Mama Alfa's Pizzeria

I have not been here since the new owners took over but when Mama Alfa and Ralph ran this restaurant it was incredible. Her pasta was made to order, the pizza was delicious and not too greasy, and the ceasar salad was a homemade secret recipe. I understand the new owners have all the old recipes and very much hope they are honouring this local legend. Rest in Peace Mama Alfa. We love you!

In all the years I lived in Thunder Bay, I never once went there or even ordered take out. What a regret. Great food, top-shelf service in a quaint little place that is clean with a feel of “old-school.” We will be back, and soon!

Best crust

Ordered a deluxe pizza that came with virtually no cheese on it but had pineapple. Order was mixed up I am guessing. Was a take out order. Wouldn’t recommend.

Food: 2

Service: 4

Was not what I expected.The lasagna was lacking sauce and spices the Alfredo was more like soup. All in all won’t go back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Definitely will never order from this place again not only was the pizza not what I ordered but they were really rude on the phone and did nothing to fix the problem. I definitely would not recommend them as they won't fix the problem. and horrible rude on the phone. terrible service

Great pizza and even better staff, you have to try the homemade Cesar salad dressing and homemade desserts

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Ground Beef Pizza

Great pizza! Good quality ingredients and great flavour.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Now also houses Seattle Coffee House, so great Coffee, great local and original pizza in a friendly, comfortable environment.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Almost $100 for three large pizzas. Out of the group that we fed everyone was disappointed. One pizza was under cooked, the other didn't have many toppings. We were not pleased, which is a shame as we had people recommend it that had a positive experience. It's tucked out of the way a bit and a little dated inside.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers

Great spot. Pizza super good and coffee great. Friendly lady from southern Ontario ;). I’ll be back when I’m in town.

Haven't had Mama Alfas since I was in highschool I drove past and I decided to call an order from them again to see if it was still as good as I remembered. Oh man was I not disappointed, tasted just like how I remembered! Great place I don't know why I ever stopped going! Great service, great atmosphere and even better pizza! If you haven't tried them then give them a try. You won't be disappointed! 5 stars!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Greek Pizza

the pizza is really greasy and will be the first and last time do not recommend for picky eaters, horrible.

For $50, you expect a decent pizza, but I will never order from here again. I did like it years ago, but they have changed. I don't know if Mama Alfa is still cooking here. She was pretty old when I worked here a couple of decades ago, so I don't think she's still the cook. There's way too much herb in it. No one here liked this at all. It tasted very herby with a lot of cilantro and oregano.The ground beef was little meatballs. The bacon was maybe a tablespoon of dark brown crumbs. You have to look really hard, but you will see the lunchmeat style "ham" that they use on top of the bologne type pepperoni that they use. The crust was overcooked to burnt in places. One of the pizzas was swimming in sauce (which is disgusting), while the other was ok.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

First time is the last time. Pizza wasn't ready and basically think they forgot mine. Waited way too long. Ordered the Gourmet and not very good. Was told it was good food....off night l guess. Not going back.