I'm kinda disappointed, I'm originally from Thunder Bay and have been to the Coney Island I can't even count how many times, food was always great especially that sauce, totally my favorite. Every time I would go to TBay to visit I always made sure to stop in and grab a few containers to take back to Manitoba,bragging about this amazing sauce, long story short, I was recently visiting some family and I was definitely going to get some of that sauce to take back home to wpg for myself and a few friends. When I saw the price for a container I was in shock,not cheap! Needless to say I only got 2 containers for myself. Decided to have it for supper, hot dogs and fries with the sauce! Definitely not what it used to be, super runny,no flavor except for pepper, was actually disgusting, I ended up dumping it was so bad. Two places in TBay I love to always stop at and bring some goodies back to Manitoba with me, The Persian Man and the Coney Island. Sad to say, after paying that price for not quite sure what that sauce was supposed to be, I highly doubt on my next visit I'll be stopping at the Coney Island again! Very disappointed ??
Food: 1
Service: 5
Niall McKee
Coney Island is a classic iconic staple of Westfort. People rave about it. Myself I think it lacks a bit of sauce and would prefer a 5 star bun vs bennet but I understand the connection. Way too much onion on it. So ask for no onion if you aren't a fan. I am a fan of other establishments as far as Coney goes. I feel like the sauce is just not quite flavorful enough. But MANY people love this place. So go try it out for yourself. Very personal old school feel inside. Love the 50s vibe.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Daniel
It's a thunderbay staple ...everyone should come here once and try there coney burgers and coney dogs ..classic food and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jayde Turcotte
Always an amazing experience with the ladies at Westfort Coney Island! The service, is fast and friendly, and the prices can’t be beat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Bruce
The girl with the red hair at Coney Island is super disgusting and mean to other workers and don’t do her job to her best
Food: 3
Service: 1
Jennifer Silvaggio (Wailerette73)
I love coming here the only thing that has changed since childhood is the prices. Always a great experience when I come for lunch. The food is awesome, & service is always wonderful & fast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
crystal seargeant
Coney Island been around as long as ive been around to know about coney Island thats over 30 yrs and still going
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Peter Cloidt
Had the half and half. Not very hot and took quite a while. Service was
Was in the area and had a cheeseburger and hot dog with everything on it. Had been there before and food was all right. This time, cheeseburger was absolutely tasteless. Hot dog was downright bad...weiner tasted like it wasn't even cooked.
Blue Foxxo (ThatBlueFox)
Worst service I've ever experienced, lady behind the counter was unnecessarily rude to me and my friend, we didn't even say anything rude, practically threw the bag of food at me, and then the food there tastes like it was pumped with a bunch of preservatives or something gross, almost inedible.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Darestrum
Bad service from a younger worker, not very welcoming at all to newcomers or first timers. Probably not gonna go back. Prepped food with bare hands after handling cash.
R T
I want to start off by say Coney Island was my fav restaurant in westfort. However, times have changed and so has the food at this local iconic restaurant. I went there today for the first time in a long time. I ordered two hotdogs (no onions) and two cheeseburgers (no onions). Let’s start with the hotdogs. The bun was steamed, soft and tasty. The hotdog itself, was not very good at all. It was over cooked, rubbery, and chewy with no flavor. The Coney sauce was not the Coney sauce I remember, it lacked flavour. Now onto the cheeseburgers. Again the bun was steamed and tasty. However, the actual hamburger meat was over cooked, tough and lacking flavor. The sauce was the same as the hotdogs. Customer service was fantastic. Too bad the food has slipped.
Ayanna Briand
I loved the burger I got and I love the laid back atmosphere!! I'd love to work there! Keep being awesome
I'm kinda disappointed, I'm originally from Thunder Bay and have been to the Coney Island I can't even count how many times, food was always great especially that sauce, totally my favorite. Every time I would go to TBay to visit I always made sure to stop in and grab a few containers to take back to Manitoba,bragging about this amazing sauce, long story short, I was recently visiting some family and I was definitely going to get some of that sauce to take back home to wpg for myself and a few friends. When I saw the price for a container I was in shock,not cheap! Needless to say I only got 2 containers for myself. Decided to have it for supper, hot dogs and fries with the sauce! Definitely not what it used to be, super runny,no flavor except for pepper, was actually disgusting, I ended up dumping it was so bad. Two places in TBay I love to always stop at and bring some goodies back to Manitoba with me, The Persian Man and the Coney Island. Sad to say, after paying that price for not quite sure what that sauce was supposed to be, I highly doubt on my next visit I'll be stopping at the Coney Island again! Very disappointed ??
Food: 1
Service: 5
Coney Island is a classic iconic staple of Westfort. People rave about it. Myself I think it lacks a bit of sauce and would prefer a 5 star bun vs bennet but I understand the connection. Way too much onion on it. So ask for no onion if you aren't a fan. I am a fan of other establishments as far as Coney goes. I feel like the sauce is just not quite flavorful enough. But MANY people love this place. So go try it out for yourself. Very personal old school feel inside. Love the 50s vibe.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
It's a thunderbay staple ...everyone should come here once and try there coney burgers and coney dogs ..classic food and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Always an amazing experience with the ladies at Westfort Coney Island! The service, is fast and friendly, and the prices can’t be beat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The girl with the red hair at Coney Island is super disgusting and mean to other workers and don’t do her job to her best
Food: 3
Service: 1
I love coming here the only thing that has changed since childhood is the prices. Always a great experience when I come for lunch. The food is awesome, & service is always wonderful & fast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Coney Island been around as long as ive been around to know about coney Island thats over 30 yrs and still going
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Had the half and half. Not very hot and took quite a while. Service was
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Some of the best fries and gravy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Staff and food are both great!
Restaurantji Recommends
Was in the area and had a cheeseburger and hot dog with everything on it. Had been there before and food was all right. This time, cheeseburger was absolutely tasteless. Hot dog was downright bad...weiner tasted like it wasn't even cooked.
Worst service I've ever experienced, lady behind the counter was unnecessarily rude to me and my friend, we didn't even say anything rude, practically threw the bag of food at me, and then the food there tastes like it was pumped with a bunch of preservatives or something gross, almost inedible.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bad service from a younger worker, not very welcoming at all to newcomers or first timers. Probably not gonna go back. Prepped food with bare hands after handling cash.
I want to start off by say Coney Island was my fav restaurant in westfort. However, times have changed and so has the food at this local iconic restaurant. I went there today for the first time in a long time. I ordered two hotdogs (no onions) and two cheeseburgers (no onions). Let’s start with the hotdogs. The bun was steamed, soft and tasty. The hotdog itself, was not very good at all. It was over cooked, rubbery, and chewy with no flavor. The Coney sauce was not the Coney sauce I remember, it lacked flavour. Now onto the cheeseburgers. Again the bun was steamed and tasty. However, the actual hamburger meat was over cooked, tough and lacking flavor. The sauce was the same as the hotdogs. Customer service was fantastic. Too bad the food has slipped.
I loved the burger I got and I love the laid back atmosphere!! I'd love to work there! Keep being awesome