Brooklyn Trattoria Italian Restaurant

Food was really good, there were some little things that were a little strange for me and my group of 4. No physical menus? We were given one tablet to view the menu between 4 people until we asked for a second one. The tablets are inconvenient and bulky for the small space we had.

I asked about which wines weren't dry, and our server was not only under the age of 21, but she had no idea what that meant and could offer no insight. And apparently no one else was available who could it explain it to me-- we had to wait for someone to taste each of the wines and then tell us which ones were the least dry?? Very bizarre. The managers should make a cheat sheet for servers so they can offer a little information to guests at least.

I would eat here again for sure, but maybe we just picked the wrong day!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Nice place. Good food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

The food was delicious! The atmosphere was wonderful and comfortable. The owner stopped by to chat with us a couple times which was nice. Unfortunately, we waited ten minutes after being seated to see our server and then after ordering our food he never checked back with us, the WHOLE meal. Drinks went unfilled and we wanted dessert but after sitting for 15 minutes after our meal with no waiter in sight we decided to skip it. The restaurant only had a few tables and was not full so it was pretty disappointing. I would come back for the great food but would probably sit at the bar where we would have access to staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

My partner and I celebrated my birthday at Brooklyn Trattoria, and the entire experience was absolutely lovely from start to finish. We made a reservation in advance, and they went above and beyond by setting up a cozy booth for us, complete with a birthday card and fresh rose petals—such a thoughtful touch that instantly made the evening feel special.

The service was fantastic throughout. The staff was warm, attentive, and timed everything beautifully. Our drinks came quickly, and the appetizers were served with just the right pause before the entrees arrived.

We started with calamari and focaccia bread. The calamari was a standout—it came with a delicious dipping sauce and was paired with fried green olives and peppers that added a unique and flavorful twist. We loved it. The focaccia was fresh and satisfying as well. (I wish they served balsamic with the bread but that’s my only feedback)

For entrees, I had the breaded parmesan sole, which was served over a creamy butternut squash orzo—absolutely delicious and a perfect match for the seafood. My partner had the halibut piccata and opted to substitute the asparagus for brussels sprouts. The brussels were crispy, flavorful, and so good that we instantly regretted not ordering them as an appetizer!

We also enjoyed some excellent cocktails—balanced, well-made, and tasty. For the quality of food, service, and ambiance, the price felt very reasonable. Two appetizers, two entrees, and two drinks came to around $120.

To top off the night, the staff surprised us with a complimentary chocolate mousse for dessert to celebrate my birthday, which was a sweet and generous gesture. The owner, David, was present and welcoming. It’s clear he truly cares about creating a great experience for his guests.

After dinner, we checked out The Red Room, a cozy speakeasy-style cocktail lounge next door, also owned by David. The vibe was low-lit and intimate. The bartender there was friendly and crafted a beautiful, delicious drink for us. It’s a great spot to unwind after dinner or to visit on its own.

We didn’t end up ordering dessert, but the tiramisu caught our eye and seems to be a crowd favorite—next time, for sure!

Overall, Brooklyn Trattoria is a gem—cozy ambiance, attentive service, delicious food, and thoughtful details that make a special occasion feel even more memorable. When we’re looking to treat ourselves again, this will be the first place we think of!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I couldn’t have picked a better place to celebrate my parents 64th anniversary❤️ When I made the reservation and asked for a quiet booth, I had no idea how accommodating the restaurant would be. When we arrived, there were roses on the table and a hand signed card, wishing them a happy anniversary. I brought a bottle of special wine, which they cheerfully opened for a reasonable corkage fee. It was hard to choose from the many delicious menu items and my dad who is a bit of a spendthrift, volunteered his opinion that his dinner was amazing, a generous size, and a good value. After dinner as we were considering dessert, the server brought another surprise, a commentary chocolate mousse! Special occasion or not, this restaurant is a 10 on the five point scale. (P. S . be sure to get the focaccia bread- it was so good that we asked for a second order😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Some of the best cuisine on the west side no question about it
The chefs are top-notch
Great service David has completely out on himself this time

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great lasagna. The filet was super soft, like eating velvet. Cooked just like I wanted it. Made for a great anniversary meal and they had roses on the table for me ❤️ (it was an option in the reservation)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Had a reservation and were seated immediately. Ambience is nice. There is. Usually but had no trouble with having a conversation. Service was fantastic.
Food was good but I wouldn’t say it was amazing.
Tried the focaccia and a couple of pasta dishes and the tiramisu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu

While everyone was very nice and attentive, knowledge of wine was very lacking. Our server didn't have any win knowledge, stating she was under 21. She brought a few samples of the type we were looking for. Nothing close. Asked her to maybe ask the bartender for some help. I watched the bartender taste every red they had. Yes, he literally tasted all of them..we did like what he suggested...lol, food was less than fair...not a returning customer. To each there own.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 2

Went for a birthday dinner with my family. Food was good but service needs to be improved. After we got our food the server never checked back and when we were finished with our meal the dirty plates were not taken away and it took forever to get our check. It was as if we were totally abandoned.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Calamari

Wow, this place is such a gem! The food is fantastic, I've been here multiple times and the menu changes and the food is always delicious. Cocktails are terrific too. Great atmosphere for a wonderful meal!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was ok but tiramisu was small and triangle, not a square not very big for the price

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

It was my birthday and they put our group in the Red room which was extremely comfortable and pleasant. We all enjoyed our meals very much. The owner came out to welcome us which was appreciated. We will be back for any special occasion in the future.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It's an Italian restaurant near my house, so I've always been curious about it, and today I finally decided to try it for the first time.

It was a Thursday evening, and there were other customers in the restaurant, but it wasn't full, so it didn't seem too busy.

We ordered the shrimp scampi and focaccia as an appetizer, followed by the braised beef pappardelle and lamb dish.

The scampi and focaccia were good, so I was looking forward to the main dishes, but they were just so bland, and I was disappointed. It wasn't worth the money at all.

The biggest disappointment was not the food but the service. Our server was a woman with wavy hair in an updo, and she didn't do anything but take our order. She didn't even come to refill our water, let alone she never asked us how the food tasted.

In between, another young man brought our food, cleared our plates, and gave us things we asked for. He wasn't the one who took our order, and I don't even know if he was a busser or a server, but that was the only service we got.

Don't ask me why we didn't mention this at the restaurant, because no one checked our table or asked how everything was🤣

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

We celebrated four birthdays in the private dining room. If you’re looking for a great space, good food and amazing service look no further. I highly recommend the Brooklyn Trattoria.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5