Maison Selby

592 Sherbourne St, Toronto
(647) 943-1676

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sheila

Cozy and very attentive and friendly staff. Caesar salad and beef Bourgogne were very tasty.

Mary

Overall nice experience. The food was tasty but was a little too salty. The ambience was nice. Place is great for a date night as the lights are low. They have festive decor as well for the holiday.

Caroline

Beautifully decorated restaurant atmosphere. My only feedback is, if only the server were willing to accomodate me, and ask the chef if he/she would be able substitute the roasted potatoes for carrots or grilled veggies, that went with the octopus appetizer, that would've made my experience 5 stars!

Jacob

Amazing and will be coming back. Great ambiance, service and the quality of food and drinks are higher than our expectations.

Trish

Maison Selby never disappoints. Food was delicious, best French onion soup in the city. Staff are welcoming and helpful. Great for lunch or dinner.

Anthony

I had specified that we were there for a birthday on the reservation; also told the waiter the same thing when asked. usually they would have a candle on the dessert that was ordered. Another couple did in fact get that while we were there last night. We did not.

Adam Christopher

My girlfriend and I had our first there and we have been going there every month for almost 2 years now. We were always blown away by how amazing everything was, nothing was even close to average. However, this time, for some reason, it was very different. We ordered 2 starters that were always great, and they bad and poorly executed. the beef bourguignon is our go to and this time, it was dry and with almost no vegetables. Also, we had a reservation and, even though we got there on time, we still had to wait 20 min to be sat on a table 2cm away from another couple - if you don’t have the capacity to accommodate that many people, just don’t. It was really disappointing, specially because it’s almost one of our favourite restaurants. I believe they do deserve a second chance but no idea what happened, if they changed the cookers or are under new management.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Agnes

The restaurant was aware that we were celebrating birthday and assigned a very nice table for my family. Our server Lilou provided excellent service and she was so friendly. The food was perfect. We definitely will go to Maison Selby again.

Deb

For lunch the place was freezing. Maybe a weather curtain at the door foyer but hopefully the heat will be more available as winter temps drop!

Jim

The Skirt Steak was very flavourful and tender, and the frites, as always, were excellent!

Alina Miroshnikova

My favourite place of all times❤️ Olga is the one I love the most, she’s the most professional server I’ve ever met🫶🏻

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ash S

The charming, chic and cozy atmosphere at Maison Selby is exquisite. My server was a pleasure. Dishes are presented beautifully. However, the flavour fell short, especially for the price. French onion soup was decent. Escargot was delicious. Beef bourguignon was tasty, but not as tender and somewhat dry. Steak frites lacked seasoning and the jus tasted just okay. At least dinner ended on a good note with the sticky toffee pudding. Overall, I think if the flavours matched the aesthetic this could easily be a 5-star restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Janet

Beautiful, classy restaurant. Cozy ambience. Delicious, classic menu. Food was great. Service was good too. Amazing low-alcohol cocktails too which is a bonus!

Nikko Tuason

The atmosphere gets crazy hectic, loud, and cramped at peak hours. The service was excellent. The staff was friendly, attentive, and professional. The French onion soup and escargot were both delicious and the meal’s highlights.

The only disappointment was the steak frites. I ordered the filet medium rare, but it came out medium, and the fries were lacking seasoning.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Susan V

Had a lovely brunch for my dad’s birthday here today! 🥂 Delicious food and drinks!

A couple minor hiccups with our order but they accompanied the issues very well and it did not at all take away from our overall experience 🙏🏼🎉

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Loading...