The Night Baker - College

825 College St, Toronto
(416) 901-5590

Recent Reviews

Sort by
RR

Such a perfect treat to kick off the weekend! So glad they accept customers until the very last minute. Staff were super friendly too! ;)

Bang Buck

Love their unique selection of cookie flavors!

MEL From Toronto

OMG. The best cookies in town! 🤩 Crispy/firm on the outside, soft/chewy, filed-in flavour in the inside! Not too sweet, lots of flavours to choose from! My fave is the ube but I love them all!
Hurry, they sell out fast! ♥️

Wendy Xu

Cookies are pretty pricey but they're so good! Definitely worth trying if you've never had them before. They have a ton of unique flavors and I've never had one that wasn't a hit!

Menta Na

been here a bunch, unique flavors, often hard to choose~

Hiral Patel

Delicious cookies!!! All unique flavors

Eloïse Tassy-Bunyan Ngwiri

This is who Craig’s Cookies think they are.

Megan Bingley- Stanistreet

Ordered 6 on Uber eats and they we’re phenomenal! Looking forward to visiting the store!

Vy Do

Delicious cookiessssss!!!! 🍪

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Cookies, Pandan Coconut Cookie, The Mistachio and Ooh BAE Cookies, Box of 12 Cookies, Cookies

Barbara Marrelli

During our Sunday walk, we stumbled upon Night Baker and were greeted by a friendly representative from Fleischmann's. They were promoting their new baking soda and offering the first 100 visitors a free jar of the product along with a half-dozen assorted cookies. She kindly directed us to the line, and within 10 minutes, we were inside to collect our goodies.

We’d been eager to try Night Baker’s cookies for a while, and this turned out to be the perfect opportunity. The cookies exceeded our expectations—fresh, moist, and full of distinct, delicious flavors. Each one truly delivered on its name. We’ll definitely be back for more!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Cookies

Rose Goodwin

These cookies are the best in the city! Craig who?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Insta Pump

Amazing Cookies…. I found out about their store on the 2G2G app. I ordered 1 and was hooked. When I see them pop up I’ll get a minimum of 2. I might start grabbing 3 if available. It’s a bit far for me but very worth the travel to get some good cookies. Thanks again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Cookies, Pandan Coconut Cookie, Cookies

Nicole Fairbairn

I love this cookie shop. I have loved all the cookies I’ve tried. I’m glad it’s not too close to me because I would be going every day. Love the staff as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yari Ralt

Average at best. Can you imagine if artificial food colouring was added into their cookies? Thinking whether I’ll turn into Hulk with ADHD after eating this.

*REPLY*
Thank you for the reply. By no means am I shaming anyone with ADHD. I was simply raising a question whether this vividly green colour cookie contained artificial colours. If they do, as a consumer we should be aware that artificial colours are scientifically proven to cause ADHD.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Vivian W

Way too sweet for my taste, but I love the soft and chewy texture and bit of crunch on the edges. Staff were friendly and I appreciated that they were wearing masks. Lots of interesting rotating flavours.

Wheelchair accessibility: Did not see a ramp available. There are three steps before the entrance.

Loading...