Can wait to have my Pizza and Sandwiches mm m YAY let's show some Love to the greatest pizza place around See you soon
Jason
I miss y'all :<
marianne knapp
It was so Yummy Mmm mm m my Cat was even looking at my plate the DoorDadh was Fabulous ?Vegetarian options: Vegan Pizza So Perfect And so Delicious Nice Light brown bubbly crust so good ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Garlic Knot Pizza
Cindy Ford
The food at your pop up was spectacular!!! We have missed visiting your restaurant and can't wait till you are back in your restaurant! We will continue to visit every pop up you have till then!!!
Sam Smith
Currently recovering after falling on hard times, but they'll be back i am sure. Best cruelty free pizza I've had yet!I would like to share that we had some activists come all the way from Philadelphia to do an Easton animal rights event and part of why they made the trip is to go to your pizza place after... We loved it and we had a great time ?Vegetarian options: Vegan options, egg and dairy still abuse animals so I am happy they go the extra mile to vegan
doug dewalt
So refreshing for a place to offer ballin' vegan options when it comes to pizza rather than throwing some unmelted fake cheese on a crust with some sauce and charging you 30 dollars. Paranormal Pizza is the REAL deal. Between the decadent pizza and the amazing wings you can't get much better.But wait. You can? They also have one of the best chik'n sandwiches (and I mean in general, not just from a vegan standpoint) I've ever had in my whole life.PLUS everything is named after X-Files AND they play cool music like Thursday sometimes. Sometimes I feel this restaurant was made just for me.
Heather Boswick
Wow! last time we went to Bethlehem, vegan finds were hard to find… now this place is new and amazingggggg. Drool worthy. Must visit!! We got the garlic knot vegan pizza and was blown away. Love the funky decor and vibe here. Seems family owned which is amazing and should be supported. My friend who isn’t even vegan said it was in his top 10 best pizzas. Love their combos and flavors. Please come here- vegan or not. The pizza is DIVINE ?✨
Kara T.
Just ordered delivery via grub hub from here and was so excited to have vegan pizza I was willing to suck up the $50 order price for just a pizza and garlic knots. SUPER disappointed when all my meal showed up cold and sad. Won't order again. Wish I could choose ZERO stars.
Sarah Wirth
Paranormal Pizza is truly the best plant based pizza you can get in PA & NJ! We look so forward to the emails we get each week with the weekly specials in them & it’s hard to not make every single Friday or Saturday a pizza night. So grateful this place exists ?? They are also SO kind & accommodating around our soy allergy. Cannot recommend enough!Vegetarian options: Everything is vegan!Dietary restrictions: They can easily accommodate soy free!
Really Bites
Probably the single best vegan spot in the valley. Comfortable hometown pizza joint vibes and wonderfully kind operators, as well as decadent and delicious food! Special shouts out to the buffalo wings which are better than any non-vegan buffalo wing I’ve ever had :D
I love The X-Files so much, and am always looking for good Vegan fare. Win/win. It's a bit pricey, but that's to be expected. The last visit we had the honey garlic Sriracha wings and they were ???. Even cold the next day at work. Plus there's always X-Files on the TV.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vivian Timor
I'm sorry to ruin the 5.0 review but as a vegan pizza coinessuer I have to be honest. The seitan, I will say, was a solid 8.5/10. The wings in particular were wonderful, but I found the pepperoni bland. The texture is there but not the flavor. What ruined this pizza for me was honestly the cheese. The texture/flavor isn't there and I feel I could have made something of similar quality in my own kitchen. The crust was good, especially with garlic knots but overall the entire meal did give my friend and myself stomachaches. The sauce was fine, average.I wouldn't recommend this pizza to non vegans, but I would recommend the wings. I drove an hour and a half to try this pizza and the dining room was closed a half an hour before the restaurant closed, which was also disappointing because we had called early in the day to make sure we made it. Reworking the cheese or switching to premade vegan cheese would greatly improve this pizza. Overall it also lacked salt and herbs throughout pizzas (alien bounty hunter and pepperoni). Bland, needs improvement.Edit to add (after reply from the owner) my sister and I called twice. I called in the early afternoon to confirm your hours then my sister called at 630pm to place our order. We live in Harrisburg and drove over an hour and a half specifically to try this pizza, and we had no way of seeing the window before we got there. Over the phone we were initially told to place an order by 7 because the store closed at 7:30. So we called again to place our order and were told about the dining room being closed after we had driven an hour to try this pizza. Good luck though.
Food: 3
Service: 2
Robin Miller
Delicious pizza and wings! The texture of the wings was incredible, nice and crispy with a few crunchy bits. The Alien Bounty Hunter was phenomenal! The garlic knots were a dream of dough and garlic while the piled high veggies were scrumptious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Alien Bounty Hunter
Keith Noonan
Fantastic. I'm not vegan or vegetarian but I was really impressed by Paranormal Pizza's food. I ordered the pepperoni pizza and the buffalo seitan wings and both were really good. Sauce and dough/crust for the pizza were really tasty, vegan cheese and pepperoni substitutes were surprisingly good, and the buffalo sauce and overall taste of the wings was really nice too. My family really enjoyed the food, and I would definitely recommend it.Vegetarian options: Whole menu was vegan.Dietary restrictions: Had gluten-free options in addition to vegan menu.Kid-friendliness: Very friendly staff and cool supernatural memorabilia on the walls and tables.
Tmoss682
I’ve eaten pizza all over Italy, New York, Philly and more. This is the best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust is the shining part; Although, the entire pizza is great. Must try for anyone with a mouth: vegan or not. Garlic know crust is a must. I love the specials of the week; It speaks to the staff’s love for creative food making. I have not tried the extra menu items, but I look forward to it.
