Service was ok ribeye was so disappointing I order it and so did my friend it was the toughest piece of meat for 35 dollars I could of gotten the same cut for cheaper price at Applebee's add one were forgotten for the steaks my other guest had a dry chicken dish I don't normally bother given bad reviews but this had to be noted 
Katie Ries
Delicious! Great staff, great food, good prices!
Jackie Ruddy
All around incredible!
Wesley Pfeiffer
Very accommodating food was greit
Ron
Haven't been here in a minute. My wife took me here for father's Day (6/15/25). We had a reservation which I highly recommend you do always because without it, you may not get seated. As with my last visit the hosts were very nice and the drinks were good also.. What was different this time was the food. My wife ordered the Prime Rib and I opted for the Steak ( Bone in Ribeye}. My wife mentioned to me that her prime rib had no flavor. I thought she was just having an off day with her taste buds. But, when she offered me a piece, she was right. The prime rib had no flavor. It was like they just threw it in and on the plate with no seasoning at all. I looked at my steak and was dying to dig into that. But, when I did, it was the same thing. Cooked medium well with no flavor but, the light charr that was on it. I was very disappointed. I heard the manager going table to table greeting the customers and asking how their meals were but, he never made it to our table. We left disappointed. I still like Prime but, I don't know if they changed chefs or what. I will someday go back but, If I order the same thing again and it comes out that way, I won't be back. It wasn't a good father's day experience.
Gary Maurer
For many years, the Prime Steakhouse has been a family favorite for everything from a small dinner for just my wife and me up to large family gatherings for as many as 12 to 14 people. In the past, the food was always excellent and the service was great. On our last two visits, including last evening, the service was just okay, but the food was not close to Prime’s previous quality. The salad bar was the highlight of our meal. It was well stocked, visually appealing and delicious. Unfortunately, our appetizers and entrées were mostly disappointing. Some items came out cold while others were well overcooked. Sauces and seasonings were bland and not as flavorful as in the past. Except for the salad bar, it was like eating at a diner but at much higher prices. We will certainly eat at the Prime again sometime in the next few months, but if it disappoints us again, it will probably be our last visit.
Sherri Walden
We were totally impressed. Need one in the Mechanicsburg area.
Melanie
I was not satisfied with the food at all. I had the calamari and steak medallions w/crab meat. It was bland to me, it didn't have any flavor. My husband enjoyed his steak but his opinion on the calamari was the same. My daughter enjoyed her chicken strips and fries off the kids menu
Michelina
Server, Giovanni, was exceptional. We were lucky to be seated in a small booth in a quiet alcove away from family parties and groups. Steak and salmon both done nicely.
Food was delicious. We had steaks, crab cakes and salmon. Waiter was very attentive but service was slow. The restaurant was crowded since it was Father's Day, and I am guessing service was slow due to this. 90 year old father in law enjoyed his steak and chocolate dessert.
Kathy
The prime rib is always perfectly cooked. Get the raw horseradish with it, it's so good. Scallops were sweet, not fishy. It's always a treat to eat there.
Bonita
Prime Steak house is a great place to eat, whether alone of with family, friends, etc. The staff are all very nice and helpful, as are the management team. Watch for the great events they offer, as they are fun to be a part of. Give them a try as you will love what they have to offer whether it's appetizers, salad bar, meals, & drinks
Nancy Simonetta
Got there and seated. No waitress or waiter for 20 minutes Had to wait until other people came to flag down their waiter to have someone come take care of us. A great waitress volunteered to take our table. Our friend ordered steak medium we'll. My husband ordered his medium rare. Both came out the same. My friend and I ordered lobster tail. Hers was fine. Mine needed more time to cook. Manager told us drinks and appetizers are on the house. Bill came, drinks were on the bill. What a mess.
Eric
For the past 3 years we have gone to Prime Steak house to celebrate our Anniversary. We requested a more private table. The lighting was just right, not too much noise, great service (Shirley S.) was wonderful. My husband had the Ribeye, and I enjoyed the crabcakes with lobster sauce. Excellent meals. The Caesar salad before the meal was also very good and my husband had the salad bar. They presented us with a piece of Triple chocolate cake to share for Anniversary celebration. So delicious.!!! We will definitely be back.
