Central Smith Creamery

739 Lindsay Rd, Selwyn
(705) 742-5867

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kyla Rupert

Now I may get a few haters I’m gonna say it anyway. I have always been a Kawartha Dairy kind of gal but today it changed it up for me. I went to the mandarin and they serve Central smith ice cream I tried the birthday cake flavour and OMG amazing!
I don’t know what you have done but it’s 100% better!

sahel b

Its not open sundays although its advertised otherwise!!! Unhappy

Jaffna City

There's nothing better than a scoop of Central Smith Creamery ice cream. Love it .

Life of a Bachelor

Refuses to sell to local Canadian business. Trying to open small independent convenience stores and ice cream trucks and won’t sell. Says I need to go through Sysco foods. Sysco foods refusing to do business. Not looking for credit. Just looking to purchase ice cream to sell.

Lyndsay Galica-Morrissey

Love Central Smith! We drive out of our way just to get ice cream there! Watermelon and Lavender Lemonade are delicious!!! So happy that we can buy a tub (or 2) and enjoy at home!

Bruce Taunton

Sooooo good 👍 Delicious offerings, huge cones and fair pricing .

KELLY MARINO

Tasty ice cream and great staff!

Ligeia Niu

Rum and raisin is best! My kids love
Algonkin canoe! In my heart, this store is better than kawartha lake!

Tom Brohm

Great product and customer service. Tons of history and charm.

Dwijen Thakore

Awsome icecream and friendly staff

Kiran Parihar

Many flavors to explore—I’ve visited several times this summer and always enjoyed the experience! So far, my favorite flavor has to be the Blueberry Bliss. Highly recommend checking this place out!

Richard A

Did not live up to the hype. How can an icecream place not have chocolate icecream at 2pm on a Saturday?

Pia Luong

It was hot day and we wanted to try some local ice cream. 🍦. Central Smith Creamery had a very nice and smooth texture. We ordered a cone and a 1.89 L to take home.
They don’t wrap or give you anything for the take home ice cream, so remember to bring something yourself. It was also a little softer than I expected, but was delicious and smooth in my mouth.

Papia Dutta

Great to visit on a hot summer day!
This place is all about the experience of stopping on the side of the road in the middle of the country to have some locally made ice cream on a hot day.

This place is more about the experience than the ice cream itself.

The great thing about Central Smith Creamery is that they have a tonne of flavours and also offers a few dairy free options making it a great stop for the whole gang.

Prices and portions are fabulous!

Laura White

It was a hot day my raspberry cheesecake ice cream went perfectly with the weather. Clean grounds. Lots of parking. Quick service. Really enjoyed it. I got a small dish single scoop for $5. It was quite large. A little pricey. Alot of summery outdoor ambience. A nice treat.

Loading...