Very disappointed. Ordered a Sicilian pizza definatly not worth the price. Very little sauce Tasted like a loaf of bread with a FEW toppings. Will not order from here again.
Sharon Palchinski
Went to pick up pizza and the workers weren’t very friendly. Got home and the the Sicilian pizza wasn’t good at all. Could barely finish a second piece. Barely any sauce and cheese and the top layer of the crust under toppings just didn’t look right. Very disappointed, first time trying Pizza Plus and not going back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bonnie Thompson
Hot Sauceage is the worse ever , it was so dried out no one could eat it and just barley warm...threw the damn thing back in the container and putting in the trash where it must of been found in the frist placeGot a 2nd sandwich for friend it was a steak, cold buns were like rubber a total waste of money and timeNever againNow to call someplace to get lunchMushrooms cold and mushy but edible..I guess
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Tyler Henricks
The food here is great. They have some killer deals too. I have ordered the pizza, bread sticks, and wedges and liked them all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Breadsticks, Pizza Plus
Michael Celestin
The Owner stopped by personnelly to fix a small mistake on an order. Great service!! Great pizza!!
curtis holmgren
Ordered " THIN" CRUST" I got thick. Sausage , Pepperoni, extra cheese. The cheese is awful. Had 1 SLICE. YUCK. NEVER
Food: 1
Service: 4
Amanda Pelesky
I placed an order through the Slice app. Per the app, pick up time was 8:30. When my husband arrived to pick up our order, he was told that they were closed, and all the ovens had been shut down. He was also told that the app isnt always reliable. The restaurant website says they are open until 9 pm. I do not understand why a restaurant would shut down well ahead of their stated hours, then blame an app for the issue.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
trenton ward
They over cooked the pizza did not write the slip up correctly so instead of getting pepperoni sausage and mushroom we got pepperoni talked to the GM and he was not helpful at all and basically blamed us for not ordering what we wanted been going here for a decade and now will not go
Atmosphere: 1
Mikayla Turner
This was our first time ordering here and it was a very positive experience. Prices were very reasonable and a great deal. Pizza was big with lots of toppings and tasted great. Will definitely be ordering again! Also huge selection on
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Breadsticks
Thomas bishop
Worst pizza I have ever had. No sauce or flavor, cheese wasn’t even melted. HORRIBLE.
Ordered doordash, breadsticks normal pizza.... and pierogi pizza but they put green peppers on it... nasty... nowhere in the description did I see green peppers. I don't like peppers so I didn't even eat it... whole pizza went to waste...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jonny B.
I've been getting pizza at Pizza Plus for a couple of decades now. I always said it was the best pizza in Butler. Today, however, I bought a pizza for lunch and about an hour after eating a few slices, I had the worst, most painful hamstring thigh cramps hit me. I only ever consistently got those same leg cramps after eating cheap BP gas station pizza off of route 28 Millerstown exit. It's cheap crap pizza that I call painful pizza because of the cramps that onset after eating it. Those are the only two places that ever gave me excruciating thigh cramps. I'll never eat there again. I think they changed ownership. I've never seen the guys before who are currently running it. Way to ruin the best pizza shop in Butler. I'll never go back. I'm throwing away the rest of the pizza that's left over. Honestly, it doesn't even taste the same. It's really bland. Where'd the flavor go. It's absolute garbage.
Rick N.
What happened here? It used to be the best, but it is now ranking as one of the worst. Dough is never fully cooked, leaving a soggy mess and disgusting crust even after asking for them to cook it longer. I have given it one last chance for the last time. So sad because just a few months ago it was delicious!
Carolyn Wincer
Order was delivered to the wrong address when we used the slice app. When food finally arrived the pizza and wings was over cooked. No offer was made to make the situation better. Order was placed at 4pm, did not have the food until 630. Will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Heather Brown
Online ordering is temporarily paused. Um, ok. How do you do business?
Very disappointed. Ordered a Sicilian pizza definatly not worth the price. Very little sauce Tasted like a loaf of bread with a FEW toppings. Will not order from here again.
Went to pick up pizza and the workers weren’t very friendly. Got home and the the Sicilian pizza wasn’t good at all. Could barely finish a second piece. Barely any sauce and cheese and the top layer of the crust under toppings just didn’t look right. Very disappointed, first time trying Pizza Plus and not going back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Hot Sauceage is the worse ever , it was so dried out no one could eat it and just barley warm...threw the damn thing back in the container and putting in the trash where it must of been found in the frist placeGot a 2nd sandwich for friend it was a steak, cold buns were like rubber a total waste of money and timeNever againNow to call someplace to get lunchMushrooms cold and mushy but edible..I guess
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
The food here is great. They have some killer deals too. I have ordered the pizza, bread sticks, and wedges and liked them all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Breadsticks, Pizza Plus
The Owner stopped by personnelly to fix a small mistake on an order. Great service!! Great pizza!!
Ordered " THIN" CRUST" I got thick. Sausage , Pepperoni, extra cheese. The cheese is awful. Had 1 SLICE. YUCK. NEVER
Food: 1
Service: 4
I placed an order through the Slice app. Per the app, pick up time was 8:30. When my husband arrived to pick up our order, he was told that they were closed, and all the ovens had been shut down. He was also told that the app isnt always reliable. The restaurant website says they are open until 9 pm. I do not understand why a restaurant would shut down well ahead of their stated hours, then blame an app for the issue.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
They over cooked the pizza did not write the slip up correctly so instead of getting pepperoni sausage and mushroom we got pepperoni talked to the GM and he was not helpful at all and basically blamed us for not ordering what we wanted been going here for a decade and now will not go
Atmosphere: 1
This was our first time ordering here and it was a very positive experience. Prices were very reasonable and a great deal. Pizza was big with lots of toppings and tasted great. Will definitely be ordering again! Also huge selection on
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Breadsticks
Worst pizza I have ever had. No sauce or flavor, cheese wasn’t even melted. HORRIBLE.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered doordash, breadsticks normal pizza.... and pierogi pizza but they put green peppers on it... nasty... nowhere in the description did I see green peppers. I don't like peppers so I didn't even eat it... whole pizza went to waste...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
I've been getting pizza at Pizza Plus for a couple of decades now. I always said it was the best pizza in Butler. Today, however, I bought a pizza for lunch and about an hour after eating a few slices, I had the worst, most painful hamstring thigh cramps hit me. I only ever consistently got those same leg cramps after eating cheap BP gas station pizza off of route 28 Millerstown exit. It's cheap crap pizza that I call painful pizza because of the cramps that onset after eating it. Those are the only two places that ever gave me excruciating thigh cramps. I'll never eat there again. I think they changed ownership. I've never seen the guys before who are currently running it. Way to ruin the best pizza shop in Butler. I'll never go back. I'm throwing away the rest of the pizza that's left over. Honestly, it doesn't even taste the same. It's really bland. Where'd the flavor go. It's absolute garbage.
What happened here? It used to be the best, but it is now ranking as one of the worst. Dough is never fully cooked, leaving a soggy mess and disgusting crust even after asking for them to cook it longer. I have given it one last chance for the last time. So sad because just a few months ago it was delicious!
Order was delivered to the wrong address when we used the slice app. When food finally arrived the pizza and wings was over cooked. No offer was made to make the situation better. Order was placed at 4pm, did not have the food until 630. Will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Online ordering is temporarily paused. Um, ok. How do you do business?