Excellent
Service was ok ribeye was so disappointing I order it and so did my friend it was the toughest piece of meat for 35 dollars I could of gotten the same cut for cheaper price at Applebee's add one were forgotten for the steaks my other guest had a dry chicken dish I don't normally bother given bad reviews but this had to be noted 
Delicious! Great staff, great food, good prices!
All around incredible!
Very accommodating food was greit
Haven't been here in a minute. My wife took me here for father's Day (6/15/25). We had a reservation which I highly recommend you do always because without it, you may not get seated. As with my last visit the hosts were very nice and the drinks were good also.. What was different this time was the food. My wife ordered the Prime Rib and I opted for the Steak ( Bone in Ribeye}.
My wife mentioned to me that her prime rib had no flavor. I thought she was just having an off day with her taste buds. But, when she offered me a piece, she was right. The prime rib had no flavor. It was like they just threw it in and on the plate with no seasoning at all. I looked at my steak and was dying to dig into that. But, when I did, it was the same thing. Cooked medium well with no flavor but, the light charr that was on it. I was very disappointed. I heard the manager going table to table greeting the customers and asking how their meals were but, he never made it to our table. We left disappointed. I still like Prime but, I don't know if they changed chefs or what. I will someday go back but, If I order the same thing again and it comes out that way, I won't be back. It wasn't a good father's day experience.
For many years, the Prime Steakhouse has been a family favorite for everything from a small dinner for just my wife and me up to large family gatherings for as many as 12 to 14 people. In the past, the food was always excellent and the service was great. On our last two visits, including last evening, the service was just okay, but the food was not close to Prime’s previous quality. The salad bar was the highlight of our meal. It was well stocked, visually appealing and delicious. Unfortunately, our appetizers and entrées were mostly disappointing. Some items came out cold while others were well overcooked. Sauces and seasonings were bland and not as flavorful as in the past. Except for the salad bar, it was like eating at a diner but at much higher prices. We will certainly eat at the Prime again sometime in the next few months, but if it disappoints us again, it will probably be our last visit.
We were totally impressed. Need one in the Mechanicsburg area.
I was not satisfied with the food at all. I had the calamari and steak medallions w/crab meat. It was bland to me, it didn't have any flavor. My husband enjoyed his steak but his opinion on the calamari was the same. My daughter enjoyed her chicken strips and fries off the kids menu
Server, Giovanni, was exceptional. We were lucky to be seated in a small booth in a quiet alcove away from family parties and groups. Steak and salmon both done nicely.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was delicious. We had steaks, crab cakes and salmon. Waiter was very attentive but service was slow. The restaurant was crowded since it was Father's Day, and I am guessing service was slow due to this. 90 year old father in law enjoyed his steak and chocolate dessert.
The prime rib is always perfectly cooked. Get the raw horseradish with it, it's so good. Scallops were sweet, not fishy. It's always a treat to eat there.
Prime Steak house is a great place to eat, whether alone of with family, friends, etc. The staff are all very nice and helpful, as are the management team. Watch for the great events they offer, as they are fun to be a part of. Give them a try as you will love what they have to offer whether it's appetizers, salad bar, meals, & drinks
Got there and seated. No waitress or waiter for 20 minutes
Had to wait until other people came to flag down their waiter to have someone come take care of us. A great waitress volunteered to take our table. Our friend ordered steak medium we'll. My husband ordered his medium rare. Both came out the same. My friend and I ordered lobster tail. Hers was fine. Mine needed more time to cook. Manager told us drinks and appetizers are on the house. Bill came, drinks were on the bill. What a mess.
For the past 3 years we have gone to Prime Steak house to celebrate our Anniversary. We requested a more private table. The lighting was just right, not too much noise, great service (Shirley S.) was wonderful. My husband had the Ribeye, and I enjoyed the crabcakes with lobster sauce. Excellent meals. The Caesar salad before the meal was also very good and my husband had the salad bar. They presented us with a piece of Triple chocolate cake to share for Anniversary celebration. So delicious.!!! We will definitely be back.
Loading...