Pegasus Pizza - Willamette Street

Excellent pizza, lots of toppings...my favorite is the Mt St Helens. Really good salads, too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is some of the best pizza I have had in years! Little Italy pizza. Staff was welcoming and friendly. Just an excellent experience! This is for the Oakway location!

The pizza is good for Eugene pizza. Salads are delicious. They have very thin crust speciality pizzas, if you’re from the East coast you might not like it. It’s tasty pizza. I ask for extra sauce. I will say the cost of pizza out here is crazy, and they will charge 1$ extra for ranch and don’t tell you. Out in NY, you get blue cheese and ranch on side for free with a HUGE pizza for a fraction of the costs. So it’s a tough adjustment. But still, best pizza out here in my opinion is Sy’s pizza Downtown, Coburg Pizza and Pegasus.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Pizza is mediocre, the staff looks unkept and homeless. 😢

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Pegasus is one of my top 3 pizza joints.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I always love Pegasus when I go to the oakway location but willamette is closer to my house- unfortunately it always a crap experience at Willamette. Missing ingredients on my pizza as well as the crust being burnt (and I don’t mean just a little bit crispy- I mean BLACK and as hard as a hockey puck) and they also forgot our dipping sauces for the cheese bread. Super annoying.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Food was not worth it. Had upset stomach and nausea the next day

What a fun little hidden gem. Definitely best pie in town that I've tasted at least! Been going here for lunch for some time now and the staff is always a blast and the food is extremely well proportioned and super tasty. The Pear Gorgonzola salad is the best accompaniment to any pizza on the menu! Definitely a must visit if you live here or even if you're just passing through👌

I cannot begin to brag enough on this pizza establishment! My son and I just moved across the country and so finances have been a little tough but being that we could both eat for under $10 there what else could you say except amazing. Their food is astronomical. Their service is above and beyond, and I cannot brag about this place enough The other locations. I don’t know about. I just know about this one the sweet young girl that works there plus the girl with the glasses and the guy that always has all the Kansas City shirt go Chiefs! Have always treated us with the utmost respect and considerationThis place is the best … even the guys in the kitchen come out to say hello and they call us the regs which I assume means regulars we always tip them and let me mention this just because you get it to go order leaving $.55 or a change order is not a tip. Take care of these people because their prices are so inexpensive and their service is so exceptional. They’re definitely taking care of you!!

The bottom of the pizza was burnt black. Not ordering again from this place.

We came in with our two daughters excited to try their pizza. We ordered a large half cheese and pepperoni with garlic knotts. We waited for 45 minutes before asking where our pizza was that never came out and they didnt even make it. I would totally get it if it was busy but we were the only people in the restaurant, litterally! Im not sure what these guys were on but how does this happen. Now we have to leave and get fast food because our children are starving.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Inedible pizzas, incredibly overcooked. Didn't even bother to cut. Management did not care!

Food: 1

Service: 1

Callie is the best. Pizza is delicious. Was very reasonably priced.

Kid-friendliness: They have a( weekly??) Coloring contest. Kids can also vote for there favorite ones as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pesto Pollo Small - 10, Lil Pep Pep Large - 16

Got a Gluten Free combo pizza, love it the outside crust has a nice crunch, the crust with the toppings has a most excellent chew, the ingredients are fresh and have a snap when you bite into them, I had a really old punch card I finally filled out and they still honored it even though the deal on the new punch cards changed , the employees are super friendly and the atmosphere is pure nostalgia for me and takes me back to a real pizzeria, I am so over the moon with Pegasus Pizza they have a customer for life, and I have been to other pizza joints those are a very very distant 2nd.Love you guys keep up the good work

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Combo Pizza

Had an employee tell me “the delivery charge doesn’t include the tip”. First of all, you’re charging $40 for pizza and can’t even pay your drivers!? Second of all, you charge AN ADDITIONAL delivery fee and further stiff your drivers.Your pizza is mediocre and your business model is anti customer and anti employee. Here’s hoping this California owned, parasitic business goes under asap.