Oh. My. God. I was at the Weston summer market and had a brownie from Carla’s and let me tell you… LIFE ALTERING. WOW 🤩 amazing service. Large portions and THE FLAVOUR. 🤤 best ever
Jacquie Turner
I placed my order online. It arrived 2 days later. Absolutely best butter tarts I’ve ever had!! Would totally recommend Carla’s Cookie Box.. Customer service was amazing as well
Lidia Ferayanti
Goodddd very delicious
Duane Graves
I've wanted to try the butter tarts for awhile now , I typically don't order things online but I saw a vendor at the aurora street festival and decided to try a couple of the tarts , I usually take alot of photos , lol unfortunately they went fast so I didn't get any but anyways , I've had alot of different butter tarts in my life and I have to say I think these are the best , I had a plain , pecan and turtle tart, I can't say enough about how good these are , highly recommend these , thanks.
Lisa Oki
Based on the photos and a friend’s recommendation, we expected to love the tarts from Carla’s Cookie Box but the crust was surprisingly soggy and not crispy or flaky at all. We got a 6 pack of Traditional (Plain, Raisin and Pecan) and the filling was firm the way we like but alarmingly sweet. I know butter tarts are sweet but these were too sweet. We tried a small piece of each kind and didn’t want to finish them. An expensive lesson learned.
Jodie Osmond
First time ordering Carla's and the cookies were amazing! Each one had a different flavour and were equally enjoyed by all.
Robyn Smith
Ordering was easy. Shipping was pretty fast and as expected. The Butter Tarts are incredible. We usually go to the Butter Tart Festival in Paris to buy Carla’s butter tarts because we love them. My coworkers and I decided to place an order for delivery and we were very excited when they arrived. The flavours are amazing. They freeze well and warm up great in the oven when ready to eat them. Would highly recommend all of Carla’s products. You won’t be disappointed.
S A
Got these from an event tried three different kinds, and there were all amazing!!
Lindsay H
I tried Carla's butter tarts for the first time today at a corporate event. Absolutely the best I have ever had. ❤️ Staff very friendly as well!
MICHELE “MICKIE” MACDONALD
Delivery of raisin butter tarts was quick and the tarts were all in one piece, they were delicious.
While I can’t say anything about the atmosphere of the storefront we grabbed tarts yesterday when you were at Bowmanville Apple Fest. Honestly so good that I would make the drive from any distance they are that delicious. My new favourite tarts beats out any and all competition hands down. Perfect texture, taste and size too. Filling to pastry ratio is absolutely perfect. Highly recommend and will definitely be visiting you again very soon at your storefront.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts
leah stephenson
Carla’s butter tarts are outstanding. I placed an order fairly close to Thanksgiving and Carla went out of her way to ensure I would receive my order in time. Each butter tart was beautifully packaged and labeled and was a perfect little gift I gave my guests. Carla’s tarts are absolutely delicious! I highly recommend! I rated atmosphere because of how the tarts made my guests feel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts
Maia Sibley-Swain
Ordered this for my boyfriend in Canada (from the UK!). Delivery was incredibly fast, and he and his family enjoyed the cookies! His favourite was the turtles flavour. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gourmet Cookie in Different Flavours - 12 Pack
K O (katiezora)
These are the best tarts I have ever had! I tried it for the first time at the CNE and I haven't stopped thinking about these since. 10/10 A MUST TRY!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Menezes
Quick pick up, great follow up emails on instructions. The butter tarts were amazing!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts
Oh. My. God. I was at the Weston summer market and had a brownie from Carla’s and let me tell you… LIFE ALTERING. WOW 🤩 amazing service. Large portions and THE FLAVOUR. 🤤 best ever
I placed my order online. It arrived 2 days later. Absolutely best butter tarts I’ve ever had!! Would totally recommend Carla’s Cookie Box.. Customer service was amazing as well
Goodddd very delicious
I've wanted to try the butter tarts for awhile now , I typically don't order things online but I saw a vendor at the aurora street festival and decided to try a couple of the tarts , I usually take alot of photos , lol unfortunately they went fast so I didn't get any but anyways , I've had alot of different butter tarts in my life and I have to say I think these are the best , I had a plain , pecan and turtle tart, I can't say enough about how good these are , highly recommend these , thanks.
Based on the photos and a friend’s recommendation, we expected to love the tarts from Carla’s Cookie Box but the crust was surprisingly soggy and not crispy or flaky at all. We got a 6 pack of Traditional (Plain, Raisin and Pecan) and the filling was firm the way we like but alarmingly sweet. I know butter tarts are sweet but these were too sweet. We tried a small piece of each kind and didn’t want to finish them. An expensive lesson learned.
First time ordering Carla's and the cookies were amazing! Each one had a different flavour and were equally enjoyed by all.
Ordering was easy. Shipping was pretty fast and as expected. The Butter Tarts are incredible. We usually go to the Butter Tart Festival in Paris to buy Carla’s butter tarts because we love them. My coworkers and I decided to place an order for delivery and we were very excited when they arrived. The flavours are amazing. They freeze well and warm up great in the oven when ready to eat them. Would highly recommend all of Carla’s products. You won’t be disappointed.
Got these from an event tried three different kinds, and there were all amazing!!
I tried Carla's butter tarts for the first time today at a corporate event. Absolutely the best I have ever had. ❤️ Staff very friendly as well!
Delivery of raisin butter tarts was quick and the tarts were all in one piece, they were delicious.
Restaurantji Recommends
While I can’t say anything about the atmosphere of the storefront we grabbed tarts yesterday when you were at Bowmanville Apple Fest. Honestly so good that I would make the drive from any distance they are that delicious. My new favourite tarts beats out any and all competition hands down. Perfect texture, taste and size too. Filling to pastry ratio is absolutely perfect. Highly recommend and will definitely be visiting you again very soon at your storefront.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts
Carla’s butter tarts are outstanding. I placed an order fairly close to Thanksgiving and Carla went out of her way to ensure I would receive my order in time. Each butter tart was beautifully packaged and labeled and was a perfect little gift I gave my guests. Carla’s tarts are absolutely delicious! I highly recommend! I rated atmosphere because of how the tarts made my guests feel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts
Ordered this for my boyfriend in Canada (from the UK!). Delivery was incredibly fast, and he and his family enjoyed the cookies! His favourite was the turtles flavour. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gourmet Cookie in Different Flavours - 12 Pack
These are the best tarts I have ever had! I tried it for the first time at the CNE and I haven't stopped thinking about these since. 10/10 A MUST TRY!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quick pick up, great follow up emails on instructions. The butter tarts were amazing!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts
Loading...