Kicked off my biscotti binge in Bradley Beach but since that's so far away from me, I asked around & My Boys Bakery came highly recommended. Got there & was a little taken aback that a bakery has zero display of their baked goods. Just a sign & packaging. So you have to take it on good faith & not have your eyes do the ordering. Not knowing what you're ordering or even having any kind of visual like a picture display or anything is kinda weird but I'm on a binge so ok. A box of 18 is $13. I thought that was reasonable ASSUMING the size of the biscotti is the "usual" size. I got the Almond, the Orange Toffee Pecan, Cranberry Pistachio, and I had her recommend their big seller which was the Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Caramel. As soon as I opened the box, I was disappointed because I could tell there was no anise flavoring. To me, no Italian cookie should be without it. BUT when I did bite into each one, I was happily surprised! They were buttery, flavorful, and with each one, the ingredients TOGETHER were a symphony. As I tried each one, it was hard to choose which one I liked best. Even the plain ol classic almond was delicious. They were on the smaller side but each one was good. Now that I know what to expect, I'll be back!
Suzanne Bents
Outstanding chocolate chip biscotti! Wish I lived closer to you to avoid the shipping charges but it was worth it! Thank you.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marjorie Kline
I could eat a million of these!My
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CLL
Absolutely the best biscotti and cookies that can be found in our area.
G G
Love their biscotti. I
Brian W.
Wow. Amazing cookies and biscotti. I mean amazing. I had shipped a large box of everything to my mother for her birthday and it arrived early and was raves about. Highly recommend
Connie Gilchrist
A vendor gifted me a tin of various biscotti. These are the absolute BEST I've ever tasted. I just re-ordered a large tin for my family Christmas celebration.Such a wonderful bakery.
Maureen S.
The biscotti is to die for! Absolutely delicious! I believe I ordered the hazelnut, black and white, sea salt chocolate and some other delicious kind. Will come here to buy biscotti for Christmas gatherings.
Bassmasta911
Delicious biscotti and friendly staff?
Amy Sunnergren
It is 12:30, they close at 4:00. I ordered cookies for me to pick up today. I have not received a call. I have tried calling them and nobody picks up the phone. Very disappointed. These cookies are for my mother's funeral.
I received biscotti from a family member as a Christmas gift. This is absolutely the best ever! I may have to order more when this tin has been eaten. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this bakery! Top notch!
Amy Hawley
Nice varieties of biscotti. Friendly service. Nice packaging for gift presentations.
Amber Dawn Collins-Figueroa
I’ve had a handful of different varieties of their biscotti. While all were delicious, I am obsessed with their sea salt chocolate chip caramel biscotti. It is absolutely phenomenal!!! I ordered online and went there for the first time a couple of weeks ago. I gave some biscotti as gifts, and the recipients loved them!!! The employees I dealt with online and in person were very helpful and really pleasant. I cannot wait to go back and try new items. Great place to go!!!
Roy Minieri
Just received a tray from one of my clients..undoubtedly some of the finest baked goods gifts I have ever eaten ..can't wait to buy some of your products and send them to my clients...
Joy Ragan
Picked up a bag of peanut butter chocolaye chip at a crackee barrel. Tasted stale and had a chemical after taste. Almost scary. Looked at expiration date and its February 2020. Its now January 2020. Maybe just old but, we wont buu again.
Kicked off my biscotti binge in Bradley Beach but since that's so far away from me, I asked around & My Boys Bakery came highly recommended. Got there & was a little taken aback that a bakery has zero display of their baked goods. Just a sign & packaging. So you have to take it on good faith & not have your eyes do the ordering. Not knowing what you're ordering or even having any kind of visual like a picture display or anything is kinda weird but I'm on a binge so ok. A box of 18 is $13. I thought that was reasonable ASSUMING the size of the biscotti is the "usual" size. I got the Almond, the Orange Toffee Pecan, Cranberry Pistachio, and I had her recommend their big seller which was the Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Caramel. As soon as I opened the box, I was disappointed because I could tell there was no anise flavoring. To me, no Italian cookie should be without it. BUT when I did bite into each one, I was happily surprised! They were buttery, flavorful, and with each one, the ingredients TOGETHER were a symphony. As I tried each one, it was hard to choose which one I liked best. Even the plain ol classic almond was delicious. They were on the smaller side but each one was good. Now that I know what to expect, I'll be back!
Outstanding chocolate chip biscotti! Wish I lived closer to you to avoid the shipping charges but it was worth it! Thank you.
Food: 5
Service: 5
I could eat a million of these!My
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely the best biscotti and cookies that can be found in our area.
Love their biscotti. I
Wow. Amazing cookies and biscotti. I mean amazing. I had shipped a large box of everything to my mother for her birthday and it arrived early and was raves about. Highly recommend
A vendor gifted me a tin of various biscotti. These are the absolute BEST I've ever tasted. I just re-ordered a large tin for my family Christmas celebration.Such a wonderful bakery.
The biscotti is to die for! Absolutely delicious! I believe I ordered the hazelnut, black and white, sea salt chocolate and some other delicious kind. Will come here to buy biscotti for Christmas gatherings.
Delicious biscotti and friendly staff?
It is 12:30, they close at 4:00. I ordered cookies for me to pick up today. I have not received a call. I have tried calling them and nobody picks up the phone. Very disappointed. These cookies are for my mother's funeral.
Restaurantji Recommends
I received biscotti from a family member as a Christmas gift. This is absolutely the best ever! I may have to order more when this tin has been eaten. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this bakery! Top notch!
Nice varieties of biscotti. Friendly service. Nice packaging for gift presentations.
I’ve had a handful of different varieties of their biscotti. While all were delicious, I am obsessed with their sea salt chocolate chip caramel biscotti. It is absolutely phenomenal!!! I ordered online and went there for the first time a couple of weeks ago. I gave some biscotti as gifts, and the recipients loved them!!! The employees I dealt with online and in person were very helpful and really pleasant. I cannot wait to go back and try new items. Great place to go!!!
Just received a tray from one of my clients..undoubtedly some of the finest baked goods gifts I have ever eaten ..can't wait to buy some of your products and send them to my clients...
Picked up a bag of peanut butter chocolaye chip at a crackee barrel. Tasted stale and had a chemical after taste. Almost scary. Looked at expiration date and its February 2020. Its now January 2020. Maybe just old but, we wont buu again.