Good sized slices and pizza. Ordered large pepperoni. Crust is handmade and loads of toppings. Fair price as well. 😋
Joe Swaim
We love the pizza and the punctual service. If you order pizza for 5:45, that’s when it shows up. I’ve ordered delivery a bunch of times and never once had to call and ask where my pizza is. It’s especially great when you have people coming over and you’re trying to get everything ready, you don’t have to wonder when the food is coming.
Nick S
Food was great, and the staff was super friendly!
Joe Weldon
The food was terrible, I just picked it up, onion rings were freezing and very greasy ! The bottle of soda in the refrigerator was warm almost Hot! The pizza was warm and under cooked! This place is terrible. Ps the two girls were very friendly and nice! This place is a zero
Bonnie Coppola
THE WORST -I ordered thru a third party now the third party has my order correct -the 3rd party has no way of checking order -- I call Mr.P's 1st call on hold 5 mins then hung up on 2nd call-explain that the order was NOT what I ordered..girl said they will send out new corrected order..I get a phone call back ..MR. P Pizza says that there is nothing they can do! They messed up but I have to go thru loops..here's the kicker ..my dish was so disgusting..dried out ..overcooked..and clam's and mussles??? HORRIBLE ...it was in red sauce my order was white.
Matt Wilson
Currently battling food poisoning after a pizza I ordered last night. Liquid coming out of both ends at the same time.
Wayne Gusoff
Great food and even better employees. Had a minor issue and they fixed it in a major way. Will order again.
Philomena DeLancy
Been a fan of Mister P’s for years! Really sad how badly the food has declined. The past 3 Stromboli’s we’ve gotten have not been fully cooked and super doughy! I have mentioned this to them before while I’m ordering. Got a pizza last week, it was soggy and not fully cooked.
Claudia Nesmith
I waited 45 minutes if I hadn't walked to register after watching folks get their orders then female rep asked coworker where was the order it was sitting on top of oven where 2 boxes from the stack left with female and my order was 4th box out of 5 boxes. Then I spoke to rep and asked for my money she argued that I should feel the box was still hot. I left out but decided to take a pic. Then another Female follows me to outside and began taking pics and loud talking me as I drove off with no reply worse experience ever
HanksAdmirer AynRandisMyFavoriteAuthor
I recommend Jenny to be your waitress here. I am autistic and it was almost my birthday. She was extremely friendly, kind and attentive. The food was also great.
Pizza was just super undercooked. Second star because it probably would have been pretty solid if it spend another few minutes in the oven. I ordered three slices and threw out two of them.
cody akers
I eat these pizzas from out of the store never have from restraunt itself but just from store I love their pizza have ate it for years absolutely love it.
Rob N
Been a few months since I've had dinner from here. USED TO BE my go to for cheese steaks, but extremely disappointed with latest visit. ORing($8+) tasted soapy(maybe change the fryer oil ?!?) & cheese steaks were average at best. Meat tasted off/old. 2 Steaks & 1 order of rings for $35 ? Not again.
Lisa Weiss
Pleasantly surprised. Been by here a thousand times and tonight decided to stop. The food was good.
Lynne Vittorio
I've had a number of different items on their large menu and they're very satisfying, big servings. It's clean. The wait staff is friendly. Management is friendly. Reasonably priced.
Good sized slices and pizza. Ordered large pepperoni. Crust is handmade and loads of toppings. Fair price as well. 😋
We love the pizza and the punctual service. If you order pizza for 5:45, that’s when it shows up. I’ve ordered delivery a bunch of times and never once had to call and ask where my pizza is. It’s especially great when you have people coming over and you’re trying to get everything ready, you don’t have to wonder when the food is coming.
Food was great, and the staff was super friendly!
The food was terrible, I just picked it up, onion rings were freezing and very greasy ! The bottle of soda in the refrigerator was warm almost Hot! The pizza was warm and under cooked! This place is terrible.
Ps the two girls were very friendly and nice! This place is a zero
THE WORST -I ordered thru a third party now the third party has my order correct -the 3rd party has no way of checking order -- I call Mr.P's 1st call on hold 5 mins then hung up on 2nd call-explain that the order was NOT what I ordered..girl said they will send out new corrected order..I get a phone call back ..MR. P Pizza says that there is nothing they can do! They messed up but I have to go thru loops..here's the kicker ..my dish was so disgusting..dried out ..overcooked..and clam's and mussles???
HORRIBLE ...it was in red sauce my order was white.
Currently battling food poisoning after a pizza I ordered last night. Liquid coming out of both ends at the same time.
Great food and even better employees. Had a minor issue and they fixed it in a major way. Will order again.
Been a fan of Mister P’s for years! Really sad how badly the food has declined. The past 3 Stromboli’s we’ve gotten have not been fully cooked and super doughy! I have mentioned this to them before while I’m ordering. Got a pizza last week, it was soggy and not fully cooked.
I waited 45 minutes if I hadn't walked to register after watching folks get their orders then female rep asked coworker where was the order it was sitting on top of oven where 2 boxes from the stack left with female and my order was 4th box out of 5 boxes. Then I spoke to rep and asked for my money she argued that I should feel the box was still hot. I left out but decided to take a pic. Then another Female follows me to outside and began taking pics and loud talking me as I drove off with no reply worse experience ever
I recommend Jenny to be your waitress here. I am autistic and it was almost my birthday. She was extremely friendly, kind and attentive. The food was also great.
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was just super undercooked. Second star because it probably would have been pretty solid if it spend another few minutes in the oven. I ordered three slices and threw out two of them.
I eat these pizzas from out of the store never have from restraunt itself but just from store I love their pizza have ate it for years absolutely love it.
Been a few months since I've had dinner from here. USED TO BE my go to for cheese steaks, but extremely disappointed with latest visit. ORing($8+) tasted soapy(maybe change the fryer oil ?!?) & cheese steaks were average at best. Meat tasted off/old. 2 Steaks & 1 order of rings for $35 ? Not again.
Pleasantly surprised. Been by here a thousand times and tonight decided to stop. The food was good.
I've had a number of different items on their large menu and they're very satisfying, big servings. It's clean. The wait staff is friendly. Management is friendly. Reasonably priced.
Loading...