Awesome little place! So clean! Nice inviting restaurant! People there are even better!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
April
My husband and I were visiting Butler for a wedding and visited Tani’s for the first time. We both got calzones and they were amazing! The sauce was delicious too! The staff was so incredibly nice. Wish we had one local to us!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Black Tooth86
Definitely good pizza 🍕 I had a thin crust with pepperoni and bacon and even with greaser toppings it still had a good crispy undercarriage definitely recommend!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tom Hallberg
Food was good people were nice it was a cozy place I am looking for the perfect pizza I think I found it
I had pizza the first time. This time it was the warm steak hoagie. Both times the food was great. I will definitely return again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Russell Grimes
CONGRATULATIONS TO TANI'S PIZZA FOR WINNING FIRST PRIZE IN THE FOLLOWING CATEGORIES:
🏅 Worst Sicilian Pizza, 2025 🏅 Worst coverage by pepperoni and sausage on a pizza, 2025 🏅 Blandest crust, 2025 🏅 Most overpriced pizza, 2025
I'm an apologist for chain restaurants, like Pizza Hut, Little Caesar's, and Domino's. It's at such pizza places one will receive the best value.
I ordered a 16 slice Sicilian pizza with pepperoni and sausage. The cost was over $24. The cheese and toppings were scanty and the dough was way too heavy and with little flavor. I'm not sure why I paid so much for what is essentially 85% bread (estimation) but I'll never do it again.
Maybe the thin crust is better? Who knows. Regardless, I'll put my money on a chain.
Before you order a Sicilian pizza from Tani's, ask yourself one question: Why am I paying so much for chewy bread?
Disclaimer: Prizes awarded are informal and based upon the subjective beliefs of the reviewer and in no way reflect the opinion of other customers.
My response to your response: Receiving an award for best pizza and Italian restaurant in Butler is like a person getting an award for best chef when pitted against people who don't know black pepper from oregano. Who is the competition?
I think the truest test of quality would be to do a blind taste test, like outside of a supermarket. I could buy a few of your pizzas and a few from another establishment and have people try both and offer their opinions.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
tyler aikman
Their pizza is delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ian Fullen
Major respect to Tani. He stood on business, and promised to make me a great pie after a not so great first experience.
The sauce is spiced to perfection and the crust is even better the next day. I will be returning for sure. Thank you sir.
Edited : since you guys closed early yesterday due to a family emergency, hopefully we’ll get the chance in the near future to visit. Hope all is well! 🙏
Brittany S
Absolutely the best pizza place in town I ordered from here for the 2nd time and there Hawaiian pizza calamari spinach and bacon calzone garlic knots and provolone sticks we all loved everything they are the most kindest people the owner is amazing and kind thank you for the wonderful food and service I recommend anyone to eat at this place you will fall in love so good 😊
Seasonal Depression
Ordered wings and a pizza with mushrooms. I ended up with a Sicilian some how even though I didn't ask for one. It was very garlicky. Witch was fine to me but garlic causes some people to get ibs attacks and unfortunately I happen to live with one of those people so it was a unwelcomed surprise and I'm stuck eating it all myself. I'll likely be bound up for a week.
James Young
The linguine with clams and white wine clam sauce was one of the best things I've ever had! Absolutely amazing! Was full after half the dish but kept eating because it was so crazy good! Treat yourself, don't cheat yourself! 11/10!
Dan Rodgera
Their pizza is absolutely 🔥! BEST IN TOWN! If you're in Pittsburgh,Cranberry etc it's definitely worth the drive! Just buy extra because you're going to want left overs! Picture doesn't do it justice, cheese is great,fresh crust! Try it and you'll be amazed! If you are unsatisfied for any reason let them know and they'll take care of it.
Great food, prompt service Tanis the man!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome little place! So clean! Nice inviting restaurant! People there are even better!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I were visiting Butler for a wedding and visited Tani’s for the first time. We both got calzones and they were amazing! The sauce was delicious too! The staff was so incredibly nice. Wish we had one local to us!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Definitely good pizza 🍕 I had a thin crust with pepperoni and bacon and even with greaser toppings it still had a good crispy undercarriage definitely recommend!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was good people were nice it was a cozy place I am looking for the perfect pizza I think I found it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Square Thick Sicilian Deluxe Pizza
I had pizza the first time. This time it was the warm steak hoagie. Both times the food was great. I will definitely return again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CONGRATULATIONS TO TANI'S PIZZA FOR WINNING FIRST PRIZE IN THE FOLLOWING CATEGORIES:
🏅 Worst Sicilian Pizza, 2025
🏅 Worst coverage by pepperoni and sausage on a pizza, 2025
🏅 Blandest crust, 2025
🏅 Most overpriced pizza, 2025
I'm an apologist for chain restaurants, like Pizza Hut, Little Caesar's, and Domino's. It's at such pizza places one will receive the best value.
I ordered a 16 slice Sicilian pizza with pepperoni and sausage. The cost was over $24. The cheese and toppings were scanty and the dough was way too heavy and with little flavor. I'm not sure why I paid so much for what is essentially 85% bread (estimation) but I'll never do it again.
Maybe the thin crust is better? Who knows. Regardless, I'll put my money on a chain.
Before you order a Sicilian pizza from Tani's, ask yourself one question: Why am I paying so much for chewy bread?
Disclaimer: Prizes awarded are informal and based upon the subjective beliefs of the reviewer and in no way reflect the opinion of other customers.
My response to your response: Receiving an award for best pizza and Italian restaurant in Butler is like a person getting an award for best chef when pitted against people who don't know black pepper from oregano. Who is the competition?
I think the truest test of quality would be to do a blind taste test, like outside of a supermarket. I could buy a few of your pizzas and a few from another establishment and have people try both and offer their opinions.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Their pizza is delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Major respect to Tani. He stood on business, and promised to make me a great pie after a not so great first experience.
The sauce is spiced to perfection and the crust is even better the next day. I will be returning for sure. Thank you sir.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Makes a great pizza best I've had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Edited : since you guys closed early yesterday due to a family emergency, hopefully we’ll get the chance in the near future to visit. Hope all is well! 🙏
Absolutely the best pizza place in town I ordered from here for the 2nd time and there Hawaiian pizza calamari spinach and bacon calzone garlic knots and provolone sticks we all loved everything they are the most kindest people the owner is amazing and kind thank you for the wonderful food and service I recommend anyone to eat at this place you will fall in love so good 😊
Ordered wings and a pizza with mushrooms. I ended up with a Sicilian some how even though I didn't ask for one. It was very garlicky. Witch was fine to me but garlic causes some people to get ibs attacks and unfortunately I happen to live with one of those people so it was a unwelcomed surprise and I'm stuck eating it all myself. I'll likely be bound up for a week.
The linguine with clams and white wine clam sauce was one of the best things I've ever had! Absolutely amazing! Was full after half the dish but kept eating because it was so crazy good! Treat yourself, don't cheat yourself! 11/10!
Their pizza is absolutely 🔥! BEST IN TOWN! If you're in Pittsburgh,Cranberry etc it's definitely worth the drive! Just buy extra because you're going to want left overs! Picture doesn't do it justice, cheese is great,fresh crust! Try it and you'll be amazed! If you are unsatisfied for any reason let them know and they'll take care of it.
Loading...