Pizza thief is a great, casual pizza spot! I came here for lunch on a Friday and got three slices and a small seasonal salad. They didn't have all the slices on their menu available, unfortunately, so I didn't get to try the slice I really wanted to, but we got the cheese, hot tony, and seasonal slice. The cheese was my favorite! Tasted like a classic NY slice. The seasonal was also one of the better white pizzas I've tried (they're usually not my favorite). It had asparagus, sunflower seed pesto, spring onion mix, and a bunch of cheeses. The Hot Tony wasn't my favorite surprisingly since I typically love a spicy meat pizza. And their small seasonal salad was good but just a touch too acidic for me although I will say the feta on the salad was super creamy and delicious.
Jess O.
This is a once a week kind of place!! We pizza thief. The salads are always fresh and the pizza is always HOT. the fact that they always have seasonal pizzas. the easy counter service with their lovely staff. There is plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. It's always clean! Can't get enough.
James S.
I would like to say thank you to pizza thief. I ordered three peaches to pick up for a group of kids that were staying at our house. One of the pizzas accidentally got made incorrectly not only did they put a rush on it and had it within 10 minutes Than my weight was supposed to be. They included the pizza that was made incorrectly at no charge. I was able to split that pizza up and give it to the kids to take home that evening. I will recommend this place any other place in Portland, not only because of the quality of food, but also the service, thank you pizza thief!
Barbara F.
Best pizza I've had in a long while! Ordered a slice. Amount of cheese was perfect and tasted so good! I'll be back
Baruch Z.
I'm from New Haven, so when I say this is good pizza, that means it's good! This is a pizzeria, nothing fancy, just really good food. Excellent cannoli too!
Melissa E.
So yummy! Friendly! Clean! Such a nice experience. Can't wait to go back! Food was so flavorful!
Nithisha R.
We have been to this place a couple times and they never disappoint. The only reason I don't go there anymore is because their menu is kind of limited and I already explored almost everything in their menu. It changes seasonally but not much. Service is amazing as always. Ambience is very refreshing and serene. I really love their vegan pizza with a very fresh flavor of kale. Never loved kale as much as on this pizza. Their cheese, pepperoni pizza's are good. Desserts: The closer, cannoli, and seasonal ice creams are pretty good. I want them to play around with their menu and give the regular customers some more options to enjoy Their drinks are exceptional. You pick anything, they would never disappoint you. Overall a good place to try.
deb m.
Great Atmosphere and good music. Was very casual and fun. The food was so good, we live in Bend and we will come up here to eat every time we get the chance to. The people were really nice and friendly, great place all around will come again!
James Cramer
Best. Best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Shine
Parking: GoodKid-friendliness: Yes
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cannoli - Dozen Call or Email Pizzeria, Caesar Salad, Wildwood, Wildwood Pizza, The Baller, Italian Sandwich, Cookie, Focaccia
Love this place! Always hits the spot ❤️ Hwy 99 was delish! And good beer selections of course.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zane Fowler
Pretty mediocre pizza if I'm being honest. Service and environment are great, it's just the dough is chewy, the sauce is bland... Usually I don't dislike pizza like this. Maybe just an off day for them?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Jayden Dominguez
Best pizza I’ve ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Casper Landbo Petersen
Good pizzas, but service isn’t great. The waiting time is too long. I have still not managed to visit the place without waiting in ages.Food is great, also the gluten-free options.
Pizza thief is a great, casual pizza spot! I came here for lunch on a Friday and got three slices and a small seasonal salad. They didn't have all the slices on their menu available, unfortunately, so I didn't get to try the slice I really wanted to, but we got the cheese, hot tony, and seasonal slice. The cheese was my favorite! Tasted like a classic NY slice. The seasonal was also one of the better white pizzas I've tried (they're usually not my favorite). It had asparagus, sunflower seed pesto, spring onion mix, and a bunch of cheeses. The Hot Tony wasn't my favorite surprisingly since I typically love a spicy meat pizza. And their small seasonal salad was good but just a touch too acidic for me although I will say the feta on the salad was super creamy and delicious.
This is a once a week kind of place!! We pizza thief. The salads are always fresh and the pizza is always HOT. the fact that they always have seasonal pizzas. the easy counter service with their lovely staff. There is plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. It's always clean! Can't get enough.
I would like to say thank you to pizza thief. I ordered three peaches to pick up for a group of kids that were staying at our house. One of the pizzas accidentally got made incorrectly not only did they put a rush on it and had it within 10 minutes Than my weight was supposed to be. They included the pizza that was made incorrectly at no charge. I was able to split that pizza up and give it to the kids to take home that evening. I will recommend this place any other place in Portland, not only because of the quality of food, but also the service, thank you pizza thief!
Best pizza I've had in a long while! Ordered a slice. Amount of cheese was perfect and tasted so good! I'll be back
I'm from New Haven, so when I say this is good pizza, that means it's good! This is a pizzeria, nothing fancy, just really good food. Excellent cannoli too!
So yummy! Friendly! Clean! Such a nice experience. Can't wait to go back! Food was so flavorful!
We have been to this place a couple times and they never disappoint. The only reason I don't go there anymore is because their menu is kind of limited and I already explored almost everything in their menu. It changes seasonally but not much. Service is amazing as always. Ambience is very refreshing and serene. I really love their vegan pizza with a very fresh flavor of kale. Never loved kale as much as on this pizza. Their cheese, pepperoni pizza's are good. Desserts: The closer, cannoli, and seasonal ice creams are pretty good. I want them to play around with their menu and give the regular customers some more options to enjoy Their drinks are exceptional. You pick anything, they would never disappoint you. Overall a good place to try.
Great Atmosphere and good music. Was very casual and fun. The food was so good, we live in Bend and we will come up here to eat every time we get the chance to. The people were really nice and friendly, great place all around will come again!
Best. Best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Parking: GoodKid-friendliness: Yes
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cannoli - Dozen Call or Email Pizzeria, Caesar Salad, Wildwood, Wildwood Pizza, The Baller, Italian Sandwich, Cookie, Focaccia
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is always amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wildwood, Cookie
Love this place! Always hits the spot ❤️ Hwy 99 was delish! And good beer selections of course.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pretty mediocre pizza if I'm being honest. Service and environment are great, it's just the dough is chewy, the sauce is bland... Usually I don't dislike pizza like this. Maybe just an off day for them?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Best pizza I’ve ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizzas, but service isn’t great. The waiting time is too long. I have still not managed to visit the place without waiting in ages.Food is great, also the gluten-free options.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2