Sheryl's Caribbean Cuisine (formerly Judy's Island Grill Toronto)

Run far...they love to over charge.... I get it. I mean I really get it. Food costs everywhere is expensive, but when you're charging $8 for a $2 drink, it's not acceptable when your prices aren't consistent. Not acceptable.... Coleslaw upwards of eight bucks when they feel like it not acceptable. It's cabbage for crying out loud

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Really good, lovely oxtail. Went with a group of 4.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Macaroni Salad, Rice and Peas, Coleslaw, Ox Tails Rice and Peas Green Salad

Great food

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Rice and Peas, Ox Tails Rice and Peas Green Salad

My friend got Plastic in his oxtail. Took a photo. Went back a day later. They confirmed it was plastic from manufacturer.
We did not get a refund or a new oxtail plate. They offered him a small jerk chicken meal as compensation.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I ordered plain white rice off of Uber eats The price they were charging was $7... No problem ordered it my fault for having expectations at least a full to the top white rice container bussin .... Especially at that price I never thought a company would be so stingy and greedy for white rice my mistake but I'll never do it again

I went there to buy a fish dinner one snapper and was charged $30 for a small dinner which I think is highway robbery when no matter how expensive it is to import one fish dinner should not be $30 . But as they say you only do it once because never again will I buy it.

Food: 3

Service: 1

First choice of where to grab lunch in the neighbourhood the Mon to Wed Chichen special more than enough food a great taste and value . Great daily soups.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I read the reviews and was very excited to try the food so I did on July 19th. I tried the curry goat which was tender but was full of fat and not eatable. I also bought the Fried BBQ which was also not great. The worse was the festivals which were rock hard. Definitely not going back. One of the server was nice but the other grumpy.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

It can more than gwon. Again I had the oxtail rice and peas extra gravy and coleslaw. My guy had curry goat on boil food with extra gravy no dumpling. Than got a small goat soup. Soup sell off second time around! Decent size servings and made it exactly how I ordered it. And they are freindly. Chef came out and said hello and brought out fresh food. Great presentation of food. Pleased yet again! Parking is a challenge sonetimes but not their fault.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

I go for the soup on Thursdays. Chicken soup is exceptional

Such good jerk chicken. Ate leftovers cold the next day and somehow even better. Great patties too.

Excellent tasting food, especially for the cost!

I've been seeaching for an authentic flavourful Caribbean restaurant on Eglinton west for a long time. This is a match made in tummy heaven. The service was exceptional and came with a side of humour. Come here for both the flavour and and experience. Job well done! Shout out to Odette, definitely coming back

Delicious food and excellent service from Jada

Best food ever huge portion do yourself a favour and try this place!😊