Downtown Bagel House

143 N Main St, Butler
(724) 234-0534

Recent Reviews

Christina Jasper

Delicious chewy perfectly cooked bagels.

Ivy Rose

A great family owned business that is doing so much good in our communityDelicious is just another perk!Check them out! You won’t regret it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Linda Protzman

Very friendly service. Unfortunately, the breakfast sandwich which was $8 for an egg and cheese bagel was not tasty at all.. The egg was very brown and overcooked which tasted really bad. Very disappointing! We were the only customers in the building, why were my eggs burnt?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Kevin Hart

Absolutely fantastic bagels on par with the best I've had and definitely the best I've had in the Pittsburgh region! True jersey bagels! They also serve pork roll which is really unique around here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels, Spreads

Emily Schiebel

Great little shop when you want New Jersey style bagels!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwiches, Bagels

Glen Randall

A little hidden gem in downtown Butler, PA. Fantastic-tasting bagels. I had the big boy Benny which has sausage, bacon, double pork roll, eggs, hashbrowns, and cheese with your choice of bagel. That was one of the best breakfast bagels I've had in about 30 years. This little gem is worth the stop-in. The owners are very friendly and both are from New Jersey. Please stop by and grab yourself a fantastic bagel or dozen.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: North Jerz, Big Boy Benny

mark r

This place was awesome. Nice, clean and quiet inside! The owners were extremely nice, and the bagels/sandwiches are some of the best I’ve had from the west coast to the east! Definitely stop in for some good breakfast!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels, Springsteen

Karissa M.

Such an awesome and cute little spot to eat! Staff is so kind and friendly! The bagels are absolutely delicious! 10/10 would absolutely recommend!

Amelia Henderson

Small place in Butler but super friendly staff and good bagels for sure! You can tell they put thought and care into what they make for you!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels

Rachel Fiedler

The best “Jersey” bagels in the Pittsburgh area! We ordered a variety of bagels with cream cheese for a New Jersey brides getting brunch here in Pittsburgh and they were perfection! The owners made it extra special by including a sweet note to the bride- thank you so much!

Paul Friesen

I'm NOT a bagel guy, I never buy them or pick them when there's other options. Their shop is downtown and close to our hotel. We had the "egg" bagels. One with jalapeño cheddar cream cheese the other one was the S. Jersey Turnpike sandwich. They were good, I'm not a bagel guy so I can't get too excited but the staff was friendly and I like supporting the local businesses. Give them a shot if you're in town, especially if enjoy bagels.

Aidan M.

Kind staff, huge portions, extremely fresh and tasty. Nice little building with good decoration.

Mae Gray

Fantastic bagel place situated in downtown Butler, has a wide selection of bagels and spreads, along with a strong menu of bagel sandwiches, owners and staff are amazing to interact with, my favorite place to grab breakfast in butler.

Kofi C.

Straight bacon egg and cheese bagel wouldn't go anywhere else so good. Great service too

Mandy Miller

Delicious bagel breakfast sammiches! They were HUGE…like 2x the size of normal bagels. Great deal for the price. I got the Kayla bagel which came with egg, cheese & hashbrowns plus i added bacon too and it was super yummy. My 2 little kids gobbled it up too. Will definitely return next time I’m in area. Owner was super friendly too!

Load More