’t live close so anytime I’m in Newmarket, we stop here to grab a sandwich. Haven’t tried the pizza yet but have heard it Is also delicious. Staff are kind and easy to order with, they ask you wait 15 mins while they make the bread fresh. Prices are also fair for a fresh sandwich which is pretty large.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caprese, Italian Deli, Prosciutto
Absolutely amazing. You can tell how much care goes into the food here. Everything made in-house, from the focaccia bread to the garlic dip. The prosciutto sandwich was a particular standout!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto
Absolutely delicious. Fair price. Pleasant customer service. Ordered the Calabrese Newyorker and cheese/pepperoni. Great crust, fresh tasting, loved the sauce.
This is a great lunch spot, has been for 20 years!
Great New York style pizza.
We ordered the margherita and new yorker pizzas to go. Beautiful undercarriages, delicious zzas ALLL dayyyyy. 100% We’ll definitely order again! 😁
Food: 5
Sad to write this as I try to support locally owned businesses. Ordered from Best Pizza tonight and it was not great. hardly any toppings, very little cheese (even though we ordered extra cheese), way too much sauce.
Over the years this was my go to pizza place and it was always delicious. I know it’s changed ownership and now it’s probably one of the worst pizzas in town.
As a side, the menu has also gotten really small, I used to order the hamburger with fries and gravy all the time but now the menu is just lacking, quality is not good and I’ll have to find another pizza joint to order from in the future.
Food: 2
We tried the pizza tonight and it was so delicious! Such good sauce and toppings. Reasonably priced and very lovely people running it! Support local! We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Probably one of the best spots for lunch in Newmarket. Hands down. 15 at most for a fantastic sandwich, better food and cheaper than McDonald’s for real food.
Expect quality level of a $20+ sandwich if you were downtown, great food, great people who run the place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing Italian sandwiches! I got the Italian Deli. The bread was freshly made when I ordered and the sandwich was scrumptious!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Deli
Hidden gem! Got the Brooklyn pizza. Absolutely delicious the crust was perfectly crispy and light, toppings were fresh and the flavours were all spot on. Definitely recommend trying it out
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
If Dave portnoy came here it would be 8.5 or higher. Been to many pizza joints and been trying to find something like this close to home. Knocked it out of the park.
I ordered only because of the ratings.
Unfortunately I will not be reordering from here as the pizza was underwhelming to say the least.
The crust was so chewy and pizza greasy and not even appetizing to look at.
Food: 1
Just picked up a veal sandwich and no joke the guy makes the bread fresh to order for me like who does that man. It was crazy fresh and seasoned perfectly and tasted amazing. I also got a hot honey pizza which sounds weird but it was amazing as well.
I recommend this place to anybody you won't be disappointed.
The name speaks for itself—truly the best pizza in the area. After moving north from Toronto, we were thrilled to find a spot that rivals the top downtown pizzerias. It’s become our go-to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best sandwich EVER! They make the bread fresh. I don’t live close so anytime I’m in Newmarket, we stop here to grab a sandwich. Haven’t tried the pizza yet but have heard it Is also delicious. Staff are kind and easy to order with, they ask you wait 15 mins while they make the bread fresh. Prices are also fair for a fresh sandwich which is pretty large.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caprese, Italian Deli, Prosciutto
Loading...