14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Orangeville

“My husband and younger sister recently had dinner at Boston Pizza and we wanted to thank you for the wonderful evening. The food was superb, was the service. A special thanks to our host Guneet who looked after us and did so with a smile.“

“The food here is always outstanding!!!!!!! Service and staff are warm and welcoming, best place in town to eat and celebrate with friends and family.“

“I recently visited this place in Orangeville and it becomes my favorite pizza store in town. The friendly and supportive staff ensure quick service. Prices are pocket-friendly, especially with frequent deals and promotions, making it a great value.“

“Have pizza delivered to our home 25 minutes away and still hot!! Pizza and wings were excellent!! Delivery people always friendly. Awesome service all round!!“

“Best in town guys. We were having home party and it was almost 3 party size pizzas first we were planning to dine in but then we decided to order at home and all the food was well delivered by your driver . His name was harry and he was charm and nice person . Thank you so much guys .“

“I did an online order at the store because there was no option for thick crust . I wasn't sure what they called it the lady was very friendly and helped me do the online order . The pizza was perfect as usual . It's my go to place for pizza in Orangeville“

“Amazing dinner ❤️ So lucky to have this gem in our neighbourhood!“

“Literally THE BEST pizza I’ve ever had/around.
Ordered 5 party pizzas for my buck and doe, and the whole crowd was raving about how good of pizza it was.
The flavours were favouring!!

Also the service and ownership is tip notch, support this amazing pizza place! ☺️“

“4 outta 5 stars would be 5 stars if they were open until 11 frustrating when I work until 1030 and can’t grab it on the way home“

“great staff great food, quick and fast service, pricing is good aswell.“

“I recently visited Pizza Hut, and I have to say the experience was made 10x better thanks to Kimi! She was incredibly kind, professional, and attentive from the moment I walked in. You can tell she really cares about her work and the customers. My order was accurate, the food came out fast, and she made sure everything was just right. Her friendly attitude and positive energy made my day.

If you go to this Pizza Hut, ask for Kimi—you won’t be disappointed! 🙌🍕“

“Johnnys is hands down a gem ESPECIALLY in this little town. It is not only about the pizza it’s more than 2 decades of caring about the community, it’s over 2 decades of providing young people with their first jobs -It’s more than 2 decades of never being dragged for violating employees (especially young) - you don’t see that anymore Johnnys support the community from animals to kids and they do not advertise the good they do. It’s a gem of a place owned by a good family old school codes / old school values and one of the last standing here that operates under that mantra. It’s not PR it’s not fake it’s just a good place that deserves to be supported and recognized. Old school pies - homemade/ lasagna homemade sauce is done only by the owner - no you’re not going to get butter chicken on your pie here - no freakin Marsala pizzas. Simple , classic old school pizza and THANK G for it. Johnnys is literally a town icon - if you know you know👊🏆👏“

“Great pizza cooks working there! Very thoughtful and kind with our daughter which we all appreciated. And there were special add-ons and it felt like they weren't just making it cause it was an order and we really enjoy this location as a result. Keep it up girls and guys!“

“I honestly don’t understand how this guy at Pizza Pizza does it, but he is, without a doubt, the undisputed pizza god in town right now. I’ve been telling my friends, family, and basically anyone who will listen that Pizza Pizza has some of the best pizza around, and everyone looks at me like I’m crazy 😂 But I’m serious.

There’s a taller guy with blonde hair who works here, probably late 20s/early 30s, and this isn’t some hit-or-miss thing with him. Every single time I’ve had him make my pizza, it’s been absolutely insane. I’ve had pizzas made by other people here, and I’ve tried plenty of other pizza places around town, and this guy specifically is just on another level.

I don’t know what it is about him, but you can tell he actually has a passion for making the pizza. Even a simple two-topping pizza somehow looks and tastes like so much more. The crust comes out perfectly, with those bubbles coming up from underneath the cheese, everything is evenly placed, cooked properly, and just looks like someone actually took their time and took pride in making it.

At this point, I genuinely want to know this guy’s schedule because if I’m ordering pizza, I want HIM making it. 😂 I don’t really care what anyone else says right now — this man is the undisputed pizza god in town.

Pizza Pizza, give this man a raise. Seriously. Whatever he’s doing, keep him doing it, because this guy is making some ridiculous pizza.“