Fatty's Pizza

401 May St N, Thunder Bay
(807) 285-7700

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tarandeep Singh

“Slowly, gradually, with great mental resistance but still inexorably, it dawned on me that I had paid $25 for a pizza with almost no flavor. It was burnt, too.”

Kaylee Elizabeth

amazing food! great service and very kind staff

Dina McCabe

Excellent service & food. Prices are very reasonable. All around fantastic. Best pizza in town.

Suzanne Steed

The All dressed pizza is da bomb. We added basil and red onion. I was expecting basil leaves and big chunks of red onion. It wasn't they took the time to sheffonade the basil and slivers of red onion throughout. NO Skimping on product whatsover. Lifetime customers here. Tks Fatty's

Lux G.K

I ordered a pizza and it came 40 mins later it was black underneath my fingers were going black it was cremated. Way to thin not even to mention the delivery man asked to buy weed at the door with the money for the pizza. Honestly I'd much rather any other place although the service was good the people were friendly. Pizza was not even edible it was hard and black to a crisp my dog didnt even want it. It looked nothing like the pictures showed. 25$ for cremated pizza y'all...

Josie Baxter

I loved the selections and the pizza was amazing, not greasy and not cheap with toppings as well. Good prices and good fast friendly service as well which is always important.

Sarah De Corte

Great food great staff

jose mendozachicas

Out of business @may and dease location.......No ....Comment..

James Doe

Wow, very expensive, very much mediocre pizza here. We walked in for takeout and still ended up waiting about an hour for two large pizzas.

Erica Geddes

Didn't give us our pizza

Tyana Young

I gave 4 stars because the pizza presentation was great and it tasted pretty good as well. My only issue was that some of the toppings were a little sparse in my opinion. Other then that I'm happy with both my food and the customer service :)

David Morgan

They are rarely open

Justin B

The place is infested with mice. I wouldn't eat hear if it was the last place in thunderbay

Sean Leveille

I ordered a perogi and a philly cheese steak pizza, smalls just to try. Super friendly staff and driver,they told me when pizzas would be here, and because they were busy, they called me back to let me know they would be a few more mins, which was fine, and then showed up promptly. But all that aside, the quality was through the roof, the pizzas looked picturesque, and were absolutely amazing. Super fresh ingredients and the cheese was out of this world. Price was normal for quality pizza. I would highly recommend this pizza to anyone who is a pizza connoisseur, it will not disappoint.

Bradley Temple

Was late... Delivery guy was an a****

Loading...