The Penalty Box

57 Carl Hall Rd, Toronto
(416) 398-1862

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Pat Vecchiarelli

The only good thing was french fries. Over priced food and not alot of menu options.
Food service was cold and salad not appetizing
Small portions for your money
Not worth going back ever.

Rylan Morel

fantastic service !! super fast and efficient, as well as super friendly! Abby was amazing!

Hank Ban

Nice spot. Not overly busy but weird hours.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

ives ivusic

Food was decent but waitress...Such a horrible service, rude, arrogant

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Emma Rosen

Our server Lorenzo was extremely nice. The food came out quickly and was good. The other servers were talking the whole time and it was hard to get their attention

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Rhodes

Daniel and company always take care of our

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashton McQuaid

No substitutions

Brian Gouthro

Great chicken sandwiches!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Terry

Food was tasty but poutine portion is small. Had to seat ourselves, waitress was indifferent and bordered on rude, didn’t give us enough menus, put jug of water on table with plastic cups had to serve ourselves,. No cutlery. No condiments for burger, burger was barely warm. Waitress never asked if we needed anything. Waited ++ for the bill. Won’t eat here again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

michelle witcher

Sat down at a table. No one greeted us. Had to ask for a menu. Asked 2 different servers for assistance. No one came. Clearly, it was an extremely busy day and there was not enough help.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kris Howson

Food was good, my partner got tacos, dad got wings, and I got the handmade chips, all were actually pretty good for rink food. Was pretty cool to be able to sit in a toasty place, eat food and also see into one of the rinks. My bone to pick is the service. Absolutely horrendous. Our waitress looked like she’d rather be sticking bamboo shoots up her nails than service us, she’d never ever heard of “service with a smile”, or if she had, she said “nope” to that. Besides putting plates of food on our table, she did nothing. Didn’t check on us, not once, we had to go find her or go to the bar if we wanted more water, and when we asked for a napkin because one of the waters spilled, she left to the back and just never came back so we had to figure out that mess ourselves. We thought maybe we’d be regulars for the convenience but after the terrible service, we’ll just eat before we come here.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Julie Serbinek

Sat a dirty table for over a 45minutes. Not a single staff member checked on us. We flagged a waitress down and she said someone would come, 15 minutes later - still no one but all the other tables around us were being served even though we were there before them. Don’t waste your time, BP’s is a two minute drive

Swagcat66yt Gaming

Awful experience very rude

VoudouLounge

Nice place to grab a bite or a drink before or after the game. Nice selection of cold beers on draught and I’m pretty sure the foods ok too from what I saw.

Ashton Prout

Staff was extremely rude and kept ignoring

Loading...