Nutmeg Bakeshop

256 Main St S, Newmarket
(289) 796-1802

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

Stuffed Cheddar Cheese Bread

Cronut and Cheese Biscuits

Runny Butter Tarts

Assorted Cruffins

Assorted Pastries

Nutella Cruffin

Coffee Cake

Croissant

Photos

+25 photos

+24 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Ordernutmegbakeshop

Recent Reviews

A cute little bakery on Main St. New Market. We went after lunch in the afternoon so most of their pastries were sold out already, so I grabbed a chocolate chip maple dip.
Very decadent and pairs well with a black coffee.

Next time I’m in the neighbourhood I’ll be back to try some other items.

September 2025

Dangerously delicious and full of temptation — this bakery is our go to heaven. The cheddar jalapeño sourdough? Life-changing. If a bread could win awards, this one deserves a trophy and a standing ovation. So DELICIOUS. As for the cinnamon cruffin pull-apart… let’s just say my kids turn into wild animals when it hits the table (including myself). It’s their all-time favorite dessert. If you’re looking for something delicious for an everyday bite or special occasion,...

April 2025

I placed an order for same day pastries on a Thursday and unfortunately there was a mix up and my order was not ready when I arrived. The owner was so apologetic she gave me a dozen complimentary cookies (which were absolutely delicious). She had my order ready before opening the following day and threw in another box of complimentary pastries. She was so kind and rectified the situation immediately + more! My party raved about the pastries all day long! 10/10

April 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Newmarket, ON

Nutmeg Bakeshop

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Nutmeg Bakeshop