Petrosky Pierogies

601 N Main St, Simpson
(570) 498-2435

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Chris Stamatos

Dough is very very VERY thick almost gummy They only ever have potato nothing else unless requested (2 weeks in advance) I was told when I went in. Had high hopes but have to find another shop

Keith Landau

How r u posting this place as a restaurant when it isn't twice we drove to the location u are supposed to be open and it's a house not a restaurant made a trip for nothing

Jim Waurin

Have been stopping here for years as we visit relatives in the surrounding area. Always wonderful. Don’t be fooled by the minimal storefront. Their pierogies are excellent!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kenneth Saul

Not mincing words or going on for long, super disappointed. Ordered a dozen each of steak and cheese, corn, and broccoli cheddar pierogis. Where the filling at. Specks of color barely seen in the potato filling for each one, can barely even taste the difference between them. It's just mostly potato. Add on the fact that I had to order a week ahead of time to pick them up even, this is just a joke. They may be better than bog standard grocery store pierogis, but it's a huge rip off in my eyes the way this place does them.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 4

pattie guitelli

The best of the best. So happy to have found you.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Demon FromSun

5 stars all around. The people are amazing their food is fantastic and the atmosphere is an all around vibe. Wish there wad delivery though it would definitely increase business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gregory Owens

The weirdest combination but everything is delicious. The peirogies are a must.

Marty

Just like grandma made

Bob Norris

We went there on saturday and they were closed for remodeling we drove down from Binghamton to get some of their delicious Pierogies.. We stopped at a bar for a drink they heard us saying we couldn't get in. We happened to be at a bar were their was an employee sitting there. He called the owner and he met us back at the store and sold us what he had left... What great people and great town... Awesome Pierogies too.... Must stop for sure...

julius prezelski

(Translated by Google) Best pierogi's around.(Original)Best pierogi's around.

Siobhan Guerin

Very friendly people.The pierogies were excellent. Call in an order & get different flavors.My husband LOVED these pieorgi's. He said they are the BEST he had,since his MOTHER made them! He is super picky. If he loves them you know they are the best. They have a customer for life.

dunst jubbone

Small hometown old world flavor. You would be doing an injustice if you dont stop in and try these perogies. You wont be disappointed!!!!

Amanda Tompkins

Authentic and delicious!

Amanda Ozehoski

Authentic and delicious!

Michele Muir

Excellent Pierogies!! Definitely will be ordering from them again!!

Loading...