The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria

Tasty and High Quality, I recommend all pizzas and sandwiches.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very nice pizza.

Average pizza with too much attitude !

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

The staff is very friendly, their pizza is so fresh and authenic, loved the marinara sauce. Fresh pizza takes time to bake but it was served quite quickly. Thanks for the good time!
P.S. their donuts are the best in town

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stopped by to try a couple of slices, had a cheese, margherita, one toasted coconut donut, and a can of pop. With tax and tip, over $25... by far the most expensive reheated pizza slices I've ever had, and not as good as other places. The margherita had chopped ribbons of basil instead of leaves, but a very good sauce. The regular cheese slice was nothing special. I will admit, the donut was pretty good, but I think a bit stale (my fault, came later in the day). Would give it 4 stars except for the poor value. If I come back, I'd order a whole fresh pizza and see how much better it would be.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

I got influenced. Saw posts online about this location and decided to check it out. Not worth the hype that was put behind it.

First off they need to change their ordering system. It's overly complicated and frankly just annoying. This is an extremely boomer take but I just want a menu I do not want to scan your QR code and then order through an app when I am sitting down at your restaurant.

Mozzarella sticks we ordered were in my opinion over priced and did not live up to expectations. They were quite flavorless and were not overly warm when served to us. I would skip these personally in the future.

The pizza I am torn on. While the size and price were decent I found the pizza to just be mediocre. I ordered a Margherita to share with my partner and we found it to just be overly cheesy. This was of course our own fault for not correctly reading the description of the pizza but neither of us expected a Margherita would be a traditional cheese pizza with extra mozzarella and parmigiana on top. I would recommend going with the create your own option.

Overall an okay experience. Most likely would not return. Donut selection was extremely lacking but it seemed they were doing a large catering order as their entire indoor seating was not accessible.

Awesome pizza, I missed out on the donuts tho

The pizza was amazing! The size is big! And the pi
zza is so saucy- i will come again!

The Fourth Man in the Fire blew us away! The barbecue chicken and margherita pizzas were absolute perfection! Fresh, flavorful, and fire-kissed! 🤌🏻

Fourth man in the fire was my first date spot and it created magic! The pizza is so good and saucy! The crust is to doe for. I will keep coming back !!

Their pizza was really good. Loved the ambience

Crispy cheesy pizza and beer n doughnuts.. everything was great.

Food was excellent. They have chicken cutlet sandwich done in a beautiful vodka sauce - out of this world, A car prese salad so fresh, service was excellent. My waitress was Christie - she was excellent helpf very very pleasant. Nice atmosphere, Nice selection of pizza - the place smelt so good, you gotta check them out - well worth it ! Oh don’t let the massive doughnuts when you walk in the door fool ya - they are huge ! And I mean huge !

THE RATING IS SPECIFICALLY FOR THE DONUTS: if there was a 6th star I would give it to them for the donuts.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Doughnuts

AMAZING
one word tells it all!
Amazing Pizza, Amazing Donuts. I mean Amazing.
Can’t say enough about this place, thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Apple Fritter, Pie, Doughnuts