Can wait to have my Pizza and Sandwiches mm m YAY let's show some Love to the greatest pizza place around See you soon
I miss y'all :<
It was so Yummy Mmm mm m my Cat was even looking at my plate the DoorDadh was Fabulous ?Vegetarian options: Vegan Pizza So Perfect And so Delicious Nice Light brown bubbly crust so good ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Garlic Knot Pizza
The food at your pop up was spectacular!!! We have missed visiting your restaurant and can't wait till you are back in your restaurant! We will continue to visit every pop up you have till then!!!
Currently recovering after falling on hard times, but they'll be back i am sure. Best cruelty free pizza I've had yet!I would like to share that we had some activists come all the way from Philadelphia to do an Easton animal rights event and part of why they made the trip is to go to your pizza place after... We loved it and we had a great time ?Vegetarian options: Vegan options, egg and dairy still abuse animals so I am happy they go the extra mile to vegan
So refreshing for a place to offer ballin' vegan options when it comes to pizza rather than throwing some unmelted fake cheese on a crust with some sauce and charging you 30 dollars. Paranormal Pizza is the REAL deal. Between the decadent pizza and the amazing wings you can't get much better.But wait. You can? They also have one of the best chik'n sandwiches (and I mean in general, not just from a vegan standpoint) I've ever had in my whole life.PLUS everything is named after X-Files AND they play cool music like Thursday sometimes. Sometimes I feel this restaurant was made just for me.
Wow! last time we went to Bethlehem, vegan finds were hard to find… now this place is new and amazingggggg. Drool worthy. Must visit!! We got the garlic knot vegan pizza and was blown away. Love the funky decor and vibe here. Seems family owned which is amazing and should be supported. My friend who isn’t even vegan said it was in his top 10 best pizzas. Love their combos and flavors. Please come here- vegan or not. The pizza is DIVINE ?✨
Just ordered delivery via grub hub from here and was so excited to have vegan pizza I was willing to suck up the $50 order price for just a pizza and garlic knots. SUPER disappointed when all my meal showed up cold and sad. Won't order again. Wish I could choose ZERO stars.
Paranormal Pizza is truly the best plant based pizza you can get in PA & NJ! We look so forward to the emails we get each week with the weekly specials in them & it’s hard to not make every single Friday or Saturday a pizza night. So grateful this place exists ?? They are also SO kind & accommodating around our soy allergy. Cannot recommend enough!Vegetarian options: Everything is vegan!Dietary restrictions: They can easily accommodate soy free!
Probably the single best vegan spot in the valley. Comfortable hometown pizza joint vibes and wonderfully kind operators, as well as decadent and delicious food! Special shouts out to the buffalo wings which are better than any non-vegan buffalo wing I’ve ever had :D
Restaurantji Recommends
I love The X-Files so much, and am always looking for good Vegan fare. Win/win. It's a bit pricey, but that's to be expected. The last visit we had the honey garlic Sriracha wings and they were ???. Even cold the next day at work. Plus there's always X-Files on the TV.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm sorry to ruin the 5.0 review but as a vegan pizza coinessuer I have to be honest. The seitan, I will say, was a solid 8.5/10. The wings in particular were wonderful, but I found the pepperoni bland. The texture is there but not the flavor. What ruined this pizza for me was honestly the cheese. The texture/flavor isn't there and I feel I could have made something of similar quality in my own kitchen. The crust was good, especially with garlic knots but overall the entire meal did give my friend and myself stomachaches. The sauce was fine, average.I wouldn't recommend this pizza to non vegans, but I would recommend the wings. I drove an hour and a half to try this pizza and the dining room was closed a half an hour before the restaurant closed, which was also disappointing because we had called early in the day to make sure we made it. Reworking the cheese or switching to premade vegan cheese would greatly improve this pizza. Overall it also lacked salt and herbs throughout pizzas (alien bounty hunter and pepperoni). Bland, needs improvement.Edit to add (after reply from the owner) my sister and I called twice. I called in the early afternoon to confirm your hours then my sister called at 630pm to place our order. We live in Harrisburg and drove over an hour and a half specifically to try this pizza, and we had no way of seeing the window before we got there. Over the phone we were initially told to place an order by 7 because the store closed at 7:30. So we called again to place our order and were told about the dining room being closed after we had driven an hour to try this pizza. Good luck though.
Food: 3
Service: 2
Delicious pizza and wings! The texture of the wings was incredible, nice and crispy with a few crunchy bits. The Alien Bounty Hunter was phenomenal! The garlic knots were a dream of dough and garlic while the piled high veggies were scrumptious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Alien Bounty Hunter
Fantastic. I'm not vegan or vegetarian but I was really impressed by Paranormal Pizza's food. I ordered the pepperoni pizza and the buffalo seitan wings and both were really good. Sauce and dough/crust for the pizza were really tasty, vegan cheese and pepperoni substitutes were surprisingly good, and the buffalo sauce and overall taste of the wings was really nice too. My family really enjoyed the food, and I would definitely recommend it.Vegetarian options: Whole menu was vegan.Dietary restrictions: Had gluten-free options in addition to vegan menu.Kid-friendliness: Very friendly staff and cool supernatural memorabilia on the walls and tables.
I’ve eaten pizza all over Italy, New York, Philly and more. This is the best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust is the shining part; Although, the entire pizza is great. Must try for anyone with a mouth: vegan or not. Garlic know crust is a must. I love the specials of the week; It speaks to the staff’s love for creative food making. I have not tried the extra menu items, but I look forward to it.