Mikey’s Caribbean Restaurant & Bar

Great food

Love it

Bland, unfresh food. Oxtail was mediocre and unimpressive. 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼

Excellent customer service and quick serving. I got the small oxtail entree with rice & peas and a Tropical Rhythm drink. Absolutely delicious! I cannot wait to come again!

*Disappointing Oxtail Experience at Mikey's*

As first-generation Caribbean Americans, my husband and I know a good West Indian meal. We were craving oxtail, but our experience at Mikey's was a letdown.

We had tried Mikey's oxtail last year and were disappointed, but we decided to give them another chance. Unfortunately, our experience was just as bad, if not worse.

The oxtail meal was overwhelmingly salty, and the portion sizes were inconsistent. My small order came with five small to medium-sized pieces, while my husband's large order had seven pieces, with only three being larger.

We were both disappointed and frustrated, feeling that our money had been wasted. The excessive saltiness and lack of value for the price make us caution others: eat at Mikey's at your own risk.

I only gave two stars because the texture of the oxtail, which can be hard to get right, was perfect.

Unless they revamp their oxtail recipe, we cannot recommend it. We haven't tried other menu items, but if you're craving oxtail, beware.

I'm impressed that I ubered food from here at 830-900pm and it was actually fresh and delicious. I ordered shrimp rasta pasta, small order of Mac and cheese and a jerk chicken dinner. I hope this wasn't a fluke because I told all my coworkers about this place and I'll definitely be ordering again.

Food was disgusting. Waste of money . Would never return . The restaurant has a moldy smell .

I was visiting from Atlanta & I had the steamed snapper. It was really good

Yeah mon real yard food that.

We went there at 10:05, google said they were open until 11 pm. They were closed.

Look, if you don't know how to slow whine? Eat some of this jerk chicken, and you finna walk up outta there ruling the entire dance hall... do you hear me? Pon da rivah!! Wooo E go crazy at this place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Oxtail Rasta Pasta with Penne Pasta or Fettuccine, Jerk Chicken Rasta Pasta, Brown Stewed Chicken, Rasta Pasta

Super clean, friendly staff and the food is ALWAYS on point!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stewed Chicken

As a Caribbean I am so disappointed with the way my “Bake Mac “ was made and taste. As you can see in the picture that’s not appealing and the taste match it. The steam Red snapper had no color and as I was making my way to eat I smelled fish like the sea order type smell so I went and open it and boom a dirty stinky fish not fresh at all ? as you can see in the pic it was not clean. But my wife got the Ox tails and they were great so that’s a plus I guest but never again

Food: 1

Service: 1

Fantastic food and even better service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I hv visited Mikey a couple off times. Trying out his dishes. I give him 2 stars. The large oxtail. He is giving you a large container of. Rice. Not oxtail. The oxtail is cut very thin for 21$ it’s not worth it. Brooklyn Jamaican restaurant. When you pay for a large oxtail. You get what you pay for. Mickey is giving a large container off rice / no comparison to the taste and quality you get in Brooklyn will not be going back

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2