12 Best Italian Restaurants in Sault Ste. Marie

“Love their food, always tasty no matter what we get. Their pizza/panzos are some of the best in town!“

“The best Italian restaurant I've been to since I worked in Toronto years ago. First time dining at Arturo and everything was perfect--the food, the service the atmosphere. We'll be back!“

“Always a pleasure when dining here. The staff are above and beyond friendly and the food hits all the right spots. This is our 3rd time eating here when visiting Sault Ste Marie. We will most certainly be coming back on oir next trip in to town.“

“Food was delicious
Amazing customer service
Nice dine in setting
Mussels in white wine was amazing.
I also tried Fettuccini and Veal. Little salty but good.
Hot Toddy was really good.
Ferrero Rocher cheese cake was amazing too.

Plenty of parking spaces“

“I dined at Sandro's while home for Thanksgiving with my family. The food was amazing! I had the buffet, and everything was delicious. It would be nice if there was another salad besides Caesar, and perhaps a dessert besides jello, but I still recommend the buffet. Staff was friendly.“

“The food was exceptional, the Service was great and the atmosphere was fantastic. Great place to eat & golf!! Highly recommend the Root!“

“I picked up a couple pizzas/ pop on a whim yesterday and the guy working was really sweet. He helped me load everything into my car which was unheard of. The pizzas were excellent. And everything for $31 was pretty wild. I'll be back soon!! Thanks for the top notch service :)“

“We were up in the Sault for some hockey and looked up restaurants in the area besides the regular ones we already knew about and came across Gino’s Fired Up Kitchen and Bar. It sounded perfect to try out. And boy was I glad we went. I ordered the build it your own pizza and did not expect the taste and perfect crust that came along with the fired up oven cooking technique they use. I was absolutely blown away by this pizza. I wish i lived closer and not 5 and a half hours away. So jealous lol.“

“My favorite restaurant in the city. Always ordering from here on nights when I work late and don't have the energy to cook. Ive only eaten in once. But I can definitely say it was a wonderful experience. Waiter was so kind and food came out pretty fast.“

“Excellent service. Totally enjoy the food. Love the wine choices, and those wine glasses are a conversation piece..also enjoy Wine Wednesdays with tasty appetizers. Attending this year's Easter Brunch. Looking forward to this event.“

“I don’t know what pizza the critic ate that said this pizza is terrible. I think he needs to brush his teeth! lol 😝 This is the best pizza in the Soo and some of the best pizza I’ve tried in North America and I travel!! I remember growing up eating this and Mrs B’s, back then the two places were almost identical. Something magical in this sauce and dough… I highly recommend this pizza if you haven’t tried it yet. These are the same old recipes I remember from my childhood. The Italians do it the best!! The food is a great value. I’m a foodie and always get a full pepperoni and cheese pizza to take home with me. Unfortunately it’s a days drive away so I don’t get to enjoy it as much as I would like. My Mom gets me this pizza as a treat when I visit and she ordered it this time. Mmmmm good old Mom!!“

“Love Auroras.
Usually get the panzarotti but tried their special this evening.
There wasn’t a wait to be seated and spots were available- I don’t imagine the storm helped that and it was a Tuesday night.
Service staff was a bit standoffish but still professional.
Restaurant is small, but clean and well decorated.
Huge menu available.
One of the Sault staple Italian restaurants. You can also do take out from the hillside location which is great.
Parking was decent tonight as it wasn’t busy however when it is busy it can be challenging and need to park in another adjacent lot.
Preferred to make reservations it just sucks they don’t use open table or the google app for it- so you have to call to do so.
Then also have a take out section attached too.

Reliable consistency in their food.
Prices have gone up for inflation but the food is still delicious and it was worth the visit.“