Cousins Steak House & BAR

110 Pony Dr, Newmarket
(905) 895-8053

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Becky Martins

The dinner I had was fantastic! Homemade. And the owner is super nice! I highly recommend you try out this gem! 10 out of 10 👍

thomas mcgill

My steak was perfect, and my lobster was beautifully soft and flavourful mash potatoes where amazing and vegetables were cooked perfect 👌 i give this restaurant 100 stars

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Timon Lau

Came in for dinner with some friends. The staff were accommodating to help us make a last-minute reservation, even with a large party in the other room. The place is quite nice and comfortable, and the servers attentive. We were a little disappointed with the thinness of the steak, although it was cooked and seasoned well. Glad we came!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

MOHD_ RAFEEQ

We visited cousins steakhouse last night and were impressed by both the food and service. The Smokey BBQ Ribs were tender and flavourful, the chicken souvlaki was perfectly seasoned, and the haddock fish plate was crispy and fresh. The portions were generous, and the service was excellent- friendly, attentive and efficient. It made for a fantastic dining experience and we’ll definitely be returning.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael B

Placed an order with skip.
Last time they did forget my 2 Pepsi-Cola.
Probably 3 months ago.
I placed an order tonight. Called the store and brought up how they forgot my pops months and months ago.
They remembered my order. Added 2 pops no questions asked.
The food.
2 Montreal smoked meats.
Amazing.
Pilled high.
Good amount of fries.
Great experience

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wayne Forhan

21.00 for a glass of wine. Ridiculous price
The salmon was dry according to most of our party that had salmon. There was very little chicken in my wife's pasta chicken
dish. No garlic bread supplied with pasta dishes. And we were limited to four dishes to choose from. We will not visit this restaurant in the future.
Wayne

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Allison Barker

We had a great first experience with Cousins tonight! The food was amazing with very generous portions. The service was excellent.

All in all, fabulous!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cheryl King

Food was fantastic, the place was clean and quiet and our server was a lovely lady. Portions were amazing, flavourful definitely will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Club House Sandwich, Chicken Souvlaki Dinner, Greek Salad

Sheri Cawston

Food was lackluster. Fries were not cooked enough. Would not go again. Waitress was not very good

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mark Reed

More details will be on my blog for my followers.

Location: the restaurant itself is a bit hidden but next to a hotel. It has a bit of an old Italian Tuscany feel and look. Being a Wednesday it was very empty.

Service: this is hard to be critical ... the lady was quite nice but lacked simple things. I start my meals off when doing reviews with a cocktail. I ordered a Negroni to which I got ... I don't know what that means. No attempt to talk to the bartender just staring at me. If you are a steakhouse and bar there 3 main cocktails you MUST know. 1) Manhattan 2) Old Fashioned 3) Negroni. They are iconic. With her lack of effort I just take a red wine. Here is where this costs them. I determine how much I am about to spend based on this. If you can't make 1 of the 3, I pass on appetizers, desert and a scotch to finish. I will say she was attentive but never asked if I wanted more wine. Just got .. anything else after my food was done.

Food: I've seen some good reviews so I was hopeful.

Stater was a Ceasar salad. It was OK and a fair.portion. Would prefer to see homemade croutons for the price but overall dressed properly and flavour was good.

Main: I order a sirloin med rare with fries and veg for sides.

Fries. Store bought frozen. At $34 I expect better than Costco Cavendish.

Veg: 1 carrot, 1 small beet and bok choy. Interesting combination. Cooked properly but kinda light on the portion.

Steak: perfect med rare .... but zero seasoning. Salt and pepper are essential, especially when grilling. Just lacked flavour.

As I said. No dessert when you can't even google Negroni.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Victoria Bigger

I was having a very tough time finding a restaurant to eat at that had not already disappointed me in the past with either bad service , food etc … i can assure you i was not disappointed even the slightest while visiting cousins this past week with my family ! We had never eaten there before and wanted to try something new and I’m so glad we did . The food was excellent, service was amazing as well and over all i will be going back . Steak was seasoned beautifully and veggies were perfectly cooked . 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nallanathan Prasanthan

Amazing food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Souvlaki Dinner

Stephen Davis

Portions are large
Food is well prepared
We were there for a small wedding celebration and the staff were excellent.
A diamond in the rough.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Souvlaki Dinner

T McGregor

I got delivery....the sauce that com a with the bacon-wrapped scallops is insane. I know it's homemade. You could never purchase something that good. Next time I will just order a bucket of it and dip whatever in it. A spoon will do.

Food: 5

Vee Elsie (VLC)

Good portion sizes

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Loading...