Teresas' Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

We got a Sicilian pizza take out. The first red flag was that we opened the box and the Sicilian was flatter than a pancake. Okay. Disappointing. It went downhill from there. Two bites in and I had a mouthful of barely cooked dough. At least that explained why the Sicilian pizza was utterly two dimensional. At least they refunded us. I’d had previously good experiences there, but there really isn’t an excuse for this level abysmal quality control. Especially for that price.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Incredible angel hair pasta with eggplant parm. Free garlic bread and wine with your entrée. Real garlic and butter slathered the bread, insane!! Unbeatable service in a quaint, but cute atmosphere. Will absolutely return when in the area.

Vegetarian options: Get the eggplant parm! They do it right :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread

Babysitting grandkids in town Always order from Teresa’s when I’m here Grub hub delivers My order was missing the soup for my wife who did not order an entree Called driver from grub hub and she indicates that she is instructed by grub hub not to check the order and it’s the restaurant’s responsibility to insure a complete order Called the restaurant and was escalated to John I believe He offered a refund for the soup I told him my wife cannot eat the refund and please deliver the soup He said no can do you can pick it up I told him if I could pick it up I would not have utilized grub hub He didn’t care Very poor customer service Never ordering again from them

Food: 5

Service: 1

Oh my gods, this place was amazing! The food was top notch, portions were huge. The decor is beautiful and the service was amazing. Wish we were local as I easily could have made 3 additional meals from my leftovers. Do not skip this place. We're definitely going to return when we come back north.

Parking: Lots of space.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

BYOB... excellent menu.
Ask for Gilbert as your waiter.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food,wonderful staff! Take out or eat in....always very enjoyable. Thanks for coming to our neighborhood. Robin & John

Shrimp 🍤 parm i thought it would come with pasta no it come a roll for &14 dollars the sandwich was cut in half and i could take all the shrimp off one side of the soggy bread put it on the other side so i wouldn’t just be eating breading and bread 🥖 ugh the cannoli was good never again

Food: 1

Ordered catering from Teresa's and was extremely disappointed. We ordered Chicken Alfredo for catering and did not recieve any pasta with our order. When we called the restaurant we were told for catering orders pasta is not included. To me its bizarre to think the expectation of the restaurant is to serve chicken without pasta. This expectation needs to be more clearer and emphasized at time of order. At my party, there was simply chicken and sauce. This is extremely disappointing after spending $270 on our order but not recieving pasta that in theory wouldnt cost more than $20-30 dollars. I have raised my concerns and grievances with the restaurant and am still waiting on them to call me back with answers and solutions. I have called twice and was promised a call back but have not recieved any call back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

A great place with delicious food, perfect Italian atmosphere, and attentive staff. We loved our meal!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Cheese Sticks, Eggplant Parm Roll, Garlic Knots

Ordered 40 bucks of takeout. All inedible. Don’t get the eggplant parm or pasta fagioli

Food: 1

Margherita pizza was the best.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Italian Margarita Pizza

Came in today 9/5/24. First thing I notice is 2 different radio stations going. One Italian and one either middle eastern (I believe) which threw me off when trying to have a nice lunch with my man. Secondly, we got this bread- which smelled and looked amazing- but when biting into it- I could’ve broke a tooth. Seems like dinner rolls from two nights ago was cut and tossed in butter and garlic and served. Then the salad came out and was so soggy because it was pre made into a plate that just sat in the fridge until someone ordered. I am not by any means a complainer but these are the kind of things that’ll make a restaurant go under. On top of that, when I asked for fresh bread, the server (older Mexican man) had an attitude as he told me it will take 10 minutes as if we weren’t already there 25. The little amount of effort is mind boggling. I hope the owners are aware.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

It's on the pricy side but the service is delightful, the food is beyond delicious, the garlic knots are divine and I heavily recommend the Carbonara

Vegetarian options: Many pastas, dishes and appetizers can be ordered without meat, so pretty good selection for vegetarians.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Cheese Sticks, Garlic Knots

I’ve eaten my fair share of pizza in Fogelsville and this is by far the best pizza I’ve had in the area!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Italian Margarita Pizza

We have loved going to Teresa’s for years. Last night was so disappointing. Waited forever for any service at all. I ordered Chicken Marsala. I don’t think they had any marsala. Bland as could be. I don’t know what happened but it was totally out of character for them and we seemed to have met with resistance on everything. ☹️