My wife and I really enjoy Garrett Hill. The meals are outstanding and the drinks very generous. We dine at Garrett Hill (as well as Flip and Bailey’s) often and find the meals “scrumptious” and the staff friendly, outgoing, and personable. Dinner at Garrett’s is a wonderful “5 Star” experience. Bill &
The food continues to be sub par. Roasted potatoes were a grey mushy mess twice in a raw despite bringing it to attention twice.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Janet McHugh
Great for happy hour drinks are great especially beers on draft. The food is not necessarily bar food. They need to have the same food flips has because flips food has a better menu. Food is still good. I'm there almost every Friday for happy hour always the same crowd.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Kevin Leonard
Awesome place....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey Gavio
I liked the food and the beer selection better pre-covid but still a solid spot for good pub food and a few brews
Kid-friendliness: We met friends and had five kids between us -- the lively atmosphere, ample seating, and patient staff definitely makes this a kid-friendly spot on a Friday evening.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Avery Peddicord
My boyfriend and I have been to Garrett Ale House a few times for Sunday brunch and we decided to check it out for dinner. Unfortunately I don’t think we will return for dinner. We’ve had good experiences with our Sunday brunch visits but last night for dinner was just disappointing. I got a few drinks and while both of those were good, the food was disappointing. It took us over an hour after ordering to get our meals. I got the caprese panini which I was so looking forward to trying, but the bread was soggy and cold and my fries were cold. My boyfriend ordered the marry-me chicken and while he said it tasted good we just wished the portion size could’ve been slightly bigger. We were given the check and had to wait for 25 minutes before someone came over for us to pay our bill. We’ve never had a problem during brunch and will likely return for brunch, but I can’t say the same about dinner here. Our server was super friendly and it was not her fault at all that they seem to be understaffed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Bill Moller
First time visit. My wife and I loved the food (salmon and cod) with broccoli and yellow rice, nice tavern-like atmosphere. Great spot for a date night. We'll definitely be going again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JP Pruett
Average restaurant in Ohio
Jacob
The waiter was super chill and the brunch menu at dinner time helped me reminisce of my yummy egg sandwhich I had earlier this morning. The bathroom experience was to die for as the shower curtain substituting for a standard bathroom stall kept me on my toes as I never knew when a fellow customer may mistakenly walk in on me dropping logs. The bathroom experience kept me guessing as there were no toilet paper either. Truly a thrilling experience overall and I’d highly recommend. Flip and Baileys could never live up to this level of class and status.
Mryeom 1
Will be coming back. I loved the ambiance of the bathroom. 10/10
Nice neighborhood pub. Big well cooked burgers. Friendly staff.
Cornell Scott
Great place to have some awesome food.
Shannon Guzman
They have the best food in the area!
Zoe Darazsdi
Last night, my boyfriend and I had dinner here and it was a very negative experience. We got Nachos, which were a $15 handful of Tortilla chips with unseasoned black beans, three charred jalapeños slices, melted American cheese, served on tin foil. I got the meat loaf, which was incredibly salty, burnt, and had the odd aftertaste of cigarettes. My boyfriend had the burger, which was overpriced and just ok. We understand that service was slow due to understaffing, but it was disappointing to wait so long for food that was not good.
Timothy Hemcher
Every experience has been top notch. Great beer selection and great food. Sunday brunch is excellent!
My wife and I really enjoy Garrett Hill. The meals are outstanding and the drinks very generous. We dine at Garrett Hill (as well as Flip and Bailey’s) often and find the meals “scrumptious” and the staff friendly, outgoing, and personable. Dinner at Garrett’s is a wonderful “5 Star” experience. Bill &
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatloaf & Cheddar Melt, Roast Beef Sandwich
The food continues to be sub par. Roasted potatoes were a grey mushy mess twice in a raw despite bringing it to attention twice.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Great for happy hour drinks are great especially beers on draft. The food is not necessarily bar food. They need to have the same food flips has because flips food has a better menu. Food is still good. I'm there almost every Friday for happy hour always the same crowd.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Awesome place....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I liked the food and the beer selection better pre-covid but still a solid spot for good pub food and a few brews
Kid-friendliness: We met friends and had five kids between us -- the lively atmosphere, ample seating, and patient staff definitely makes this a kid-friendly spot on a Friday evening.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
My boyfriend and I have been to Garrett Ale House a few times for Sunday brunch and we decided to check it out for dinner. Unfortunately I don’t think we will return for dinner. We’ve had good experiences with our Sunday brunch visits but last night for dinner was just disappointing. I got a few drinks and while both of those were good, the food was disappointing. It took us over an hour after ordering to get our meals. I got the caprese panini which I was so looking forward to trying, but the bread was soggy and cold and my fries were cold. My boyfriend ordered the marry-me chicken and while he said it tasted good we just wished the portion size could’ve been slightly bigger. We were given the check and had to wait for 25 minutes before someone came over for us to pay our bill. We’ve never had a problem during brunch and will likely return for brunch, but I can’t say the same about dinner here. Our server was super friendly and it was not her fault at all that they seem to be understaffed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
First time visit. My wife and I loved the food (salmon and cod) with broccoli and yellow rice, nice tavern-like atmosphere. Great spot for a date night. We'll definitely be going again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Average restaurant in Ohio
The waiter was super chill and the brunch menu at dinner time helped me reminisce of my yummy egg sandwhich I had earlier this morning. The bathroom experience was to die for as the shower curtain substituting for a standard bathroom stall kept me on my toes as I never knew when a fellow customer may mistakenly walk in on me dropping logs. The bathroom experience kept me guessing as there were no toilet paper either. Truly a thrilling experience overall and I’d highly recommend. Flip and Baileys could never live up to this level of class and status.
Will be coming back. I loved the ambiance of the bathroom. 10/10
Restaurantji Recommends
Nice neighborhood pub. Big well cooked burgers. Friendly staff.
Great place to have some awesome food.
They have the best food in the area!
Last night, my boyfriend and I had dinner here and it was a very negative experience. We got Nachos, which were a $15 handful of Tortilla chips with unseasoned black beans, three charred jalapeños slices, melted American cheese, served on tin foil. I got the meat loaf, which was incredibly salty, burnt, and had the odd aftertaste of cigarettes. My boyfriend had the burger, which was overpriced and just ok. We understand that service was slow due to understaffing, but it was disappointing to wait so long for food that was not good.
Every experience has been top notch. Great beer selection and great food. Sunday brunch is excellent!
Loading...