Conspiracy Pizza

858 Eglinton Ave E, East York
(647) 694-3327

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Geoff May

This is one of my fave pizza joints in Toronto! Big big pies with lots of deliciousness.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: XL Pizza

Eric

I would rank Conspiracy Pizza high as probably one of the most hidden gems in the city for pizza. They offer a very nice selection of custom pizza creations that add creative toppings with a lot of flavour. Their customer service is also 10/10 and will go the distance to ensure that you are properly taken care of, every single visit. This is a very satisfying, enjoyable pizza experience. Highly recommended !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Olivia Morra

Ordered the pepperoni pizza and wings. The pizza was nothing special, kind of floppy and nothing more to say. We ordered the wings, they were small, dry and overcooked. The “mild sauce” on the side wasn’t so mild and tasted sour.

Food: 2

Kat

Came here on Tuesday for a pizza Slice and I was told they are closed Tuesdays and to come back Thursday. Came back Thursday for a slice and they told me they are only doing full pizzas when I've had slices before. Disappointing.

Robin Floyd

Love Conspiracy Pizza. Pizza is delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pizzas

Ryan Dehaney

It was ok.

Leroi Naval

Wanted to try a new pizza spot and did not disappoint. Great pizza and didn’t wait too long either. The employee working there was very nice and she was helpful when we needed anything.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

staz m

Good reviews here must be fake accounts - awful service and mediocre food. Weirdly, business owner response to one-star reviews is to make up a story about the accounts writing them - rather than try to work out the reason for a bad review, which speaks volumes for now this business is run.

pauline williams

There is not one thing I liked about this place! I found the restaurant was dirty and the staff unfriendly. The food in my opinion was gross. I would never recommend this restaurant! Only an idiot would leave a response like this! Your food sucks and so does the atmosphere!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kayla

Response to "owner"

Not only was the pizza gross and the facility unclean, but when I left a 1 star review this "company" accused me of being part of a plumbing company. I am definitely not a plumber. But based on my experience here and the audacity of whoever responded to my review, I might give GA plumbing a call with any of my future plumbing needs. Thank you for showing me that not only is your pizza distasteful, but so is your attitude.

Service: 1

ramsha bhatti

Tried the “dodo bird”, its was amazing when it was fresh! The chicken had a smokey flavor, pairing with onions & bbq sauce took it to the next level. Crust was crispy, slice was soft, however, the only downside was that I didn’t taste the gouda cheese much. The person who made it was extremely nice, and patient. The garlic sauce did feel more of a dressing than dip, but I’d definitely recommend trying this option out.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Adrian Law

Passionate owner, top quality ingredients.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

VoudouLounge

Another top 3 Pizza stop in Toronto. Great value, cooked and topped right, giant slices and tastes incredible. Pepperoni was my favourite if you like it stacked and the Brisket Pizza had a really nice different flavour too but could’ve use a bit more Brisket but still great overall. Another highly recommended stop ??

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Donair Sauce, Hawaiian Pizza, Brisket, Sauce, Cheese Pizza, Pizzas, Cowspiracy Pizza, XL Pizza

ScrambledMegs

Vegan cheese and house-made vegan sausage are available as substitutions. I choose to build my own pizza with those vegan options plus mushrooms, black olives, and diced tomato - very tasty with the mild hot sauce for dipping! Still workshopping a conspiracy-themed name for my pie. 🤔

Alex Fraser

Great neighborhood pizza spot for when you are sick of the big chains. Fresh, fun and super unique pizza options. Always had super friendly service so it’s now our go to for pizza in Leaside.

Loading...